6 ms·
Why does it matter? The remote extensions for WSL and SSH in Visual Studio Code are extremely useful and actually work. Why should we care if they are closed so
by bmitc 6y ago
Why does it matter? The remote extensions for WSL and SSH in Visual Studio Code are extremely useful and actually work. Why should we care if they are closed source or not?
- hardwaresofton 6y agoBecause if it breaks, you can't fix it. If it reports on you, you won't know. If it decides to not allow SSHing into a server that it has blacklisted, you can't change it. I'm having trouble with the question, it sounds like it's equivalent to "why bother open sourcing useful, currently-working software X", and that's just the "why is open source good" question, right? I can somewhat understand WSL being closed source -- maybe it's got some proprietary MS stuff in there that is legally restricted, or they just don't want people using the interfaces they used? But tools like SSH grow because they're open source, not because they're closed, seems somewhat misplaced there.
- chii 6y agoI would be OK with WSL being close-sourced, as long as the interface (including programmatic interfaces) to which you interact with it are open and documented. Vendor lock-in is what i would see as bad-faith actor's action. A product being good should be the only lock-in required.
- tasubotadas 6y agoHow is that worse than not having the extension at all?
- Nullabillity 6y agoPeople don't tend to build workflows around stuff that doesn't exist.
- mekster 6y ago> Because if it breaks, you can't fix it. If it reports on you, you won't know. If it decides to not allow SSHing into a server that it has blacklisted, you can't change it. Are these the only reasons you have problem with it being closed source? I'll happily use the closed source version when MS is developing who can handle 4 digit number of issues and likely to fix issues you care about and more. If someone black lists your SSH server publicly, you seem to have a bigger problem than an extension being closed source.
- type0 6y ago> If someone black lists your SSH server publicly The bigger risk is that MS would start selling your usage without you even knowing, don't forget it's an advertising company as well.
- cameronh90 6y agoIf that were to happen, when someone inevitably found out, we'd be due compensation under the GDPR/the California law.
- hardwaresofton 6y agoI use neither Windows nor VS Code if I can avoid it -- I prefer slower progress than getting orders of magnitude more features ahead of time, for giving up control I consider fundamental, because I feel that I'm well served by the tools that are available in the open source space. I don't achieve theoretical maximum productivity without tools like VSCode and all the things they might provide and it hasn't been a problem in my career yet. It's totally fine for other people to be fine with the trade off, but for me VSCode is an incremental gain, not a huge absolute one -- maybe it will have some killer feature (or more likely some partner/employer will force it on me because it's the current zeitgeist and because of some custom plugin) that I'll need someday, but that day is not today.
- immigrantsheep 6y agoI'm curious, and please don't take this as an attack or sarcasm because it's not, it's a genuine question. Do you only use open source software? There is nothing close source on your machines?
- hardwaresofton 6y agoI do not use only open source software, there's definitely closed source software on my machine, nvidia gfx drivers for example. But I am also not a full on fanatic -- the world is gray, not black & white (for me at least). Since I am familiar with popular good open source tooling in this space, I'm surprised others who might feel the same might compromise at this particular junction, and that was my knee jerk reaction.
- immigrantsheep 6y agoI pretty much agree with you and thank you for your answer.
- hardwaresofton 6y agono worries :) I can't say I do as much for the F/OSS community as others out there do but I donate to the authors of the tools I use, the EFF, and Letsencrypt (the amount of value they deliver is insane) from time to time.
- gravity_123 6y agoSorry for being snarky but genuinely curios : Why does it matter that anything is open source in that case if the criterion is that it should work and be useful? In this case, this is equivalent to a chrome extension being closed source. Sure its better than nothing but I would actively prefer an open source one over closed source.
- bayindirh 6y agoUsing/preferring open source software has some facets. - First one is the stance. If I'm developing open source software, I want to build it on open source pillars. This ensures that I can just share the project file with the repository. - Second one is access to source. I've chatted with a guy who had a problem with Eclipse CDT. He also reported a bug. I reproduced the bug and reported to bugzilla under his report. Someone looked to it in 24 hours after my reproduction and it's fixed and pushed. I'm using Linux and open source software most of the time for the past 15 years. Open source tools gave me a better overall experience because being able to diagnose and workaround a problem makes my life much easier. If I can I'll push a patch, otherwise I'll report. I have some closed source applications inevitably and if they're a bit complex and have some bugs, I'm a sitting duck waiting for answers to my e-mails and updates which fix bugs. This doesn't happen all the time because every developer has a time budget and will rightly spend its time on higher impact bugs. If you hammer a piece of software enough, you'll probably hit a bug which is not a big impact for most people but affects you in a big way. These kind of problems turn your relationship sour with that app. This is why I use Eclipse for last 16 years or so. Yes it's not the prettiest, it's not the fastest but, it's well polished under the hood, I can access the devs and the source and it's overall stable and extremely feature rich.
- stnmtn 6y agoWhy is open source so much better at handling bug reports in your eyes than a dev team working on closed source? Both of those options are able to fix reproducable bugs within 24 hours, that's not something exclusive to OSS Plenty of open source projects just shrivel up and die without any more changes
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dependenttypes 6y ago> Why does it matter? Because it still does not support ed25519 keys and because it is closed source you can do absolutely nothing to fix it.
- xtracto 6y agoI thought the same of my CD of Soldier Of Fortune game I got when Loki games ported it to Linux (closed source). Now I can't play it. And as that, I am sure there are tons of other (more useful than a game) software that people just lost access to run and they did not have the source code to migrate it or pay someone else to do it.