7 ms·
Don’t forget public health officials outright lied and said masks don’t help reduce the spread of the disease, putatively to help conserve masks for medical per
by rayiner 6y ago
Don’t forget public health officials outright lied and said masks don’t help reduce the spread of the disease, putatively to help conserve masks for medical personnel: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/17/opinion/coronavirus-face-masks.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/17/opinion/coronavirus-face-...
> When news of a mysterious viral pneumonia linked to a market in Wuhan, China, reached the outside world in early January, one of my first reactions was to order a modest supply of masks. Just a few weeks later, there wasn’t a mask to be bought in stores, or online for a reasonable price — just widespread price gouging. Many health experts, no doubt motivated by the sensible and urgent aim of preserving the remaining masks for health care workers, started telling people that they didn’t need masks or that they wouldn’t know how to wear them.
- gentryb 6y agoWhen I first started doing volunteer health assessments and triage at our local homeless shelter, I inquired if facial hair was an issue with PPE. The organization's initial response was no. I sent them a link to the CDC guidance[1] that includes this picture regarding facial hair styles that are ok[2]. I don't think the notice at the top of said article is helpful whatsoever saying that this isn't advice for covid-19. A proper fit and seal is important. The picture could also be considered somewhat offensive to some. [1]: https://blogs.cdc.gov/niosh-science-blog/2017/11/02/noshave/ https://blogs.cdc.gov/niosh-science-blog/2017/11/02/noshave/ [2]: https://blogs.cdc.gov/niosh-science-blog/files/2017/11/FacialHairWmaskSmall.jpg https://blogs.cdc.gov/niosh-science-blog/files/2017/11/Facia...
- wutbrodo 6y agoWhat would someone find offensive about the picture?
- infinite8s 6y agoPossibly the labels under each facial style.
- mcv 6y agoOffensive or hilarious? I love the creativity behind naming each individual style. I don't think any of them are particularly offensive, are they? It's possible I'm missing some references, of course.
- catalogia 6y agoI guess the toothbrush mustache is verboten.
- goldenkey 6y agoSome people have a hitler mustache phobia.
- chipotle_coyote 6y agoIt’s my understanding — which seems to be congruent with the pages you linked? — that facial hair is an impediment to medical-grade respirators that require a tight seal to be effective. With cloth/paper masks that aren’t intended to be PPE for medical workers, though, that’s not actually what we’re going for, though, right? What we’re trying to do is curtail the spread of droplets. Beards and mustaches really won’t materially affect the effectiveness in that case. In your specific example of volunteer health assessments and triage at a homeless shelter, you probably need real honest-to-goodness PPE, and the organization’s advice was wrong. When I’m going down to the grocery store, though, a cloth mask should be sufficient — and my (admittedly short) beard is not going to keep my mask from blocking droplets from my mouth and nose, assuming it completely covers both of them.
- blub 6y agoIt's an impediment with any mask which can form some kind of seal. A surgical mask will stick to your face when you breathe in, which indicates that it does form an imperfect seal. If one's beard is creating even more space between the face and mask, it's of course going to make things worse.
- wegs 6y agoCloth masks aren't trying to form a seal. They have a few roles: 1) They capture a lot of droplets coming out of your mouth. Do you sneeze in your elbow or in someone's face? A face mask does better than an elbow, and for every breath (not just a sneeze). So does a beard for that matter; if your sneeze goes around through a beard, it's catching big droplets too. 2) You know the six-foot-guideline? They effectively increase that distance. A person talking, yelling, sneezing, etc. can carry droplets 15+ feet in a straight line. If we're both wearing masks (or face shields), it's not going in a straight line. Beards disrupt linear airflow too. 3) You can't touch your face. They don't stop virus aerosol. That's where you need a proper seal. I'm not actually sure facial hair makes any difference with a cloth mask. Surgical mask would be in between. And an N95 probably becomes a surgical.
- javagram 6y agoFWIW, I don’t think the majority of the officials intended to lie about this. It wasn’t anything that started this year or anything - they’ve had the same message about masks since as far back as the 2009 H1N1 pandemic. https://slatestarcodex.com/2020/03/23/face-masks-much-more-than-you-wanted-to-know/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2020/03/23/face-masks-much-more-t... > But the CDC has recommended against mask use. I hypothesized that the CDC was intentionally lying to us, trying to trick us into not buying masks so there would be enough for health care workers. > But that can’t be true, because the CDC and other experts came up with their no-masks policy years ago, long before there was any supply shortage. For example, during the 2009 swine flu pandemic, their website offered the following table: > [table in link] > And during the 2015 MERS epidemic, NPR said South Koreans were wrong to wear masks: > “[ . . . ] Masks can be helpful for protecting health workers from a variety of infectious diseases, including MERS… But either type of mask is less likely to do much good for the average person on the street…Wearing a mask might make people feel better. After all, MERS has killed about a third of the people known to be infected. But there are no good studies looking at how well these masks prevent MERS transmission out in the community, says Geeta Sood, an infectious disease specialist at Johns Hopkins University. “On the street or the subway, for MERS specifically, they’re probably not effective,” she says. One problem is that the masks are loose fitting, and a lot of tiny airborne particles can get in around the sides of the masks.” > So if studies generally suggest masks are effective, and the CDC wasn’t deliberately lying to us, why are they recommending against mask use?
- entee 6y agoI think you’re right. I don’t understand the general tendency of assuming malice when a combination of uncertainty about the virus, poor supply chains, and not-very-good underlying data would do just as well. It’s also unclear what “masks” meant in the initial phases. An N95 respirator? A surgical mask? A homemade cloth mask? Each of these has different uses and effects. I seriously doubt most people knew the difference in early March, I only had a vague notion. The surgeon general likely is thinking of respirators, because all MDs in hospitals get fitted for it. They know how hard it is to put it on and take it off safely, and know how critical it is for it to be a good tight fit. None of those things are going to be true for most people in early March 2020. If that’s your frame of reference, then it makes total sense that you’d recommend people not buy masks. Everyone going out and buying N95s when they’re not particularly useful to most people unless in a close confined space is a bad thing. It doesn’t actually save many lives, but does make it harder for people who need it (docs/nurses in close confined spaces, particularly with patients on respirators that aerosolize the virus). People wearing surgical or cloth masks may help some, probably mostly in enclosed spaces and mostly for exhalation rather than preventing you from inhaling a virus from someone else. Even then, it’s my understanding that the data isn’t awesome here. Many of the papers I’ve seen are under fairly odd scenarios (for example an airplane, lots of the same air, recycled all over, for hours, where the paper showed positive mask benefit). We don’t have much for bandanas, or masks that were washed 3 weeks ago, or masks that are tighter, masks that are looser. I’d wager it helps, a little, especially indoors. In other words, this shit is complicated, why assume lying when instead we could just say, “it’s complicated, they didn’t get it 100% right.”
- deanCommie 6y agoI find this a fascinating dividing line in the sand between two types of people - those that care about the principal purity of an idea (and intent) and those that care about the pragmatic implications of it (the outcome). Clearly the medical professionals were right in their interpretation of how humanity was going to react. Subjectively, this choice saved some countless amount of lives - especially if you imagine the cascade effect that could have happened if a tipping point of healthcare professionals were not able to work and save others. AND YET, the way people like you write about this on hacker news, you make it seem that the crime of lying to the population for their own good is worse than ANY possible benefit that came out of it. Now, I don't want the government of health authorities to lie to me either. But I live in a society of millions of people. The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few. I find a libertarian "fuck everyone else, it's a pandemic every man for himself" subtext beneath every post whining about the lies of the health authorities kind of appalling. I don't think this attitude contributes to the betterment of humankind, and is a regressive detremental expression of our most basic primal instincts.
- hindsightbias 6y agoWe indeed live in an era where all things are binary. But what is a thinking person supposed to think when the Surgeon General is saying don’t wear masks in a pandemic caused by airborne viri? In urban (educated) zones likely to be hotbeds for outbreaks, could the state not do a little nuance and say “hospitals need the N95s and you need a bandana” Everybody has got a bandana, but if I were to start walking into stores with one before sanctioned, someone would be calling 911. In the meantime, how many weeks go by at R 3...
- deanCommie 6y ago> could the state not do a little nuance and say “hospitals need the N95s and you need a bandana” No. Not in 2020. Not with the vast majority of the population. Nuance is dead.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago
- Tomte 6y agoThat is simply not true and an awful accusation. The last Sars or Coronavirus illnesses differed from this one, as in those cases asymptomatic people were not spreading the virus very much. So the (reasonable) assumption was that people mostly know when they are contagious and stay at home. In that scenario "community masks" (everything below FPP-2) don't matter much. When researchers found that Covid-19 is different (and that has to do with the massively higher virus load in the throat, where former similar diseases built most of the virus load in the lungs), the stance changed. That is a good thing! Learn new information, adapt your response. What's fueling conspiracy theories now is that the messaging back then centered on "we need to preserve masks for the medical community", which was a smaller component of the motivation, sure, but got mostly conflated with the real argument. I think that is because it was much easier to explain to the public and to journalists. In hindsight that was a mistake. But the conspiracy theories that health officials just flip-flopped for no reason is wrong, and it's damaging the fabric of society even more.
- ikeyany 6y agoIt is actually true. The surgeon general literally said: "Seriously people- STOP BUYING MASKS! They are NOT effective in preventing general public from catching #Coronavirus"
- Tomte 6y agoDid you read my comment at all? "which was a smaller component of the motivation, sure, but got mostly conflated with the real argument. I think that is because it was much easier to explain to the public and to journalists."
- Hnrobert42 6y agoHow do you know it was a lie? What evidence do you have?
- zingar 6y agoThere seems a fairly trivial explanation: they were talking about the effectiveness of a mask in protecting you from what you breathe in, not the communal action of everyone wearing a mask to protect other people from what you breathe out.
- blub 6y agoSurgical masks offer some limited protection for the wearer (20-80 AFAIK according to some study). Respirators offer good to very good protection for the wearer. For a long time I was under the impression that surgical masks don't really help the wearer. There are some studies showing comparable effects to an N95, but I was assuming incorrect N95 usage and I was incorrectly dismissing the benefit of even low double-digit protection. The thing that convinced me to take a closer look was an interview with the German infection specialist Peter Walger, which said that: * all masks protect the wearer to a certain degree * medical grade surgical masks clearly offer partial protection. This was a grave error, which made personnel also in clinical practice not trust the masks and wear them for protection.
- cm2187 6y agoIt doesn’t matter, the advice was for the whole population not to go buy masks.
- NicoJuicy 6y agoWho says it's lying? Modern Western world has never had a pandemic in the current globally connected world. Recommendations try to take everything in to account. It's easy now to say: just wear masks. But then, there was even a global shortage of masks for health professionals.
- bkor 6y agoThe UK did a study a few years ago on the most important threat. The #1 spot (on importance) was a pandemic and would have way more impact than the #2 threat. The report suggested various things, including e.g. masks, etc. The report was ignored. In US there's been many warnings to subsidize a strategic PPE supply and production. This was ignored. Early on (COVID-19) a US mask producer asked officials to provide money to expand production. This was ignored. It wasn't just easy to predict, it was predicted various times.
- NicoJuicy 6y agoA comet will hit the earth is also easy to predict. But we won't build something now against it because it's a long time ago.