14 ms·
Show HN: Virus Cafe – Make a friend in 2 minutes
- feross 6y agoHey folks! I built Virus Cafe to help you make a friend in 2 minutes! My goal is to help people stuck indoors because of COVID-19 (or police curfews) to make meaningful connections with strangers. Here's how it works: 1. You are matched with a random partner for a video chat 2. You're given a deep question to discuss. You have 2 minutes! 3. The only rule is: no small talk! Small talk is the worst and I'm on a mission to eradicate it. I've expertly crafted over 200 questions designed to stimulate good conversation and skip past the boring introductions. Here are a few samples: - When in your life have you been the happiest? - What would you be willing to die for? - What is the biggest lie you’ve told without getting caught? - What is a belief you had as a child that you no longer have? - What human emotion do you fear the most? - If a family member murdered someone, would you report them to the police? - What absolutely excites you right now? I hope you use Virus Cafe to meet a new friend and make a deep connection today. Feross
- rohan1024 6y agoHey here's one question that usually starts interesting discussion. You can probably add it to your list: - What would you do if you did not have to work for money?
- feross 6y agoThat's a great question. Added it.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y ago> Small talk is the worst and I'm on a mission to eradicate it. To me small talk is the lubricant that makes conversations flow smooth with strangers. You can hear inflections and humor and irony all in a relatively safe, unemotional topic. Also, since your philosophical side is not needed, your emotional intelligence can be more engaged. For example, just by seeing how someone responds to a comment on the weather, you can learn about the person and maybe even find a shared bond(even if it is one as small as you both dislike hot, humid weather). Finally, especially needed in this divided time, it serves to humanize one to the other. So, I guess I am a fan of small talk.
- throwaway391003 6y agoYa very well put. It's very awkward to jump into big questions with a stranger. That's the point of small talk.
- johnfn 6y agoThis is really well put. I've also noticed that, while not really relevant here, small talk is a good way to gauge people's interest in having a conversation at all. If you dive right into big topics like hopes and dreams right off the bat, the other person might not be engaged, but if you ease your way in with small talk and receive a lot of energy back, that can be a positive signal to get to the deeper stuff.
- inakarmacoma 6y agoOr the person is interested in deep conversations but was turned off by the small talk?
- Closi 6y agoCounterpoint: Most smalltalk topics actually get people to give an almost pre-rehearsed response. For example if someone asks “What do you do for a living?” I will give the same answer I have given 1000 times. Ill ask them and they will do the same. There is nothing unique here. Each to their own though.
- serf 6y ago> Counterpoint: Most smalltalk topics actually get people to give an almost pre-rehearsed response. yeah, but you're supposed to then extrapolate on the other persons' pre-rehearsed response in order to escalate the conversation into something that flows without effort. "What do you do for a living?" "Mergers and Acquisitions." "Oh. I have a friend that does nearly the same thing. They told me this anecdote, does that kind of thing ever happen to you?" "Oh, as a matter of fact.." Without small talk there is no sharing of useless trivia by which to use as a jumping off point into real conversation, unless there was some introduction or motivation behind the meeting, anyway.
- kstenerud 6y agoThose aren't deep questions; they're deeply personal questions, and something not appropriate to talk about with complete strangers. I strongly recommend you re-evaluate your question set. Personal questions are dangerous with the wrong kind of person.
- whotheffknows 6y agoI agree. As a woman working as a major minority in STEM as a software developer, and seeing this being advertised on HN means I'll probably be paired with a male if I used it. Not only are these not appropriate, it's the kind of information you could give to a dangerous man to give them all the cards to know your deepest weaknesses and manipulate you. That trust has to be earned, and it turns vulnerable people into potential targets. It almost makes me feel like you've never considered how awkward these questions could be for anyone but particularly off putting to any woman whose parents taught them how to be safe when talking to strangers online since they were little girls. Like the AI app thing where two young men advertised and bragged you could snap someone's pictures and get their asl is an absolutely horrifying prospect for any women to consider having available to anyone on the streets. Sometimes these types of concepts seem so poorly thought out and ignorant especially in light of the goals being centered around the deep and social nature of human beings, I have to often attirbute this to childish ignorance in my head and remember the feds have another thing they need to regulate on the list. Being inclusive and considering abused of people who are not white males in power is literally the center of attention for most of the world right now. Take it to heart in your everyday life. There are plenty of other things you can discuss, even concept building ideas that don't center around personal ancedotes.
- adreamingsoul 6y agoThank you for sharing your perspective.
- feross 6y agoThanks for sharing your opinion. I think you raise a great point that women are more likely to be targets of harassment than men on the internet. I feel strongly that women should feel safe on the internet. If you try the app right now, you'll find many women from Saudi Arabia currently using it (a Saudi celebrity tweeted it yesterday). I noticed several women who were using the app for hours but hiding their camera with a finger. Based on that user behavior, I'm building an audio-only option so women who feel the way you do will hopefully feel more comfortable.
- AlexMuir 6y agoThis is awesome. I ignored all the questions. Just make it a clean chatroulette to have a coffee with random developers. Secure it with a programming question.
- chadwittman 6y agoThis is a great idea.
- GuB-42 6y agoSince your service is essentially chatroulette, did you do something special to keep the penises out?
- Grustaf 6y agoGoing straight to the point without smalltalk feels very weird, it’s during smalltalk that you get to know each other.
- jagged-chisel 6y agoHow long does it typically take for both parties to agree to the same question? Some of this stuff I'm not discussing with a stranger that might become a 'friend.'
- iamnotcorrect 6y agofunny.. all these questions are small talk to me :) not a criticism at all by the way! i like the concept and interested to see how it works out (plus thanks in general for thinking of thing people may like and putting the effort into creating them!). Just that i would describe it as small talk with interesting queues :) - note IMHO small talk is very important and is a great way of learning about people and the world without getting into a fight :D.. this is just small talk that is less likely to be boring :D *edit: the assumption being that as there is no trust between participants - they will answer these questions in a certain surface only way. the only thing that would make these questions not small talk is if they were part of a wider conversation.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Here are a few samples: These seem like extremely controversial, divisive topics. Not the kind of thing to bring up with someone you don’t know well, and the opposite of a good way to make a friend.
- tgv 6y agoI suppose the thought was: if two can speak about such a topic, they'll get along well. No idea if that was the case, nor about its merit.
- astura 6y agoIf you want to have "deep" conversations with a complete stranger without even getting an introduction first, then you're really not interested in a conversation, you're just interested in presenting. Which is fine, just starting a YouTube channel is a better (and more honest) way to accomplish it.
- scandox 6y agoSmall talk is the foreplay of human discourse. Frankly most people's inconsequential talk is more interesting to me than their views on Big Topics where we mostly adhere to some tribal imperative.
- soneca 6y agoI like “small talk” a lot as a great way to know people. I disagree that these questions will make more meaningful conversations. Every time I see one of these lists of ”meaningful” questions, from people who ”hate” small talk, they fit in one of these categories: it is virtue signaling, to show they are supposed to be more profound human beings than the average person; or it signalizes intelligence, show they can think of smarter things than the regular person; or they are intrusive questions, very personal questions that I would like to answer only to real friends, not strangers, and I would hate being asked that. I would much rather engage with a simple person that asks those regular questions to start a conversation and it is there to actually talk to you, not put up a show to impress you on how profound and cool they are.
- tasogare 6y agoI agree. Given the description of the service, the topic could have been named "Show HN: Chatroulette Clone for Sapiosexuals" which would have been more informative.
- esperent 6y ago> Small talk is the worst and I'm on a mission to eradicate it. Small talk is like two computers establishing a connection across a noisy network. Before you send real data, you need to establish some things like: * Whether the other person speaks your language * What their name is * Whether they are feeling ok * Whether they are interested in a conversation * Whether they are someone you want to invest time and effort in talking to * What (if any) common interests you share ... And so on. When you use a platform like Virus Cafe to establish a connection with another person, you can bypass all of that. But in normal life, small talk is important.
- GuB-42 6y agoDid you consider these questions? https://www.gwern.net/docs/psychology/okcupid/thebestquestionsforafirstdate.html https://www.gwern.net/docs/psychology/okcupid/thebestquestio... These questions are selected as particularly relevant to dating while being innocuous. Even if Virus Cafe is not a dating site but I guess they can still be great conversation starters. They are: Proxy for "Will my date have sex on the first date?" - Do you like the taste of beer? Proxy for "Do my date and I have long-term potential?" - Do you like horror movies? - Have you ever traveled around another country alone? - Wouldn't it be fun to chuck it all and go live on a sailboat? Proxy for "Do my date and I have the same politics?" - Do you prefer the people in your life to be simple or complex? Proxy for "Is my date religious?" - Do spelling and grammar mistakes annoy you?
- TurkishPoptart 6y agoI wonder what spelling and grammar mistakes have to do with religiosity!
- GuB-42 6y agoApparently nothing, but there is a correlation. Here is what the article has to say about it. If your date answers 'no'—i.e. is okay with bad grammar and spelling—the odds of him or her being at least moderately religious is slightly better than 2:1. As someone who is not himself a believer, I found it rather heartening that tolerance, even on something trivial like this, correlated with belief in God, although I should've figured out that religious people are okay with small mistakes. Next to intelligent design, what's a couple typos? It's also nice when two completely independent datasets corroborate each other. Last summer, we analyzed the profile text of half a million user profiles, comparing religion and writing-level. For every one of the faith-based belief systems listed, the people who were the least serious wrote at the highest level.
- smabie 6y agoMore likely, it's that there's a correlation between low intelligence and religiosity (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religiosity_and_intelligence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religiosity_and_intelligence). And, of course ,there's a correlation with bad spelling and low intelligence. So a religious person is more likely to be okay with spelling mistakes because they themselves are likely to not be good spellers, because they are likely to be less intelligent. It has nothing to do with religious people being okay with small mistakes.
- shoes_for_thee 6y agoJFC, please don't answer these questions to strangers who almost certainly do not have your interests at heart. What is the biggest lie you've told without getting caught? Holy shit.
- Zobody 6y agoOne important suggestion I'd like to offer: prevent the site from being closed mid conversation with an alert (like, a confirmation dialog box), as sometimes a simple missclick can rudely end the conversation ;( (I'm sorry monirz)
- feross 6y agoGood idea. Will add it!
- zebraflask 6y agoThis seems inspired by r/askreddit, but without the low impact anonymity that makes that sub work.
- whatwhyhow 6y agoIt's more like 2020's omegle
- nicc 6y agoGives out pretty negative feelings to me. A sad emojii with a face mask is pretty depressing, and even worse if you see the mask as political. Black lives matter is destroying cities across the USA. I'm sure it's just me, but I wonder if anyone else sees this?
- feross 6y agoSorry that you don't like it. Can't please everyone. Lots of people have told me they've had fun meeting new people from around the world. Regarding the hashtag, I put it there because I'm against police brutality and I'm horrified by what the police are doing. Looters should be arrested and prosecuted, for sure. But police have a monopoly on the use of violence and must be held to a higher standard.
- nicc 6y agoI didn't write I don't like it, mostly think being more neutral and removing political statements might be better. As for the Police, that was one guy. What percentage of cops kill innocent people, vs. save you from the bad guys (I was saved by cops twice, for instance). Also looks like the guy is going to be held at a higher standard and will get a harsh punishment. Is looting and burning down stores that in many cases represent people's life savings the correct way to solve the problem? As you see, we could be talking about your chat, and we're talking about violence and depressing things like a store owner saving money for 20 years only to see it burn down by Antifa.
- Garlef 6y agoI think it is easy to misread the implied context of your statement as protestors = looters = antifa. Which is of course not true. These are three seperate groups of people and the only subset relation that holds true (using a definition of `protestors` as simply participants) is protestors > looters. And I guess they constitute only a small percentage. Additionally: Not everyone who would signify themselves as part of the antifa is a looter and not every looter is part of the antifa. I would not jump to any conlusion about the ratios `looters/(antifa looters)` and `antifa/(antifa looters)`. (Note: They are not inverse). Overall, my impression is that the antifa plays only a minor role and was mostly brought up by T. to derail the public discussion.
- laurensr 6y agoAs this is HN, could you elaborate on the technologies you used to build this platform?
- feross 6y agoSure thing. The video and voice chat is powered by WebRTC. The getUserMedia API allows a browser to access the webcam and microphone of the device. I used my own simple-peer (https://github.com/feross/simple-peer https://github.com/feross/simple-peer) library to make WebRTC a bit easier to work with. The server is Node.js. I'm using Next.js for the first time on this project. I usually use a custom Express server for my projects. I'm a fan of several of Next.js's decisions -- it feels really nice to use, if a bit limiting sometimes. I use the 'ws' package (https://github.com/websockets/ws https://github.com/websockets/ws) to implement a WebSocket server which is used to help the peers get connected over WebRTC. Once peers are connected, all video and video is transferred directly in a peer-to-peer fashion. Except sometimes the connection can't be established, so to improve reliability of WebRTC you need to set up a TURN relay server for those situations. I used coturn (https://github.com/coturn/coturn https://github.com/coturn/coturn) for that. Lastly, I used Chakra UI (https://chakra-ui.com/ https://chakra-ui.com/) as my React component library. Really happy with how the easy the app has been to build. The most difficult part was getting it to work on Safari for iOS. I spent about 50% of the effort working around various bugs in the Safari media stack. https://twitter.com/feross/status/1263544033135038464 https://twitter.com/feross/status/1263544033135038464 Hope this was informative!
- putsjoe 6y agoThat's great thanks, really informative. May I ask where your hosting this all?
- feross 6y agoI'm a huge fan of Linode. I've been a customer for nearly 10 years. I wrote an review a long time ago here: https://feross.org/linode-vps-hosting-review/ https://feross.org/linode-vps-hosting-review/
- Scarbutt 6y agoThe "click the emojis" doesn't increase in difficulty ;) Are the 200 questions publicly visible somehwere?
- feross 6y agoThey're in a JSON file in the repo at the moment. I'll open source them later today when I have a spare moment: https://github.com/feross https://github.com/feross
- wenbo 6y agoI just wanted to start by saying thanks so much for your open source contributions. I've been using simple-peer in a few side projects and it's been a breeze. Are you planning on eventually open sourcing Virus Cafe on top of releasing the questions?
- feross 6y agoYou are very welcome. simple-peer has been massively improved by other OSS contributors, and I am not an expert on the video/voice aspects of it as much as the data channel, so it's actually really great that I open sourced it. It enabled me to build Virus Cafe super quickly. The power of open source!
- tdrgabi 6y agoI'm also interested in the questions. Couldn't find the file (or the repo for virus cafe) in the repo list
- AbraKdabra 6y agoIs there a chance for chat instead of video call? I like the idea but I'm not exposing myself in video. I know it "ruins" the experience but each one to its own.
- feross 6y agoI understand how you feel but I don't think anything can replace looking into another human's eyes.
- mdni007 6y agosounds gross
- shkkmo 6y agoWell, video certainly hasn't replaced it. Maybe one day we will all have devices with the multiple cameras and the signal processing to allow actual eye contact over a video call.
- rohan1024 6y agoNa I don't think any tech can replace face to face interaction.
- imtringued 6y agoThe same way no face to face interaction can replace the ability to write messages to people on the other side of the planet. Inability of substitution does not make something superior or inferior.
- deadwing0 6y agohttps://youtu.be/2AecAXinars https://youtu.be/2AecAXinars
- starpilot 6y agoAre you good at making friends yourself? This fake empathy "I understand you" then ignoring their view is quiet alienating. People have been giving you realistic feedback in this thread (Virus Cafe is a terrible name and seems hyperfocused on a trend that is on its way out) and you've just been blowing them off.
- swyx 6y agotried matching with 3 people, all took one look at my face and peaced lol nice app though! love the small touches with the emojis and sounds!
- feross 6y agoThat's a bummer! I think I'll implement a penalty for leaving in the middle of a chat. Will auto-ban folks who do that too much. Thoughts?
- swyx 6y agois what it is... chatroulette and co all have similar behavior. too many rules and you lose users.
- feross 6y agoI'm okay with losing users. I only want users who enjoy long discussions about deep questions. That's the target audience of the app. If you have no standards, you devolve into ChatRoulette. More users, but very little value.
- ReactiveJelly 6y agoI'm glad you're aiming for a different niche because I was gonna say the exact same thing. I had one awkward conversation and then one person quit in the first second. Omegle was the same for text. Either I'd quit when I saw "ASL?" or they'd quit when I replied.
- tempestn 6y agoI miss the old ICQ random chats. Found a bunch of people on there up for real conversation, and there was very little of the empty 'ASL??' nonsense back then.
- Raed667 6y agoMaybe not ban right away, but how about longer waiting times between calls?
- lxe 6y agoThis sounds anxiety-inducing.
- VWWHFSfQ 6y agonot everyone is terrified of social interaction
- ReactiveJelly 6y agoNot all social interaction is this terrifying.
- lxe 6y ago*To me, this sounds anxiety-inducing
- jcun4128 6y agoHa sadly I feel the same, when I was younger I could care less what happened, now too critical "why didn't they like me?" etc etc ah well
- smabie 6y agoThem maybe you should do it. Exposure therapy really does work wonders.
- roastedjalapeno 6y agoThe name does not inspire enough confidence for me to click on the link.
- blackflame7000 6y agoUsing the word virus on the internet is like using the word bomb in the airport. It's not a good decision.
- xwdv 6y agoIt’s a great decision, it filters out some people you probably wouldn’t care to talk to.
- feross 6y agoIt's safe, I promise. The browser sandbox is quite good. :)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- zumachase 6y agoHi feross! I presume this uses simple peer? We’re using simple peer in our app (currently on the front page as well). Thanks so much for your work!
- feross 6y agoYes, this uses simple-peer. I'm glad that it was useful for you! If it's a for-profit app, please consider supporting me on GitHub Sponsors: https://github.com/sponsors/feross https://github.com/sponsors/feross
- zumachase 6y agoWe rushed to launch this without any paid features, but we're planning on doing so. The moment we have a revenue stream, I'll be supporting you.
- fortran77 6y agoYour contact page is broken on your website and email to the address listed bounces. How can we contact you?
- zumachase 6y agochase@zumaltd.com / chase@fraclog.co Or the hello@ address should be fixed now
- starpilot 6y agoPlease tell me one of the topics is abortion. Always a good icebreaker. Virus cafe? Seriously, will my computer catch something using this site?
- feross 6y agoNo abortion questions, but I do have a 3-4 absurd questions in rotation, just to spice things up :) - Would you rather have someone secretly give you LSD on a random day once every 6 months or make everyone in the world take LSD all at the same time once every 5 years? - Would you rather have taste buds on your butthole or poop through your mouth? - Would you rather have sex with Donald Trump in secret, or not have sex with him but everyone thinks you did?
- O_H_E 6y agoFirst one is really nice, second is fine. Are you creating these yourself or have some source?
- noname120 6y agoI met a German girl on this app. We had a great time and right when we were exchanging numbers the server restarted. Please give a lengthier grace period. :(
- feross 6y agoI'm really sorry about that. :( I'm furiously deploying bug fixes!
- aurbano 6y agoWhen the time is over you should let people exchange contact info if they want - and if both say yes then they see it or something like that.
- feross 6y agoI’m going to add this. It’s the #1 request people have asked for
- quickthrower2 6y agoAnd that sir ... is your PRO plan :-)
- Item_Boring 6y agoHey, it’s the German girl :) I just sent you an e-mail - hope to stay in touch!
- feross 6y agoThis is incredible.
- quickthrower2 6y agoWill this be one of those classic threads? Like the lotta Bitcoin for pizza? I hope so.
- AdamHurley 6y agoThis app is awesome! great way to meet random people all around the world, and engage in interesting conversation.
- purplezooey 6y agoThe rampant gratuitous flagging on HN has gotten out of control, this thread is exhibit A. Stop flagging stuff. If it has the slightest tinge of humor or sarcasm it gets flagged. Put the flag down. It's OK to be a little funny sometimes. Just stop.
- omk 6y agoMaybe because it is a slippery slope. "My humorous jab beats yours" attitude ends up derailing conversations and creating noise. I like how r/ELI5 handles this by ensuring that top level comments are always serious answers.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> It's OK to be a little funny sometimes. But people usually not trying to be funny is the only thing that makes this site usable over something like Reddit. If we can keep away jokes and puns for as long as possible, that'd be great.
- focom 6y agoWas fun to meet people there! Thanks feross
- Raed667 6y agoI love this, it is like chatroulette but everyone i met was super nice and polite. (no surprise dicks is a good feature IMO)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoOnly a matter of time I'm sure. Is that still a problem with Chatroulette? They really should deploy measures against that shit. Maybe shadowban perverts so they end up together (which probably happens a lot anyway).
- antigirl 6y agoThe red button is clippped 80% on iPhone 7. My font size for OS is slightly larger than default
- xwdv 6y agoThe key to eliminating small talk is to announce observations and get to a point where you speak with more statements than questions.
- xyst 6y agoHe’s in, boys
- pepy 6y agohypothetically and within a reasonable time period, literally
- grewil2 6y ago> - What is a belief you had as a child that you no longer have? ... Hm, the type of some of these questions resemble the type of the personal questions used for password recovery by some companies. As a paranoid person, I am reluctant to disclose this information to unknown people.
- melicerte 6y agoYou already started the discussion :)
- CGamesPlay 6y agoAh, for me it was cosmic-deflect-attitude. I really struggled with it in my teenage years.
- dhimes 6y agoBut you should never give the correct answer for password recovery. What is a belief you had as a child that you no longer have? Purple Ocean. And that can be your answer for all the questions: first pet name, elementary school, and so on.
- imtringued 6y ago> But you should never give the correct answer for password recovery. Exactly. You're supposed to use your password manager to generate a second password and use that as your answer. I know this sounds stupid but it is the only way to stay safe.
- melicerte 6y agoJust to say I love the background animation when one refuse to allow the camera. Attention to details is everything.
- feross 6y agoI am glad someone noticed!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- GrumpyNl 6y agoWhats the difference with chat roulette?
- vijaybritto 6y agoI spoke to a couple of people and then I realised that I shouldnt cover my camera. My privacy filter was on and I got banned in 5 minutes. Good effort but I feel like its a clone of chat roulette!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- thih9 6y agoWhen I open it, I'm seeing "An unexpected error has occurred". I'm assuming either website went down because of increased traffic, or it's not working in Safari private mode. My video is also off by default, if that matters.
- serial_dev 6y agoThe screen that's visible when the video is not yet enabled is very annoying, might even be an epilepsy seizure trigger.
- aframe 6y agoDon’t want to sully the conversation here, but I want to raise an important point - so @feross, please stick with it. I gave my daughter (6) my iPad for ten minutes this morning and put her on a site to draw minecraft skins. I took a call and took my eyes off the device (but not daughter) for about five minutes while I paced around the room. When I sat back next to her, she somehow ended up on virus Café and was in a video chat with someone. This scared the absolute hell out of me as I knew nothing about the site, I wondered how on Earth she’d managed to stumble on it so quickly, how she’d been able to allow access to device cameras so easily and, ya know, “Virus Café”. To get around it, I’ve default denied mic and camera access and had to have a serious conversation about stranger danger. I accept my own lapse in this, but to mitigate it happening to other kids who don’t have helicopter parents, can you please put some form of test before you ask for camera settings? Some form of multiplication or division, or asking for the year you were born would be a massive boost to safeguarding young kids.
- Accacin 6y agoWell it must have been in your web history, I very much doubt she typed the URL in. You could have been visiting anything and she could have accidentally navigated there. For me, it's a very odd solution to a problem that we have to answer a question before allowing our webcam to be used. I would never set my webcam and mic to be allowed by default, and if I ever give my laptop or device to anyone to search for something I'll put them in a private browser for their privacy aswell as mine. Either way, I can probably not even begin to understand the responsibilities of being a parent, but if some safeguard is put into this one site, what about the next site you visit that has a similar idea? You're in the same situation again - and there's no shortage of websites for people to chat to each other via webcam.
- aframe 6y agoTo confirm, it’s not allowed by default, it’s set to always ask by default - which was just a case of clicking allow or not. And it most certainly wasn’t in my history. I’d never heard of it before and it’s my work iPad which she doesn’t know the passcode to. No, parenting is hard, especially so right now. Every day is a mix of work, and guilt that the kid of a full time working family isn’t getting everything she needs. Never-the-less, devices are common place now. And it’s not uncommon for children to play on them. She does have a device that only has age appropriate learning apps on, and parental controls. These apps have the above mentioned checks in place to stop kids getting into the settings. This site has a very child friendly design; bright buttons, emojis flying around. Isn’t it at least responsible to make sure that young people can’t access it?
- throwaway876786 6y agoI had some very interesting conversations here. I don't remember the exact questions and dailogue but I'll note some here for users to know what they can expect. It was addictive. I got to a couple participants that covered their camera and decided to disconnect after seeing me (Internet strangers do that). #1 What is the social and economics structure (theoritical or fictious) that you tend to agree with. We spent a minute or so discussing how we are new to the platform and it is our first session. The participant was from Europe and immediately opted for Capitalism. I sort of agreed and waved good bye at end of 2 mins. #2 Do you believe in after life? The participant was a cheerful African women. I disclosed that would prefer not to have a after life and belong the void. That is the only way to achieve peace for me. She immediately exclaimed that she prefers to have an after life as she believes that there is more to experience than the chaos we experience in life. #3 What is it that you would change in your past? It was a North American man. We shared some personal experiences. We ended up extending the time multiple times and it was fun talking. I think we both took something away from the chat. #4 You use a public toilet and notice there is no toilet paper. You are inside the stall. What do you do? An Indian origin participant from Africa shared some witty advice here. We ended up in small talk, and realized he has visited places in my city in India. We had an interesting conversation about how intellectuals can study spirituality and ignore the illogical and derive value. I had some very interesting conversations here. And I might use this platform again. Good job!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mythrwy 6y agoWow I was a little nervous at first but that was really fun! I did like 6 or 7. For some reason over half were from KSA. Might check that random seed :) But still fun. Kudos to author.
- anakimluke 6y agoNice! I have some feedback. Where can I send it to?
- feross 6y agoMy email is [my username]@feross.org
- jnaddef 6y agoMaybe I am not stubborn enough, but my experience after 5 tries is: - Nobody showed their face to the camera - why not but it seems odd to not be on equal foot - 1 person was doing ONLY small talk and did not seem interested to discuss a specific topic. - 4 people saw me and immediately ended the chat
- avidmoon 6y agoMy comments after trying it for a while: - First off all, I like the idea! Thanks for making this! HN will often hold a hobby-project to the standards of a professional product, and will hence criticize a lot, but don't get discouraged, I enjoyed it. - From time to time I got a repeated question, or the question was a bit lame/uninteresting. Maybe add a feature so you're able to "reroll" the question once per conversation (perhaps with agreement of the other). Personally I would like it if you could e.g. choose a category before getting matched. - I got insta-disconnected quite often. This doesn't really bother me that much as I can try again immediately, but it could put people off when they try out the app and get skipped the first couple of times. People will judge the app on the first conversations. Do you punish frequent disconnecters? (Maybe put a limit, like max 2 disconnects per minute) - The "no small-talk" is not very effective, some will entirely ignore the question. But I don't really think you can avoid this. - I never got matched to a troll / something inappropriate. On the contrary: some conversations where quite wholesome (like a very friendly camel farmer with his little daughter). I hope it can stay this way. - A majority of people I got matched to where from Saudi Arabia. This is not an issue on its own, but I found that many of these had poor English skills or a bad connection, which made conversations difficult. - Some conversations where interesting, but some were also very lame. It's not so much the question that's important but also the personality of the person you get matched with. There are quite some people that go "idk lol how about you" after getting asked the conversation question. However the quality of the conversations are really the maker or breaker of the experience. It can be worth wading trough the bad ones for the good ones. Good ones occur less frequent tough, but tend to be longer. Indeed, 2 minutes is very short to have a proper discussion, so you extend it if it goes well. You could try to enhance this by e.g. making each renewal of the timer a minute longer.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- docuru 6y agoThe small talk dilemma, people like small talk use it to get into conversation with strangers. And the others just don’t want to talk to strangers (or people who are not alike) End of story!
- blakeburch 6y agoI love the idea of forcing "deep talk". I found that the fleeting nature of the connection doesn't pair as well with in-depth answers and good conversation, but it pairs great when the conversation is bad. I also ran into a lot of instances where I got reported with the message of "be nice" when the other person wasn't responding and/or wasn't on cam. I'm assuming I got reported, but couldn't confirm why. Overall, really cool concept and slick implementation. Just wish more than 30% of the conversations had been fruitful. I'm assuming if you forced people to have accounts, you'd be able to improve this experience over time.
- supportact 6y agoHey! Great idea. I've had a lot of fun with it. Honestly, I'm not sure how this would even work, but it might be enjoyable if it were possible to randomise the location of both parties a little more. For the first 24 hours, I was meeting people from across the globe. However, for some reason, I now match exclusively with people from Saudi Arabia who don't speak very good English. I'm assuming the website was promoted there by an 'influencer' or something. I've met a lot of lovely people living in Riyadh, but it was a lot more fun when I didn't know where the other person was...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kinj28 6y agoThis is real cool. I would like something like this for blind matching a buyer and a seller in this covid 19 time. Sellers get 2 mins and a buyer can extend it by 5 mins. Speed dating for business.
- whatwhyhow 6y agoNice idea btw, the only problem that's full of Saudi's (no offense, it's just that I expected different people) Also, I think enforcing camera is bad btw