10 ms·
I hope one day apps like Signal will be the default for everyone, not just protesters in a time of crisis.
by matheusmoreira 6y ago
I hope one day apps like Signal will be the default for everyone, not just protesters in a time of crisis.
- senectus1 6y agowill only happen if phone manufactures ship them by default rather than the unsecure by default ones they ship atm. Sounds crazy when I say it outloud...
- RL_Quine 6y agoiMessage is end to end encrypted by default. Perhaps not as strongly, but it's a good default to begin with.
- Nextgrid 6y agoKey management is still centralized and controlled by Apple, so they can still MITM communications by messing with the key exchange. iCloud backups (enabled by default) are not end-to-end encrypted. So while it's technically E2E, in practice you get very little protection from it because it's broken by design. I still use iMessage because of the user experience, but let's not be fooled by their misleading E2E claims; it's all just marketing BS.
- ciarannolan 6y agoIf both parties disable iCloud on their phones, does Apple have any way to read messages sent via iMessage?
- frisco 6y agoWe have no idea and there’s no real way even in principle for us to know.
- Nextgrid 6y agoThey can still pull off an MITM attack by sending the MITM’s keys (pretending to be the other user’s keys) because they control they key exchange. It’s an active attack and can’t apply retroactively but within these constraints they can still do it.
- sneak 6y agoYes, if they add a wiretapping key to one or both of your key lists, which is silent/invisible to the sender.
- sfifs 6y agoWhenever key management is centralized, there is basically no security from the legal authority in the jurisdiction that the messaging vendor is located in. The vendor can always push you an MITM key. They can even show you the "correct" recipient key when you physically verify but use a different one for the actual message transfer and this would be a trivial easy to obfuscate switch in the program binary. E2E with centralized key management is primarily to protect you from casual/private threats (vendor employees, snoopers in your or your recipients network) not from legal authority.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoThe Signal Foundation is based in Mountain View and both Moxie Marlinspike and Brian Acton are US nationals... What’s stopping some US government agency from forcing them to insert code that causes the Signal app to a indicate it is behaving correctly but isn’t? And don’t say “laws”. If your threat model includes advanced persistent threats all bets are off.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- driverdan 6y agoRegardless of its security features it's Apple device only which is a deal breaker.
- loyukfai 6y agoWhatsApp isn't installed by default AFAIK, but it is one of the first apps installed by millions, if not billions, on their phones. In Korea, Taiwan and Japan, LINE became the de facto IM. In China, WeChat. But ain't sure if these are usually/always preinstalled in those markets. Cheers.
- bgee 6y agoIn Korea I think the de facto IM is Kakao, LINE is only third (after FB messager) [0][1]. [0]: https://www.statista.com/statistics/898254/south-korea-most-popular-instant-messenger/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/898254/south-korea-most-... [1]: https://www.quora.com/Which-is-the-most-popular-messaging-app-in-South-Korea https://www.quora.com/Which-is-the-most-popular-messaging-ap...
- loyukfai 6y agoThanks.
- AtHeartEngineer 6y agoIt's my default and over a few years I've pretty much converted everyone in my life except my mom
- sudofail 6y agoSame for me as well. All my friends and family have been on it for a few years now
- ViViDboarder 6y agoI convinced my parents because of full resolution images.
- nmfisher 6y agoSadly, my (65 year old) mum is the only one I managed to convince to use to Signal. All my (mid-30s) friends won't budge from WhatsApp.
- Abishek_Muthian 6y agoHaving 'Message me on Signal' as status message on WhatsApp and not replying to non-urgent messages from Whatsapp helped to covert some of my contacts.
- ClikeX 6y agoNobody gave a shit about my status to contact me elswhwere. People just open the existing conversation and never see it anyway. And most don't care, or want to switch. Whatsapp is THE messaging standard in my country. Hell, even our politicans use it for communication. "Apping" is even used by news outlets to describe communication by Whatsapp. We used to have SMS and MSN. Now it's either Whatsapp or Messenger. Depending only on the fact if you have the others phone number or not.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jwr 6y ago
- techntoke 6y agoThe Signal app experience leaves a lot to be desired compared to Telegram or Matrix.
- themodelplumber 6y agoI was about to ask about this. Signal was comparatively annoying. Can I keep using Telegram or am I postponing the inevitable? Curious.
- techntoke 6y agoAs far as I am aware E2E only works on mobile and I think Mac for Telegram, although there may be third-party apps that support it. As long as you use E2E then I believe it has a lot more active users and probably has received an equal amount of security validation, so you should be fine.
- fossuser 6y agoIs Telegram at all trustworthy? I feel like I’ve repeatedly seen on HN that they’re not a good choice for secure messaging (though I don’t remember the specifics around it). Signal and Matrix are the two options I’ve settled on. [Edit]: Looks like the main issues with Telegram are that it doesn't use end to end encryption by default and that they rolled their own encryption protocol that's likely not secure. They also used to leak a ton of metadata, but from searching around it looks like they may have made improvements. Either way seems like something to avoid when there are obviously better alternatives.
- enraged_camel 6y agoI would ditch WhatsApp in a heartbeat if Signal had a browser client.
- hcurtiss 6y agoNot in the browser, but it does have pretty decent desktop applications for most operating systems.
- atoav 6y agoIn my opinion Desktop Clients > Browser Clients when it comes to messengers. If you have more than ten tabs open it is annoying to always have to switch tabs or break out a window. Having a desktop application that remembers where you want to save stuff people send you is a plus too.
- aspenmayer 6y agoJust make a new browser profile for your browser client. It will have its own window, and different profiles prevent windows of the same browser from being collapsed onto each other on some platforms.
- plerpin 6y agoIf you really like having app-like websites, you can do that in Chrome by clicking "Create Shortcut" then click the box that says "Open In Window". Voila. It behaves like a native app, and you can embed it in your Windows taskbar with a favicon and everything. Electron isn't as safe as Chromium. Last I checked it's based off a vintage build of Chromium with some very important features like the sandbox turned off (!)
- hjek 6y agoMy opinion is the opposite, because Electron is quite heavy (which is an issue for Signal Desktop at least), and because you can't use browser containers to use multiple accounts.
- sorenjan 6y ago
- AnonC 6y agoI don't think that's a great idea until Signal stops exposing the phone number of the user to everyone else (for all the bashing that Telegram gets on cryptography, it has mechanisms to hide one's phone number and even the fact that one has a Telegram account from others).
- 0xy 6y agoAbsolutely agree. I really wish Telegram would get off the phone number system, especially after the embarrassing hack in Brazil. It's not explicitly Telegram's fault, but if your primary authentication method is insecure it's at least a little bit your fault. Phone numbers are NOT safe. I don't know why SMS MFA is even a thing, they're worse than passwords. When you use phone numbers or SMS for security, you are putting the fate of your entire company's security on an underpaid customer service rep at Verizon.
- nickik 6y agoTelegram should maybe just use proper encryption first.
- bjoli 6y agoAnd by default.
- xerxesaa 6y agoCan someone explain to me why MtProto is not considered proper encryption? Genuinely asking, not challenging. At least since version 2.0 it seems it's using AES encryption: https://core.telegram.org/mtproto/description https://core.telegram.org/mtproto/description
- nickik 6y agoBy default its not e2e encrypted and if you want to use e2e you lose lots of capability. That is simply not acceptable in a modern messenger.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]