14 ms·
Free user space for non-graphics drivers
- SomaticPirate 6y agoThis is the part of open-source that bugs me. There is and likely always will be some level of politics in play. There seems to a precedent here and people are able to get around it by who they know or their reputation in the community. I’ve seen similar things happen in the CNCF. It’s understandable but still rubs me the wrong way.
- monocasa 6y agoOn good definition of politics is "the set of activities that are associated with making decisions in groups, or other forms of power relations between individuals, such as the distribution of resources." All collaborative projects are inherently political.
- TallGuyShort 6y agoBut that's obviously not what people mean when they criticize something as being "political". The negative connotations of the word include people having double standards based on identities or group affiliations, being disingenuous about one's actual values and motivations, abusing relationships and partnerships to further an often hidden agenda, etc.
- monocasa 6y agoCan you give examples of these hidden agendas? Most of the time I see people complaining, it's more from 'I don't understand why I have to abide by the community's values (plural) in order to submit code or otherwise get free labor out of them.'
- TallGuyShort 6y agoWell take, for instance, Microsoft's reputation of embrace, extend, extinguish. That's a perfect example. I don't think they're that bad any longer, but I used to work with a lot of Apache projects where people would vote against committers from another company that they happened to compete with, and have pretty flimsy explanations for why they didn't think they belonged in the community. Or people would refuse to engage on design discussions and then shoot down proposals - usually just on opposite sides of some corporate competition. That's beyond free labor - it's mixing corporate interests with community project governance, and it's contrary to what should be the inclusive and good-willed nature of non-profit open-source projects like that.
- bsder 6y ago> There seems to a precedent here and people are able to get around it by who they know or their reputation in the community. Well, reputation matters. Greg Kroah-Hartman let the Habana Labs stuff in over objections, but Habana actually open sourced its libraries later. Qualcomm has demonstrated repeatedly that they will never do that. And, personally, I'm kinda glad GKH cut Habana some slack. A nice open-source library now exists for that and GKH cutting Habana slack may have contributed to the process. GKH has also pointed out that he has changed his mind and wouldn't do that again. People will often do something once because they see it as an exception. Now that this kind of thing is no longer an "exception", people are looking at it differently.
- imtringued 6y agoIt works and everyone is better off in the end. So why give up now? You can always give up later.
- matheusmoreira 6y ago> There is a trend toward devices that are programmable from user space and the kernel is simply used as a conduit to carry proprietary code and data between user space and the device; only the device maker has any real view into what is actually happening inside it. They just keep coming up with new ways to take away the user's control...
- grawprog 6y agoEvery bit of control taken away from the user is just another avenue that can be used to make money from them. More than that though, it's a way to ensure only select people can be creators, the rest must be delegated to consumers. Computers as they've been for the last few decades has enabled more people to create so many things than any other time in history. For one of the first times in history, the last 30 years or so has allowed any single person on this planet, with enough money for a computer to do amazing things. But, this upsets the status quo. Businesses and I guess the 'powers' for lack of a better word, that profited off society as it was have been threatened and in many cases overturned in a short time. However, they're catching up faster than the average person and through a combination of marketing and just market control, companies are closing hardware platforms faster than what it's taken for most people to begin to utilize all this amazing technology. And it's sad, I know my kids won't have the experience of booting up an atari computer and laughing as they use their first loop to make a bunch of random things appear on their screen over and over. They won't have that experience cobbling computers together from spare parts and getting on the internet for the first time and just being amazed at all the things out there. They'll never get that feeling of really being free to do anything because they have a computer. As a kid, even when everything else was really shitty, being able to just turn on a computer and do anything, whether I was supposed to or not, just really helped me through so much and honestly, I don't know how my life would have turned out if I couldn't have done that. By the time I have kids and they're old enough, unless I buy some retro computers and set it up or something, everything they end up using or seeing will be a locked down device the sole purpose of which is to constantly track them and market to them. The internet is corporate, sanitized, and locked away in these little bubbles provided by platforms. So much has been lost and slowly but surely, the ability to just pick up a computer and create anything we want is being stripped away by hardware vendors and these huge dominating platforms that control every aspect of the computing experience and feel the need to profit off of and dictate everyone's computer use.
- NickGerleman 6y agoHow did Qualcomm get on the "naughty companies list"?
- wmf 6y agoBy never releasing open source drivers ever. (Not counting Atheros which was an acquisition.)
- the_pwner224 6y agoThat's unfortunate. I remember 7 years ago I specifically seeked out an Atheros-bassed WiFi card for my computer because of Linux support, and more recently purchased a high-end router based on OpenWRT support. And a few months ago I specifically got a $450 AMD GPU because Nvidia doesn't like free drivers. Seems like Intel is the only option left for networking... Qualcomm being closed source is the biggest issue with running good (user-respecting) software on phones, since basically every single Android has a Qualcomm processor/GPU. Samsung has some Exynos stuff but not in the USA. Only because of that, I'm looking into the PinePhone and Librem 5, which can run the mainline kernels. I realize I'm far from a normal user, but the amount of ill will these companies develop is pretty massive. Broadcom for example has been permanently associated with 'this will be a pain in the ass to get working, and will break your system on updates.' And when I was buying the motherboard / wifi card / wifi router recently I immediately disqualified anything that had a Broadcom chip or didn't specify a chip. For consumer sales, technologically aware people like us have an amplified impact because people trust us for recommendations. The AMD GPU purchase doubled to $900 because I suggested it to my brother when he needed a new one last month, even though he uses Windows. I've heard this also accredited to the rise of services like Google & GMail; 'techies' used them and their influence on family & friends was a big amplifier to help get users. So I wonder why Qualcomm and Nvidia are so hostile.
- kagenouta 6y ago> Qualcomm being closed source is the biggest issue with running good (user-respecting) software on phones, since basically every single Android has a Qualcomm processor/GPU. Actually there are kernel drivers for several Snapdragon platforms now, to the point that a Poco F1 can boot both GNU and AOSP-based systems off mainline.
- ddevault 6y agoStrong support for rejecting kernel drivers with a proprietary userspace counterpart. Totally violates the spirit of the GPL. I was NACK to this WSL driver, too, totally flies in the face of the rest of the Linux graphics stack. Companies should get in the habit of talking to the kernel early, and not just dumping a patchset over the fence and hoping we like it.
- chrisseaton 6y agoWhy do companies care if their driver is in the main kernel repository or not? All that matters is if distributions ship it, which they have to if people want their computers to work. Why don't they just say 'take it or leave it.'
- stefan_ 6y agoThe kernel has no stable interface for device drivers and in fact internal APIs routinely change. If your device driver is in the kernel repository, it will be updated by the people making changes and you get the chance to give feedback.
- chrisseaton 6y agoBut again RedHat and Canonical for example can't ship without updating the changed kernel code to match the driver, so can't they leave it to them to fix?
- bonzini 6y agoRed Hat doesn't ship any proprietary module. However, they do list a number of symbols and struct definitions as stable, unlike the upstream kernel, and preserve them for the life of a RHEL major release. This is why RHEL stays on an old kernel release and backports new features to the old release, instead of releasing new kernels.
- wmf 6y agoRed Hat and Canonical aren't suckers; if you dump an infinite maintenance burden on them they will think very hard before accepting it.
- pabs3 6y agoIt would be nice if Linux kernel devs also had some leverage they could use to increase the amount of open source firmware out there. There is precious little open source firmware and most of it is hardware specific so it becomes less useful as newer generations of hardware come out. https://wiki.debian.org/Firmware/Open https://wiki.debian.org/Firmware/Open