5 ms·
There is a chance that some people with a history worth sharing might not be, and never be, in a position to talk. I personally think that non-compete agreemen
by simonebrunozzi 6y ago
There is a chance that some people with a history worth sharing might not be, and never be, in a position to talk.
I personally think that non-compete agreements are a strange beast. On one side, you want to avoid people "switching sides" and bring important secrets with them, possibly the reason why they've been hired by a competitor.
On the other side, you want a competitive job market, so that people would get the salary they deserve and the position they deserve.
- m0zg 6y ago> bring important secrets with them BS. That's what NDAs are for.
- myalphabet 6y agoAn NDA is practically unenforceable in this situation, which is the entire point a noncompete is a thing. Who is going to snitch on them for revealing AWS secrets to Google and violating the NDA? Another Google exec?
- m0zg 6y ago> An NDA is practically unenforceable in this situation As we shall see, the non-compete is also unenforceable in this situation, it just costs more to show that it's not. Non-competes are for the "small" people. The bigger question is, why are you carrying water for them? Enforceability of this BS is not in your interest unless you're a major shareholder, and even then non-competes are ethically dubious at best. If what's in his head is so valuable (which I'm almost certain it's not), Amazon should offer to pay him his previous comp for the duration of his non-compete, at the very least, so that he sits it out for a year. What are his options? To not ever work anywhere else again? To radically switch careers upon departure?
- em-bee 6y agodon't need a snitch. they can just assume that it happens and sue anyways. the difficult part is coming up with proof that it actually happened
- Judgmentality 6y agoSo you think it's a good idea to take legal action against someone with no proof and hope it just materializes over time? I mean, I can sue you for stealing US nuclear secrets. Now if only I had some evidence...
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> I mean, I can sue you for stealing US nuclear secrets. Now if only I had some evidence... #1 - No you can't, because only government officials can prosecute "crimes", as opposed to civil causes of action. (I think this distinction is stupid; it is not part of anyone's view of the world and it doesn't have any useful effects. But it will definitely stop you from prosecuting someone for espionage.) #2 - No, you can't, because you don't suffer any injury if em-bee steals US nuclear secrets.
- Supermancho 6y ago> So you think it's a good idea to take legal action against someone with no proof and hope it just materializes over time? Fishing expeditions are common and sometimes...legendary cough SCO-Linux dispute
- em-bee 6y agoi am not saying that doing that is always a good idea, but we are talking about amazon vs google, to competitors who have more resources than sense, so yes, absolutely.
- skinnymuch 6y agoThey aren’t suing someone random. Google would surely back the legal fees for the person if Google themselves aren’t somehow sued. What would be the point of this then?
- em-bee 6y agoof course not random, but the person switching jobs. clearly (from amazon's perspective) you can't switch to google without revealing secrets and violating your NDA, therefore we sue you.
- adrr 6y agoTrade secrets law is the stick that keeps people from sharing former company secrets. People don't want to go to jail or have a felony on their record.
- myalphabet 6y agoAgreed. I'm generally uncomfortable with noncompetes and especially with Amazon's practice of making every employee sign one. Unless it's a really special case where a team is working on something truly groundbreaking and secret, I don't see what Amazon is really afraid of if some random developer leaves and goes to a competitor. However, I do have to say that their argument as stated in this article does seem like a valid case for a noncompete. From the article: >“Virtually every day, Hall worked with Amazon’s most senior cloud executives to create and execute those plans. As a result, he was entrusted with an unusually broad view into Amazon’s cloud product plans; its priorities; and its competitive strategy.”
- sadsadsadsad 6y agonon-competes are a great way to spot a crap company from a mile away. worked at a little startup in a domain no one cared about and they made interns sign damn non-competes.
- anarazel 6y agoI think cases like this can largely be dealt with by allowing non-competes, but only as long compensation continues. Without that the power imbalances are just too extreme. EDIT: rephrased to make clear I wasn't just referring to base salary.
- tonfa 6y agoA large part of compensation is probably not in base salary, that'd be asking for like a 50% compensation cut.
- skinnymuch 6y agoI was assuming the person meant what you take home. Not just base salary.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- QuinnyPig 6y agoSomething to point out here: the guy Brian reported to is based in California, where non-competes are held to be unenforceable. If non-competes are truly as strategically necessary as Amazon says they are, why on earth would they hire such a senior executive in a jurisdiction that wouldn't uphold them?
- bsder 6y ago> non-competes are held to be unenforceable They're not completely unenforceable in California. And the company can make your life miserable by suing you because you have to hire and pay the lawyer to win the case. However, you generally have to be someone at this guy's level before non-competes can even have a chance of being enforceable. And there are lots of weird restrictions--you have to have access to data that would be damaging to the business, the lockout time needs to be relatively short, probably has to be in your contract before signing, etc.
- csunbird 6y ago> And the company can make your life miserable by suing you because you have to hire and pay the lawyer to win the case. This is the part that I can not understand about United States. How is this even allowed? It is literally bullying someone to submit, even if what you do is illegal. One of the main reasons I choose to immigrate to EU instead of US
- bsder 6y agoThe EU has it's own systemic issues. However, they are different because it is mostly based on a Napoleonic Law basis rather than Common Law basis. The problem in the US is that judges don't throw around the "this was pretty obviously frivolous and you lost so you have to pay for the court costs" card anywhere nearly enough. Another problem is that the lawyer doesn't share in the penalty even when it gets applied. A final problem is that the lawyers and judge are all buddies and see each other for lots of cases, so they're unwilling to actually slap each other when one of them is being stupid.
- brandmeyer 6y agoSales and Marketing non-competes aren't about taking company secrets with them, so much as they are about taking business relationships with them.
- MisterBastahrd 6y agoYup. When I was a recruiter, everyone was fully aware that the second we told our bosses we were taking another position was the second we would be asked to say our goodbyes and leave the premises. They definitely did not want us touching any system that contained details of clients or consultants. 17 years later, I've since been back to that office several times to visit friends without objection.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- devmunchies 6y agoI get that sales would have lots of relationships with customers, but why marketing? Doesn’t marketing’s relationship end once the lead becomes a customer? Are marketing executives an exception?
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> I personally think that non-compete agreements are a strange beast. On one side... > On the other side... Is there any single party interested in both of these goals?
- twblalock 6y ago> On one side, you want to avoid people "switching sides" and bring important secrets with them, possibly the reason why they've been hired by a competitor. Noncompetes are only about preventing talent from working for the competition. They aren't really about protecting secrets, because those are already protected. There are laws against stealing trade secrets, and NDAs in addition to those laws.
- alkibiades 6y agosee: anthony lewandowski