4 ms·
San Mateo County health officer: "The third modification of the shelter in place order is being made on 6/1/20. These modifications are being made in attempt t
by Animats 6y ago
San Mateo County health officer: "The third modification of the shelter in place order is being made on 6/1/20. These modifications are being made in attempt to strike a balance. They are an attempt to find a way to increase the immunity of the population (in public health terms, this is called “herd immunity”) slowly and methodically, while minimizing premature death, with equity in mind, while not overloading the healthcare system, and minimizing economic damage. Many of these considerations work in opposite directions."[1]
The current US death rate is about 1,000 per day, and that probably won't go down much until there's a vaccine or until 70% of the US population has had the disease. This is a "bury the dead and go on" situation. The US hasn't faced one of those since WWII.
Meanwhile, don't bunch up, get good masks, and wear them. The mask supply situation has improved, although too many of them are junk. The US could probably beat this thing with enough N95 respirators.
[1] https://www.smchealth.org/health-officer-statements-and-orders https://www.smchealth.org/health-officer-statements-and-orde...
- redisman 6y agoN95 is overkill. You likely bring down the R0 below one if everyone wears just cloth masks. Less covid droplets in shared air. I still don’t see how will public transport for example resume in the next year. My bus was always packed like sardines and couldn’t fit everyone in it at the stop
- Animats 6y agoN95 protects you. Cheapo masks protect other people. That's only useful with a much higher percentage of mask usage than observed in the US. Think this through. 50% use masks, 5% are spreading the disease. Interact with 100 people over a period of time. - Masks which protect others: (0.95)^50 chance of non-exposure = 0.6%. 92% of population exposed. - Masks which protect you: 50% of population exposed. This is oversimplified, but wearing masks which protect others just doesn't do much.
- robocat 6y agoIf a common mask protects you 50%, then that is a huge win both as an individual and as a group. Saying Assuming 0% in your calculations is biased. I think your word “cheapo” is derogatory. Are people just being cheap when they don’t buy an N95 mask? Saying “cheapo” masks only protect others is an incorrect conclusion: your language is also misleading.
- Animats 6y agoAnything which leaks when you inhale doesn't protect you. If you take a deep breath and don't feel the mask pulled against your face, it's not working. There's now a huge supply of poor to useless masks available, many with phony approval markings.[1] That's most of what's being sold on Amazon. It's moderately hard to make a mask which seals tightly, doesn't offer too much resistance to breathing, and filters to N95 standards. A real N95 mask (3M 8210) is about $1.25 if you can get it. Some of the fakes are much more expensive. [1] https://www.wsj.com/articles/u-s-files-charges-against-chinese-n95-mask-maker-11591395929 https://www.wsj.com/articles/u-s-files-charges-against-chine...
- robocat 6y agoExactly. The science shows a well fitted “cheapo” mask can protect you better than a poorly fitted N95 mask. Even a surgical mask provides a little protection: if they provide 25% protection and 50% reduction in transmission, and everyone uses them, that is a huge reduction in R0. Not everyone can invest the time required to learn how to source a real N95 mask. My impression is you are trying to educate the uninformed, while sweeping under the carpet important nuances. I’m sure that isn’t your intention, but that is how it comes across to me.
- redisman 6y agoIn Asian countries with low transmission everyone use a "surgical" style mask, not N95. You almost certainly cannot convince a large number of Americans to wear a N95 as it makes breathing quite a bit harder. Especially if you have any underlying health problems or poor general health (again, that's majority of Americans).
- bjourne 6y agoAlso, don't forget to wash your hands. We don't yet know how effective masks are but we have mountains of evidence showing that hand washing works.
- robocat 6y agoMy prediction is that hand washing turns out to be unimportant. I believe the vast majority of cases are transmitted by respiration, and the recent news that super-spreaders dominate transmission will eventually find that they spread the disease by air, not by contact or fomites. I have yet to see any evidence that washing hands reduces transmission by any significant amount (say 5%).
- Rapzid 6y agoThe CDC has been saying for months they don't believe surface transmission to be much of a factor in the overall spread of the virus.
- bjourne 6y agoIf you are right then covid 19 doesn't work like any other virus that spread via droplet transmission or even like any other virus in the corona family. I.e I don't think you are right. :) There is ample evidence showing that hand washing reduces the spread for viruses that are similar to covid 19.
- robocat 6y agoI agree there is a lot of evidence that washing hands reduces the spread of viruses. However I haven’t read anything that measures the percentage of transmission of corona viruses via contact or fomites. We obviously should wash hands regularly and well. Even a 5% reduction for a simple action is really worthwhile (and hand washing is clearly critical in a healthcare setting). My main beef is that in my country I think there has been too much attention paid to hand washing and fomites, and not enough information given on enclosed spaces or mask usage. The turnaround on mask usage is a classic example of seemingly obvious misinformation. Another classic is the news clips of government employees in Asian countries spraying roads and buildings - powerful images that misdirect.
- Supermancho 6y ago> This is a "bury the dead and go on" situation. > The US hasn't faced one of those since WWII. That's just incorrect. The US has faced this every year (by percentage), since it's inception. Hundreds of thousands of people die of disease every year of cancer. Not just disease. Tens of thousands by car for most of the 20th century. The hyperbole that COVID-19 can be considered historically notable, is in the scale and type (optional, changing recommendations, etc) of social measures that have been taken.
- usaar333 6y ago1968 Hong Kong flu killed 100,000 people. (170k population adjusted)
- dehrmann 6y agoWithout a vaccine, if people keep social distancing, we'll never have herd immunity. Suppose the US gets 25,000 new cases daily. That's 9.1M per year. OG SARS immunity lasts three years, and other coronaviruses are similar. We need more like 300,000 new cases per day to have a shot at herd immunity. The big caveat is we have 25,000 reported cases per day. How many asymptomatic people are getting tested? There needs to be more antibody testing so we can answer these questions.