5 ms·
Fear may be more dangerous than radiation
- tptacek 16y agoAccording to this (pretty amazing) UCSB lecture: http://online.kitp.ucsb.edu/online/plecture/bmonreal11/rm/flashtv.html http://online.kitp.ucsb.edu/online/plecture/bmonreal11/rm/fl... ... fear and lack of communication did grave damage at Chernobyl as well. For example: because the authorities could not get their stories straight, they were unable to advise local farmers to dispose of contaminated cow's milk,w which may have been the vector that dispersed the majority of the radioactive iodine to children in the affected area; elevated thyroid cancer among children is one of the clearly indicated aftereffects of that disaster. Fear may be rampant in Japan right now (who could blame them?) but my understanding is that they are, for the most part, doing everything right: monitoring mSv exposures, watching the food and water supply, liberally evacuating the surrounding areas. This stuff sounds simple but is almost literally the laundry list of things the Chernobyl authorities did wrong.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- joe_the_user 16y agoIndeed... The thing is that I doubt one can blame the fear evoked by radiation and things-nuclear on the anti-nuclear movement - its the opposite really. The event of the atomic bomb, the invisible and long-term qualities of radiation damage and so-forth have pretty much seared the fear of radiation into the psychies of modern people. The anti-nuclear movement is a result of this rather than a cause. But the thing is, unless there's a magic wand to make the fear go away, the anti-nuke folks have a point. Something that evokes this kind of fear in people will have a certain danger. Human beings aren't rational. In some circumstances, they are less rational than others. Sometimes just avoiding the situations where we are less rational is more cost-effective than imposing the "most rational" course of action (Especially since it is only "what would be the most rational course of action if it weren't for these unfortunate irrational behaviors").
- chc 16y agoOil and coal and nitroglycerin have caused similar destruction, yet you don't see comments like yours about them, so I find it specious to suggest that nuclear acquired its stigma honestly. At any rate, we have no better long-term option for power than nuclear AFAIK.
- sliverstorm 16y agoOf all peoples in the world, honestly I would cut the Japanese the most slack for being fearful of nuclear. We did drop two nuclear bombs on their cities, after all.
- chc 16y agoThat's a very good observation. If the fear of nuclear power came about because of the harm it had done, the Japanese should have hated it like crazy. And yet AFAIK they're generally much less cowardly than we are.
- joe_the_user 16y ago"Oil and coal and nitroglycerin have caused similar destruction, yet you don't see comments like yours about them.." Well, perhaps because my comment did not concern the very real dangers of these things but rather concerned the very real and irrational fear evoked by nuclear power. What does "honestly" mean in these circumstances??? ---> However nuclear power acquired it's stigma, the question is whether any proponents of it has a plan for removing that stigma.
- chc 16y ago"Honestly" means "without a strong effort to incite fear." People fear nuclear because they are told nuclear is scary, not because it has caused a relatively small amount of destruction.
- joe_the_user 16y ago
- kmfrk 16y agoIs the video getting hammered by traffic, or is it just me? EDIT: Works now, 50+ minutes after this comment was posted.
- Groxx 16y agoIt's crawling for me :\ Set up a burnbit, but it's taking a while: http://burnbit.com/torrent/165578/BMonreal11_PublicLecture_KITP_tv_flv http://burnbit.com/torrent/165578/BMonreal11_PublicLecture_K...
- Natsu 16y agoAt least radioactive milk isn't likely to cause harm this time. Quite a lot of people there are lactose intolerant, and they have very meticulous food safety inspectors to boot.
- jschuur 16y agoTimely chart about the relative levels of radiation dosage involved in every day living, medical procedures and exposure to nuclear power plants vs. what's harmful for you from XKCD: http://www.boingboing.net/2011/03/19/graphic-chart-showin.html http://www.boingboing.net/2011/03/19/graphic-chart-showin.ht...
- Tichy 16y agoThe chart seems to indicate that radiation 50km away from Fukushima was high enough to get into the "clearly linked to increased cancer risk" zone within 20 days. That's scary enough for me.
- jschuur 16y agoNow that I look at the chart again, I'm a little confused. It says ~3.5 micro sievert 'extra dose from one day in average town near the Fukushima plant as of March 17th, varies quite a bit' in the blue squares, but also 'one day dose (~3.6 milli sievert) at two sites 50 km NW of Fukushima on 3/16, seen again on 3/17' in the green ones. Even factoring in the variation they mention, that's a 1000x difference. I know the dosage drops off exponentially, but first example must be a lot further away than 50km, which is no longer 'near' in my book. Perhaps the latter measurements were extreme cases caused by wind patterns.
- Tichy 16y agoLies, damn lies and statistics... :-) In the green area, it says that doses where as high in some places, but much lower in other places. So presumably on average they were low, which doesn't help much if you accidentally live in one of the places where radiation is/was high.
- tptacek 16y agoCan we be more careful with the words "high" and "radiation"? Firefighters at the plant were exposed to high levels of radiation. Their exposure to damaging radiation is measured cumulatively in many hundreds or even thousands of millisieverts. We can legitimately talk about their health being endangered by high radiation. People living 50km from the plant have not been exposed to high radiation. They have, in the very worst possible interpretation of the numbers we have now, been exposed to multiple cross-country flights worth of radiation. If you want to call that "high radiation", I think in all fairness you must also advocate for flight attendants to be issued lead-lined suits.
- Tichy 16y agoMisleading title - fear affects more people and hence, by some kind of measuring, might do more damage in some cases. It doesn't imply that if you are exposed to both radiation and fear, fear does more damage. Besides, the fear is a real consequence of such disasters. As for the calculations of "only 500 people died of radiation" after Hiroshima and Nagasaki, I am not sure I trust those. All kinds of stories seem to float around (also for Chernobyl), I would like to see some serious studies determining who died of what. Since radiation might kill slowly, it could be difficult to study. Also the comparison to other toxins is plain silly and betrays the article as a propaganda piece.
- RyanMcGreal 16y ago> Besides, the fear is a real consequence of such disasters. I was thinking the same thing. Fear/anxiety/depression/despair are predictable, measurable and likely unavoidable.
- serichsen 16y agoThe basic fear may be unavoidable, but the current media coverage is ridiculously overblown (there is one casualty so far at Fukushima---due to a fallen crane, not any kind of radiation). This is fearmongering, and this _is_ avoidable.
- Tichy 16y agoMedia trying to cause a panic, news at 11.
- danenania 16y agoWhat many seem to be missing is that the potential downside of a black swan nuclear catastrophe is many orders of magnitude worse than anything that could occur at a coal plant and includes such lovely scenes as giant radioactive clouds circling the earth. Clearly the Japanese disaster has come nowhere close to this severity, but what would have happened if another larger earthquake and tsunami had struck in the midst of the containment operations? How about five more? Yes, these scenarios are extremely extremely unlikely, but if the possible results include worldwide radiation poisoning, it still could be worth considering, so I think these fears do have some rational basis. Comparisons to x-ray output or air pollution are completely missing the point.
- jerf 16y ago"if the possible results include worldwide radiation poisoning" Well, they don't. We've blown up dozens upon dozens of nuclear bombs, actual factual nuclear bombs, each of which is far far worse than even the worst possible multi-plant catastrophe that could possibly strike, and all we got was a measurable but as far as I know impact-free increase in radioactive cesium levels in people's bones. (Which is even less impressive than it sounds because it's really easy to measure radiation. "Measurable" is orders of magnitude below "dangerous".) "Some plants melt down and everybody in the world gets radiation poisoning" is not a "Black Swan", that's "The laws of physics have been rewritten" event. We can't plan for those at all. (No, please do not trot out anything about how we "may not" fully understand the science. Again, if there is some weird circumstance under which some uranium can suddenly become conscious and declare its undying hatred of the human race in magnificent Elizabethan English shortly before completely converting all its mass to energy, rendering the planet sterile in the resulting explosion, it still doesn't matter, because we can't plan for such low-probability events regardless. We understand radioactivity matters well more than we need to to run reactors.) I am all for rational analysis of the risks, but if you're including actual doomsday scenarios in your analysis, you haven't even started rational analysis yet.
- guscost 16y agoThis was my conclusion as well. It was somewhat true at Chernobyl, definitely true at Three Mile Island and it's going to be exponentially more true at Fukushima.
- pessimist 16y agoIn addition, irrational fears will devastate Japan food exports for years - Kobe beef and sushi industries better look to diversify.