3 ms·
You said it yourself, it's not common because the price is low. Let's not devote the valuable hours of human labor towards recapturing a gas at higher efficienc
by whatshisface 6y ago
You said it yourself, it's not common because the price is low. Let's not devote the valuable hours of human labor towards recapturing a gas at higher efficiencies than necessary when there's food, family time, and other technologies that could also use that same attention.
- sandworm101 6y ago>> when there's food, family time, and other technologies that could also use that same attention. Because unlike food and family, helium is a finite resource. Once it is released into the air, it is gone. It will float up and literally into space. By protecting and conserving it now we won't have to panic once it becomes truly rare. (Not kidding about into space. The helium in those party balloons really does leave the planet.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmospheric_escape https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmospheric_escape
- whatshisface 6y agoFamily isn't an infinite resource, we will all die someday. Further, there are other finite resources, each one with its own priority.
- gruez 6y ago>Because unlike food and family, helium is a finite resource. [...] By protecting and conserving it now we won't have to panic once it becomes truly rare. Is there a need to preemptively conserve? As it becomes rarer, prices will increase which will naturally encourage conservation. At the same time, new supply will come online as they become economical due to the higher prices.
- ebg13 6y agoYou can pay in to recapture now and have it cheap enough for everything later as our needs expand, or you can fritter it away now and have it become a burden on our future expanding needs and have to pay in to recapture it then anyway. Not recapturing now sounds like a tax on future generations.
- joshstrange 6y agoNothing against you because I held the same views in the past but I think this is a very dangerous line of thinking. Not everything can be solved with "when it's scare we will come up with alternatives" or "even if the alternatives aren't efficient enough now we will improve them if we run into a scarcity issue". I hear this around energy most often. Oil is becoming more and more expensive ($$ and energy-wise) to extract (I find the best way to look at how many barrels of oil are extracted for the energy cost of 1 barrel). This number has been falling ever since the first well was tapped. We have used up all the "easy oil" and moving on to things like fracking which, environmental damage aside, does not have good returns and some of the major drill sites have adjusted their predicted yield down sharply (also fracking sites have a steep fall off where normal wells have more of a bell curve). The problem is: we have no viable substitute for oil (/gas). The world runs on oil. Solar is great but you can't put it in a tank or ship across the ocean or fly and battery tech isn't really close to closing that gap. You also can't make plastic from solar energy. Not to mention converting all our cars, trucks, etc to battery-powered is not a fast or cheap process. I highly recommend watching these videos on Energy Economics [0], Peak Cheap Oil [1], and Shale Oil [2] (aka fracking). All of this to say, I think it's dangerous to assume that we will have the time (or money) to reverse or halt the loss of non-renewable materials. Especially since if any of these start to get really expensive due to lower supply/higher demand it will kick off a number of other issues. If the price of oil spikes that affects a ton of our economy from gas, to plastics, and more. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IvqEi7XRKY8&list=PLRgTUN1zz_ofJoMx1rB6Z0EA1OwAGDRdR&index=21 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IvqEi7XRKY8&list=PLRgTUN1zz_... [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0uKihKkx0eY&list=PLRgTUN1zz_ofJoMx1rB6Z0EA1OwAGDRdR&index=22 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0uKihKkx0eY&list=PLRgTUN1zz_... [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0uKihKkx0eY&list=PLRgTUN1zz_ofJoMx1rB6Z0EA1OwAGDRdR&index=23 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0uKihKkx0eY&list=PLRgTUN1zz_...
- philipkglass 6y agoPlastics and liquid fuels can be manufactured starting from carbon dioxide and hydrogen. Hydrogen of course can be produced via the electrolysis of water with solar electricty. Carbon Recycling International already operates a commercial methanol plant for making methanol using renewable electrolytic hydrogen and carbon dioxide. This article "Process Advantages of Direct CO2 to Methanol Synthesis" has a lot of details: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fchem.2018.00446/full https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fchem.2018.0044... Methanol is a portable liquid that can be used directly as a fuel. It is also convertible to the olefins (alkenes) propylene and ethylene, the two most common plastic feedstocks. China has built millions of tons of capacity for methanol-to-olefins in the past decade, though unfortunately their input methanol is mostly produced from coal. See e.g. this recent plant that came on stream: "World’s largest single-train methanol-to-olefins plant now operating" https://www.chemengonline.com/worlds-largest-single-train-methanol-to-olefins-plant-now-operating/ https://www.chemengonline.com/worlds-largest-single-train-me... Helium is one of the very few mineral resources that is simultaneously industrially important, scarce, difficult to substitute, and exhibits poor prospects for higher sustainable terrestrial production. The other few elements in this small club are (IMO) the platinum group metals and rhenium.
- humaniania 6y agoPricing is based on current extraction cost but the potential future need is not something that can be predicted accurately. For something that could be very important, and that is used so frivolously, yes, we should probably preemptively conserve helium gas.
- BurningFrog 6y agoThis may make me sound like a jerk, and perhaps I am, but: Helium is only a finite resource at this price point. We could extract harder to get to reserves, or even make our own by fusioning hydrogen, if the price was high enough.