7 ms·
Personal brand building is another major contributor to search engine content dilution. Whenever I Google for something in hot new languages or frameworks, I h
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
Personal brand building is another major contributor to search engine content dilution.
Whenever I Google for something in hot new languages or frameworks, I have to sift through 10s of Medium articles from beginner developers who are trying to establish themselves as industry experts.
I don't want to read some junior developer's Medium post full of animated GIFs and a pseudo-tutorial that is really just entire source code files embedded as GitHub gists one file at a time. I just want to skip to the documentation and get to work.
- Jorge1o1 6y agoThe truly worrying development is when those same Medium posts start circling HN. I’m not trying to be elitist, but what I enjoy about HN is seeing truly novel and interesting content, and every “crappy” article on the front page bumps an interesting one downwards into oblivion.
- hn_check 6y agoWorrying development? HN has never been particularly enlightened in this respect, and has all of the same trends and superficial articles that emerge on the other networks. The illusion that it's some higher ground has never held true.
- city41 6y agoBased on your bio, you may be a bit biased in your assessment.
- hn_check 6y agoBiased, or simply consistent?
- _alex_ 6y agobased and orangepilled
- runawaybottle 6y agoSomeone should create that chart with ‘Lawful Good Dunning Kruger Expert’, ‘Chaotic Dunning Kruger Expert’, etc, since I need to know where I fit.
- karolisram 6y agoI’m ashamed to say that was me at some point. On top of that, those articles did nothing to further my career. All that mattered so far is my past experience, projects and how well I can (leet)code. Now if I start blogging again, it will have to be purely out of intellectual curiosity.
- wenincode 6y agoI think this is the same situation a lot of people find themselves in. I would say I'm the same. The further along I get in my career the more I find I'm interested in learning or exploring for my own good or interests, rather than some fake sense of credibility I got in the past.
- Nextgrid 6y agoI confirm this doesn't do anything for your career, or at least not as much as just focusing that time on actual, paid work. I find that in my career my resume and experience that's on it as opposed to any side-projects or attempts at writing.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoYes, however on helping the career I think the writing is like a nice little detail on the resume, a way to make it standout a bit more, I also found that in a recent interview for a project an article I had just written on SVG was naturally relevant. As a general rule talking about little articles you've written isn't going to naturally happen in the interview because the interview process is focused on past work and horrible trick questions. It has also been somewhat useful in projects where a concern with documentation has been expressed because the writing is a better example of my ability to document things than having worked on a lot of projects where you may be able to go see what we shipped but not be able to see anything of the documentation. I think of the writing as the equivalent of a side project: * it allows me to focus on something I want to learn * it helps to make what I learn stick in my head * it gives me a deadline and people who will send me emails to say how's it going with that * it works as documentation for what I've learned * it gives me a trivial amount of money for having taken the time to learn something. Basically the last article I wrote is paying for an annual Dropbox account, and a couple days worth of food for my family. It was way too much work for that to be worthwhile, but I did learn some things that will help with later stuff.
- dustingetz 6y agoWhat's interesting is that this stuff works, which means there are idiot decision makers out there eating it up, which means the whole industry is ripe for disruption by someone who can see even an inch into the fog, so lets go do that
- watwut 6y agoBut HN was never hardcore tech content? It is more of general set of articles about wide range of tech issues.
- ryan29 6y agoThere's so many bad examples online that I can't imagine trying to learn development from scratch these days.
- MattGaiser 6y agoIf it runs, it ships! It shouldn't be this way, but it frequently is.
- hn_check 6y agoThat's an interesting, albeit selfish, perspective. Experienced developers usually aren't busy writing blog posts. Nor are they engaged on HN. As the old saying goes, those who can are out doing, those who can't `teach'. This touched a nerve, but sorry it's spot on. The more faltering the career, the less certain the skills, the more likely the person has a vigorous social media and blog presence.
- hn_check 6y agoGiven the great reception this has received, let me give an example, and one of HN's great "successes" - patio11. Guy made a tiny, miserable little service that would have made more money if he worked at Walmart. He was the seer who provided day after day of front page content for this site, the "fake it till you make it" ruse in full effect. Because his product was so miserably unsuccessfully he instead put all of his effort into blog posts and "lessons" for people to follow, and the suckers lined up. People with actually successful products were just off being successful.
- Swizec 6y agoAs a programmer with some 20 years of experience who likes to write tutorials on original research and techniques — you can pry my animated gifs out of my cold dead fingers! All my life I waited for broadband to be widespread enough to write articles with rich embedded animations. And yes, sometimes they only serve the purpose of entertainment or emotional tone setting. Other times they’re actual part of the content. Gifs are great Edit: you downvote and yet I often get comments appreaciating how the gifs make my 2000 word emails feel like a quick short read.
- azeirah 6y agoGo you! I love high quality written content with a lighter tone. I find it incredibly difficult to focus on dry tests because of my ADHD.
- tpmx 6y ago> Edit: you downvote and yet I often get comments appreaciating how the gifs make my 2000 word emails feel like a quick short read. I sampled your work. It's exactly what we're talking about. I'm sure this works for you, financially and SEO-wise.. but.. maybe use 500 words and no gifs instead?
- Swizec 6y agoI often do. My point is that this stuff doesn’t have to be boring and dry. It’s okay for content to reflect having fun when you’re having fun. Even my college professors used jokes in their lectures.
- airstrike 6y ago> some junior developer's Medium post full of animated GIFs Don't forget emojis! Such a waste of time! ⌛⌛⌛
- cjonas 6y agoThis drives me crazy! I hate searching for documentation and the top results are blogs containing outdated copy and paste of the official docs with some witty text and gifs.
- aledalgrande 6y agoOr SO answers from 2011, pasting official docs.
- tmh88j 6y agoI've recently started using Express.js for a project at work, and I've never before encountered a seemingly popular framework/language with such frustrating content churned out by the community. Express's official docs have all the technical specs you could ask for, but the framework is very light weight without any structure and feels more like a library, sort of like Flask. I wanted to see what a typical app structure looks like, but just about every single "article" I found was either a copy/paste of the same app with everything crammed into one index.js file (routing, logic, db queries, etc...), or they were walls of text filled with occasional code snippets and didn't even provide a repo for reference. The community feels like it's targeting complete beginners with its simple examples, lengthy explanations of trivial tasks and extremely little coverage of architecture. My experience with Express felt like PHP 10 years ago with w3schools.
- oefrha 6y agoIn my experience this is particularly egregious when trying to compare frameworks and libraries in the JS ecosystem. The posts usually boil down to “I wrote a hello world with X and Y, here are my thoughts”, or worse, “I wrote a hello world with X, didn’t even bother to write it with Y, here are my thoughts on why X is awesome and Y sucks”, or worse still, “I wrote a hello world with X, didn’t even bother to write it with Y, here are my thoughts on why X is awesome and Y sucks, and I’ll pretend I have ten years of experience with each.”
- goostavos 6y agoAnd those exact posts bafflingly make it to the front page of Hacker News somehow -- doubly so if you can include [esoteric language] into your "My thoughts on" title. I recall an especially egregious one on Clojure where the author had used the language for all of about a week before writing up his detailed hot takes on some "cons" of the language, like needing to know some complicated thing called `let` in order too assign variables.
- Leherenn 6y agoJavaScript seems particularly bad at this, especially compared to something like C or C++ which I'm more used to.
- ragnese 6y agoUgh. I cringe every time I have an actual, non-trivial, issue or fairly technical question about whatever I'm working on lately. I remember feeling it while I was working with Swift (50 articles titled: "What is a Protocol?" Give me a break!) and lately I keep running into all kinds of bizarre, complicated behaviors with Jackson in my Kotlin project. It's a new kind of hell to sift through every article that describes the "hello, world" of writing a single data class and having Jackson magically turn it into JSON. P.S., if you can avoid mixing Jackson with Kotlin, save yourself the trouble.
- abhayb 6y agoHard same on the Kotin/Jackson sadness. Gson also has a bunch of issues. Really want to cut my code over to Moshi but haven't worked up the energy for it. Maybe we all just want to wait till Kotlin serialization is production ready?
- ragnese 6y agoDoes Gson still force you to write "beans"? In any case, this project kind of didn't need any auto-magical serialization library, but the promise was reduced boilerplate. Instead, we just got way more complex boilerplate and a damn dependency forcing me to change how I want to write my code.
- abhayb 6y agoPretty much. I'm all about data classes so the code reads just fine. Definitely less boilerplate than something like JsonObject. But using Gson means non-nullable fields can still be null if the incoming JSON doesn't have them. So you get these "impossible" NPEs. Also, this is more a complaint about the JVM type system but Gson can encode things that it can't decode into which really messes with my mental model.
- ragnese 6y agoMy experience has been that there might actually be MORE boilerplate now than when I did ad-hoc translation to/from JsonObject. inline classes straight-up don't work with Jackson, and probably never will. So for every class that has a field that is an inline class, I have to write a "builder class" that's exactly the same except replacing the inline class with the class it wraps. Also, @JsonUnwrapped doesn't work with Kotlin. And, of course, doing anything with generics is a complex nightmare with Jackson (because of JVM's type erasure). Not to mention, all these failures happen at runtime, so you don't even know your class is going to be a problem until you run the code. The whole thing just sucks and I actually miss the simplicity of translating by hand...
- itronitron 6y agoThe Medium articles are a lot more entertaining if you read them out loud with a strong 'Valley' accent.
- AlexCoventry 6y agoYes, this is happening even at the code level, resulting in a flood of modules/packages with shallow capabilities.
- dredmorbius 6y agoWriting for money and reservation of copyright are, at bottom, the ruin of literature. No one writes anything that is worth writing, unless he writes entirely for the sake of his subject. What an inestimable boon it would be, if in every branch of literature there were only a few books, but those excellent! This can never happen, as long as money is to be made by writing. It seems as though the money lay under a curse; for every author degenerates as soon as he begins to put pen to paper in any way for the sake of gain. The best works of the greatest men all come from the time when they had to write for nothing or for very little. ... There is no greater mistake than to suppose that the last work is always the more correct; that what is written later on is in every case an improvement on what was written before; and that change always means progress.... If the reader wishes to study any subject, let him beware of rushing to the newest books upon it, and confining his attention to them alone, under the notion that science is always advancing, and that the old books have been drawn upon in the writing of the new. They have been drawn upon, it is true; but how? The writer of the new book often does not understand the old books thoroughly, and yet he is unwilling to take their exact words; so he bungles them, and says in his own bad way that which has been said very much better and more clearly by the old writers, who wrote from their own lively knowledge of the subject.... It often happens that an old and excellent book is ousted by new and bad ones, which, written for money, appear with an air of great pretension and much puffing on the part of friends. In science a man tries to make his mark by bringing out something fresh. This often means nothing more than that he attacks some received theory which is quite correct, in order to make room for his own false notions. Sometimes the effort is successful for a time; and then a return is made to the old and true theory. These innovators are serious about nothing but their own precious self: it is this that they want to put forward, and the quick way of doing so, as they think, is to start a paradox. ... Hence it frequently happens that the course of science is retrogressive. -- Arthur Schopenhauer, "On Authorship" https://www.gutenberg.org/files/10714/10714-h/10714-h.htm#link2H_4_0003 https://www.gutenberg.org/files/10714/10714-h/10714-h.htm#li...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- charlysl 6y ago... and by quoting Schopenhauer's beautiful prose instead of using your own words you are following his wise advice. Montaigne said something similar when confronted as to why he quoted Plutarch so often, replying that if he believed someone had already said something in a way that he couldn't improve, why on earth would he say it in his own words? I would very much have preferred to quote the great man himself of course, for this very reason, but couldn't locate this particular passage.
- magnetowasright 6y ago> Medium post full of animated GIFs and a pseudo-tutorial... It's almost like trying to find recipes on the internet in the age of SEO and 'personal brand building'. To get to the content you want (ingredients and method), you have to scroll through a mess of unrelated, low quality, insincere blog-like content with pictures etc.. When you actually find the recipe, half the method (always the bits you don't bloody know) is interwoven into the irritating blog content or on a separate 'blog' entry page entirely. By the time you realise there's nothing of value and decide to turn back, it's too late; they've already won. You've given them a page view, interacted with the site, and maybe their ads have loaded, too. At least you can find good cookbooks in op shops! Tech books are great, but they're not always the best resource when you're curious about a tool and want something like an implementation or configuration guide, or a post-implementation review. I have random blogs to thank for clear guides with great explanations on implementing and configuring loads of things, like early versions of webpack. It seems that in only a few years, quality content has rapidly become so much harder to find amidst the mass of low quality SEO bait.