4 ms·
The government directed Facebook to suppress Snap? https://techcrunch.com/2019/10/04/snap-ceo-isnt-expecting-much-from-facebook-antitrust-investigations/ https
by Apocryphon 6y ago
The government directed Facebook to suppress Snap?
https://techcrunch.com/2019/10/04/snap-ceo-isnt-expecting-much-from-facebook-antitrust-investigations/ https://techcrunch.com/2019/10/04/snap-ceo-isnt-expecting-mu...
- WalterBright 6y agoThink about your local ISP. They usually have a local monopoly because they use the government to make competition illegal.
- Apocryphon 6y agoYes, regulatory capture is a problem, but it's somewhat ludicrous to make a blanket statement like "government is the tool used to suppress competition". It's one tool in the toolbox, perhaps a significant one, but hardly the only one.
- WalterBright 6y agoHealth care is another example. The government empowers the AMA to strictly control the number of seats in medical school, thereby restricting the supply of doctors and competition. Licensing, permits, etc, are all ways to limit and prevent competition.
- Apocryphon 6y agoAgain, I do not deny that governments have been used as a tool for monopolies to form, but it is dubious that they are the only tool used by bad actors, nor is regulatory capture the only method for anticompetitive behavior.
- WalterBright 6y agoI did not say "only".
- Apocryphon 6y agoYou didn't, but your phrasing certainly implied it. "The government is the tool used to suppress competition" is a very stark statement. Next time, say "a" or "one of the" tools.
- 6510 6y agoA simple alternative ingredient could be that firing (read "punishing") employees on a small scale has a large chilling effect. Relaxing labor laws/job security may have a much larger long term effect. If I ask for a raise, will I get fired first either way?
- Frondo 6y agoI could ask any surfer on the beach right now and even they'd be able to identify that you've now entered a kind of argumentation where, if government is at all involved, government is the problem, no matter how it's involved. "The AMA strictly controls the number of seats, and the government has a medical licensing process, therefore the AMA's actions are the government's fault." Nope.
- WalterBright 6y agoBefore dismissing this out of hand, see "Competition and Monopoly in Medical Care" by Frech. https://www.amazon.com/Competition-Monopoly-Medical-Care-Frech/dp/0844738859 https://www.amazon.com/Competition-Monopoly-Medical-Care-Fre... Plenty of evidence and cites.
- chrischen 6y agoCould you give an example of this?
- WalterBright 6y agoWhen Google tried to lay fiber in various municipalities, they failed because those municipalities would not permit it.
- Frondo 6y agoThose were all local municipalities, responsive to their electorate - if the surfers in a community wanted Google fiber huts, they could elect councils who would allow them. I think it's reasonable that people should have local control over their city environs, even if it means a multinational like Google can't come in and build new infrastructure. It's not a "will of the people, unless Google wants to build fiber huts everywhere" kind of society. Maybe they should just go surfing instead.
- missedthecue 6y ago>Those were all local municipalities, responsive to their electorate - if the surfers in a community wanted Google fiber huts, they could elect councils who would allow them This is an idealistic line of thinking, but as a practical matter, is completely untrue. Essentially 0% of America understand their county commissioners' stance on ISP competition, myself included. No one campaigns on those things. It's a lot like saying that electorates are responsible for police violence because sheriffs are elected officials after all.
- learc83 6y agoYou need government to build an ISP in the first place. No private company would be able to negotiate with that many land owners to build out fiber on a large scale. And once a company does build a network, absent government regulation requiring them to let other companies use it, the existing infrastructure is an enormous barrier to entry.
- WalterBright 6y ago> No private company would be able to negotiate with that many land owners to build out fiber on a large scale. Before the government stepped in to anoint winners and losers in the phone business, companies sprang up everywhere and strung their own wires.
- learc83 6y agoTelephone lines were almost always built following existing public roads or private railroads (that were built with government assistance and government land grants) even in the early days. There is no history of a successful, large scale infrastructure project built without government assistance. Either directly or due to the fact that much of it was built on government land. (unless maybe you consider some case where private infrastructure was built in one large area controlled by a small group of owners, but that's basically just a government by another name and doesn't apply to modern America.)
- WalterBright 6y agoAn awful lot of railroads were built without government assistance. Of course, it was easier to build them if one got government financing. Even so, a railroad is private property and they can choose to allow or not someone stringing wires along it.
- chii 6y agorailroads were given the go-ahead by the federal government back when they were built, because the federal government granted the land to both sides of the rails to the rail builders (if they built it). It's hard to argue that the railroad builders were not given "assistance" (the granting of land).