7 ms·
Purely as a thought experiment, if we suspended mortgage repayments for N months and rental payments for N months, what bad (or good) effects might we see?
by rwmj 6y ago
Purely as a thought experiment, if we suspended mortgage repayments for N months and rental payments for N months, what bad (or good) effects might we see?
- christkv 6y agoA collapse of the banks I suspect and having to rescue them again.
- formercoder 6y agoBanks shouldn’t have a ton of this stuff on their balance sheets because of post ‘08 changes. The more likely parties to be damaged are asset managers.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Banks shouldn’t have a ton of this stuff on their balance sheets I don't understand what you mean - banks issue millions and millions of mortages.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoBut they don't keep the mortgages. They sell most or all of them.
- formercoder 6y agoCorrect, they package them up in CDOs and sell them off.
- Ididntdothis 6y agoThis would make sense to me. Why are some businesses being shut down and have to deal with income losses and others like landlords can keep going and demand their income? This seems fundamentally unfair to me.
- freeone3000 6y agoAh, but comrade, paying rent itself is inherently unfair. It allows for profit off merely having bought something sooner than another had a chance to. If the rent stops now, why should the rent start back up?
- Ididntdothis 6y agoIt should start up when the renter is not forbidden by government to make money to pay rent.
- airza 6y agoI guess you're being sarcastic, but what value is being provided to society by having landlords rent houses out to people who would rather buy them?
- viscanti 6y agoThe opportunity cost of the downpayment (and also the fact that lots of people wouldn't have the money for a down payment anyway). Generally the returns from property investing are relatively low compared to other investments.
- nradov 6y agoAnyone who wants to buy a rental house is free to do so. Just make an unsolicited purchase offer to the landlord for more than the net present value of all expected future rental income. Most landlords are willing to sell their properties, even when they're not currently listed on the market.
- airza 6y agoI'm sure the landlord is getting a lot of value from their rental property, but why is this configuration of property ownership better for society?
- 6y ago
- willcipriano 6y agoIt would probably be hard to find a rental during that period, as legally you wouldn't have to pay to occupy the space. Though landlords might be cash strapped enough to let you move in to get the down payment.
- kimjongtrill 6y agoAs long as the people that did pay get theirs back.. that’s cool.
- mkolodny 6y agoPeople who make a living by renting out a room/floor would need government assistance to survive.
- monocasa 6y agoYes, most places I've seen suspending rent and mortgage are also giving continuing monetary assistance as well.
- rwmj 6y agoWhy? They wouldn't be paying rent to their landlords either.
- bosie 6y agobecause they aren't running at cost/deficit but make actual money (profits). those would now be gone too.
- jdm2212 6y agoThe whole banking system would collapse like in 2007-2008 because "everyone stops paying mortgages all at once" is basically what happened then. Renters stop paying their rent so landlords go broke. Landlords stop paying their mortgages. Mortgage-backed securities go into default. Anyone with lots of exposure to mortgage-backed securities folds. Their counterparties in all sorts of financial arrangements can't collect (insurance, bonds, you name it). Credit markets dry up, and all the Main Street businesses that are rolling over some of their debt find they can't borrow, so they file for bankruptcy. Normally, they'd take out loans to make it through bankruptcy and restructure... but no loans are available, so they liquidate. EDIT: worth noting that this is less likely now than in '07-'08 because the Federal Reserve has been buying up bonds like crazy (that basically means financial institutions, governments and businesses are often able to get unlimited cheap credit) but if they scaled that back or stopped doing it, things are already so bad there would've been a credit crisis in March or April without a national rent/mortgage freeze. So imagine how much worse it would be with one.
- 5ociety 6y agoIt kind of sounds like we need a different money system?
- 5ociety 6y agoand whose better at designing systems than you and me?
- Ididntdothis 6y agoWe may do better than the bankers who like to design fragile systems as long as they can make boatloads of money :)
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoUnless you're an expert at designing systems as complicated as the entire economy, maybe a lot of people.
- UncleOxidant 6y agoUltimately it will damage the banks that hold the mortgages.
- ameister14 6y agoYou'd see a devaluing of the underlying property, so you'd be upside down on your mortgage. Property owners would stop taking care of buildings in terms of rentals, so maintenance would be a significant issue. There are a lot of bank loans using a real estate asset as collateral - those would now be significantly riskier for the banks to hold, so new loans would probably stall and/or become more restrictive, slowing growth. Municipal services would start to take a hit next, since a lot of the property taxes go to things like schools and waste disposal. On the flip side, people not paying their rent would have more money in their bank accounts to cover an unforeseen medical bill. I doubt retail would increase by that much if quarantining was still in place, though.
- MobileVet 6y agoI asked Paul Krugman this on Twitter and he didn’t reply unfortunately. Yes to halting the entire chain (mortgage included)but maintaining the interest.
- fortran77 6y agoThere's still property tax. I'm a commercial landlord with no mortgage, but a hefty property tax bill.