7 ms·
How about thanking or crediting the many independent doctors and scientists (https://zenodo.org/record/3873178 https://zenodo.org/record/3873178) who identified
by walterbell 6y ago
How about thanking or crediting the many independent doctors and scientists (https://zenodo.org/record/3873178 https://zenodo.org/record/3873178) who identified the issues in Lancet's publication? Even Apple credits/pays independent researchers for finding weaknesses in Apple code.
Will countries now revert national health policy changes that were based on this questionable study? What about the families of patients who were denied early HCQ treatment based on this study? Who is liable for their denial of treatment?
James Todaro, May 29th, https://www.medicineuncensored.com/a-study-out-of-thin-air https://www.medicineuncensored.com/a-study-out-of-thin-air
> Misinformation is bad. Misinformation in medicine is worse. Misinformation from a prestigious medical journal is the worst. Herein is a detailed look at the controversial Lancet study that resulted in the World Health Organization ending worldwide clinical trials on hydroxychloroquine in order to focus on patented therapeutics.
Guardian, June 3rd, https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/jun/03/covid-19-surgisphere-who-world-health-organization-hydroxychloroquine https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/jun/03/covid-19-surgi...
> The very serious concerns being raised about the validity of the papers by Mehra et al need to be recognised and actioned urgently, and ought to bring about serious reflection on whether the quality of editorial and peer review during the pandemic has been adequate. Scientific publication must above all be rigorous and honest. In an emergency, these values are needed more than ever.
James Todaro helped to bring this questionable study to light—his website (https://www.medicineuncensored.com/ https://www.medicineuncensored.com/) and compilation of HCQ studies (https://docs.google.com/document/d/1O6Cls-Oz2ZAgJuyDbnICEGjMvQPEyM-aaXARUomR9Ww/ https://docs.google.com/document/d/1O6Cls-Oz2ZAgJuyDbnICEGjM...) may be of interest.
- terio 6y agoThe WHO already restarted studies involving hydroxychloroquine. >> Who is liable for their denial of treatment? Doctors base their treatments on the best information they have at hand. In many cases, that information turns out to be faulty. This retraction does not mean the HCQ works against COVID-19, only that this particular study is no proof that it does not work.
- tjenkinsqs 6y agoHydroxychloroquine does not repair damaged cells, but it does stop the virus from replicating (especially when used with Zinc) There are five scientific studies demonstrating this for outpatient use. https://academic.oup.com/aje/advance-article/doi/10.1093/aje/kwaa093/5847586?fbclid=IwAR1uM2zcTs_UpRT4hKcf2Vm4gHDHI8wWflHEArys-Dax4vRPcTYoZCgLi9Q https://academic.oup.com/aje/advance-article/doi/10.1093/aje...
- vernie 6y agoCome back, zinc!
- abbracadabbra 6y agoSince this is being repeated multiple times, quoting benmaraschino: One of these "studies" is a 2-page Google Doc with no real data. Another is the discredited Raoult study, which is under investigation by the journal [1]. Another study cited is also by Raoult's team. The Brazil study (ref. 29) doesn't seem to have passed peer review (yet?) and has severe methodological flaws. Like the Raoult studies, the Brazil study was not randomized, but makes no attempt to control for confounding by indication or self-selection, such as with propensity score matching or similar methods commonly used in observational studies. The last study cited isn't a study, but an article from a local news station.
- ignoramous 6y agoI believe Hydroxychroloquine is used as a prophylaxis in India and possibly other countries. Have there been any studies on that? The death toll (CFR) in India is suspiciously lower than in the European states. Could it be because they're using Hydroxychroloquine more freely [0]? Though, that hasn't been without controversy [1]. [0] https://medicalxpress.com/news/2020-05-india-hydroxychloroquine-virus.html https://medicalxpress.com/news/2020-05-india-hydroxychloroqu... [1] https://science.thewire.in/health/covid-19-indian-council-of-medical-research-raman-gangakhedkar-hydroxychloroquine-prophylaxis-clinical-equipoise/ https://science.thewire.in/health/covid-19-indian-council-of...
- sjg007 6y agoThe university of Minnesota has a clinical trial out showing no early benefit of HCQ treatment.
- adventured 6y ago> The university of Minnesota has a clinical trial out showing no early benefit of HCQ treatment. They have yet to publish the results on whether it benefits patients during the early onset of symptoms. [1] Is hydroxychloroquine paired with zinc in the two studies? That has been the central claim of people supporting hydroxychloroquine this entire time and so far I've yet to see them used together in an early treatment / preventative study in the US (perhaps they've done so in Europe or China?). [1] "A separate U trial is examining whether it benefits patients after early onset of symptoms, but results haven’t been published." https://www.startribune.com/anti-malaria-drug-in-u-of-m-trial-does-little-to-stop-covid-19/570989342/ https://www.startribune.com/anti-malaria-drug-in-u-of-m-tria...
- belltaco 6y ago>Is hydroxychloroquine paired with zinc in the two studies? That has been the central claim of people supporting hydroxychloroquine this entire time Citation needed. Counter evidence: The "paper" that was popular among right wing folks stating that HCQ was a safe and effective treatment for Covid. Zero mentions of zinc. https://github.com/covidtrial/info/raw/master/An%20Effective%20Treatment%20for%20Coronavirus%20(COVID-19).pdf https://github.com/covidtrial/info/raw/master/An%20Effective... Full transcript of Trump pushing CQ/HCQ, Ctrl+F zinc = 0 results. https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefings-statements/remarks-president-trump-vice-president-pence-members-coronavirus-task-force-press-briefing-6/ https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefings-statements/remarks-pres... Smells like goalpost moving to me.
- ponker 6y agoI think by “people” he meant people qualified to discuss medicine.
- 6y ago
- xenophonf 6y agoWe haven't gone from "BLOCK" to "ALLOW". Instead, we're back to "DUNNO". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phases_of_clinical_research https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phases_of_clinical_research
- bb88 6y agoSo "dunno" is not a good enough reason to allow use of potentially damaging drugs. So we're still at "block".
- xenophonf 6y agoPretty much. Evidence-based medicine doesn't take its cues from Cave Johnson and just spitball stuff when people's lives are at stake. Plenty of promising drugs have horrible side effects, and it takes a lot of careful work to make sure they can be used safely to treat people. Thalidomide would be an excellent example of such a drug, which can cause excessive clotting and severe birth defects but also treats leprosy and certain cancers. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thalidomide https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thalidomide
- tjenkinsqs 6y agoI personally do not like drugs, but as far drugs goes Hydroxychloroquine is quite safe. Hydroxychloroquine has been used since 1958 by millions of people. It is relatively safely (as much as any drug is safe) used for Malaria, Lupus and Arthritis. Some Lupus users have used it for decades. The CDC on their web site state it is safe for young, old and pregnant. https://www.cdc.gov/malaria/resources/pdf/fsp/drugs/hydroxychloroquine.pdf https://www.cdc.gov/malaria/resources/pdf/fsp/drugs/hydroxyc...
- giarc 6y agoIt's safe for people with those conditions, we don't know if it's safe for people in respiratory distress. Take thalidomide for example. Great drug for treating nausea, but not great when that person is also pregnant. By not studying it in this group, it resulted in many people born with birth defects.
- toiletfuneral 6y agoits very possible the study can be wrong and HCQ still isn't an effective treatment, not sure you should read this news as an endorsement
- MilnerRoute 6y agoThis is just one of many studies which has not found medical benefits for hydroxycholoroquine. https://rheumatology.medicinematters.com/covid-19/hydroxychloroquine/research-round-up-hydroxychloroquine-covid-19/17990324 https://rheumatology.medicinematters.com/covid-19/hydroxychl...
- underdown 6y agoNo medical benefit ... in the treatment of covid-19.
- slickrick216 6y agoInteresting timing given what’s going on in the world. This would have got more coverage 2 weeks ago.
- thaumaturgy 6y agoPlease don't fall for this. An article over at ScienceMag [1] states, > ...James Watson, a statistician at Mahidol who on 28 May published an open letter to the journal and the study’s co-authors, signed by more than 200 clinicians and researchers, that calls for the release of Surgisphere’s hospital-level data, an independent validation of the results, and publication of the peer review comments that led to the Lancet publication. This blogger's article is dated May 29. Given that the underlying theme of this blog is "everyone's lying to you about covid19, it's actually not that big of a deal", I doubt James Todaro was as instrumental in The Lancet's retraction as the letter from 200 other researchers the day before. It will be quite bad if it turns out that the WHO reacted to a study published in The Lancet that turns out to be fraudulent or grossly erroneous. We don't need to make the situation even worse by lending undue credit to other sources of disinformation. [1]: https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2020/06/mysterious-company-s-coronavirus-papers-top-medical-journals-may-be-unraveling https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2020/06/mysterious-company-s...
- walterbell 6y agoTodaro and others have been collating HCQ studies for weeks, as visible on Twitter. It's not a competition for credit, except against misleading studies. You can review the Google doc above, which is more than a month old. It contains a list of HCQ studies which include components likely to increase success: early treatment in time to slow viral replication with a combination of HCQ and zinc. These successful HCQ studies, full of reports of lives saved, are worthy of attention.
- thaumaturgy 6y agoMan, I'd love to argue with you on this. I'd love to do a decent job of pointing out that you're moving the discussion away from this potentially fraudulent paper published by The Lancet and towards the broader argument over HCQ. I'd love to spend the time to comprehensively review some dude's Google Doc that, at a random sampling, appears to contain non-peer-reviewed preprints and observational studies from discredited authors and not a single one of the much better studies that are critical of HCQ. I'd like to ask you why you're so readily willing to trust this particular treatment of this subject given the complete lack of contraindicating evidence. But, I'm completely exhausted. Between arguing against racists and arguing against bad politics during a global health epidemic and trying to catch and counter some of the relentless stream of disinformation on this and so many other subjects -- and all without any intervention at all from any of the social media platforms that enable all of this, including HN -- I'm tired, and discouraged, and dispirited. I need to go away for a while. I hope someone else has the time and energy to curb stomp random dude's 25 page Google Doc minutes before someone else cites 25 pages of different BS.
- phonon 6y agoTry May 24th, https://statmodeling.stat.columbia.edu/2020/05/24/doubts-about-that-article-claiming-that-hydroxychloroquine-chloroquine-is-killing-people/ https://statmodeling.stat.columbia.edu/2020/05/24/doubts-abo...