6 ms·
As so many of these incidents have happened over the last few days it seems like there should be a law that heightens the penalties when cops attack the press c
by MBCook 6y ago
As so many of these incidents have happened over the last few days it seems like there should be a law that heightens the penalties when cops attack the press compared to the current penalties.
- leetcrew 6y agoI don't think the press should have special protections over ordinary citizens. the penalty for any unwarranted use of force should be increased to whatever you would want for journalists.
- dpeck 6y agoYes! Press is a thing people do, not a credential people have. All people should have freedom to observe and report on (to the extent they wish or do not wish to) actions of the state. Restricting that should have severe punishment.
- ghouse 6y agoAgreed, though be careful what you ask for. If you're not a publisher (press), you can't libel. Slander, sure. But libel, no.
- leetcrew 6y agoIANAL, but it's my understanding that anything written and viewed by a third party is considered "published" wrt libel. so it's already trivially easy for an ordinary person to commit libel.
- stcredzero 6y agoPress is a thing people do, not a credential people have. All people should have freedom to observe and report on (to the extent they wish or do not wish to) actions of the state. Restricting that should have severe punishment. Social media platforms, take note!
- joshuamorton 6y agoSocial media platforms should also have that right. And in fact they do: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23408093 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23408093
- jedberg 6y agoEdit: I'm wrong. See below. The reason they have special protection is because the constitution grants them special protection. The question of who is "the press" in this day and age where anyone can publish anything is certainly up for debate though.
- gpm 6y ago> The reason they have special protection is because the constitution grants them special protection. I'm not a lawyer, but it doesn't > There is no precedent supporting laws that attempt to distinguish between corporations which are deemed to be exempt as media corporations and those which are not. We have consistently rejected the proposition that the institutional press has any constitutional privilege beyond that of other speakers. Supreme court in citizen's united, internal quotation marks omitted. https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/09pdf/08-205.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/09pdf/08-205.pdf > protections of the First Amendment do not turn on whether the defendant was a trained journalist, formally affiliated with traditional news entities, engaged in conflict-of-interest disclosure, went beyond just assembling others' writings, or tried to get both sides of a story. 9th circuit in Obsidian Finance Group, LLC v. Cox http://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2014/01/17/12-35238.pdf http://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2014/01/17/12...
- jedberg 6y agoFair enough, thanks for the info. Looks like I was wrong.
- zucker42 6y agoI mean I suppose the argument could be that they are afforded special protections because they are acting as press (i.e. at the protests primarily to document and report events). But the constitution protects peaceable assembly as well as the freedom of the press, so it's hard to see how this case would turn on that.
- thephyber 6y agoNo thanks. We already have tons of statutes for all sorts of assault/battery with modifiers if they are done using lethal weapons. Police have already been demanding that "hate crime" laws (which are historically limited to who you are, not your profession or your choices) be amended for extra harsh punishment for attacks on police officers (despite many other existing statutes with similar purposes). In the end, prosecutions of police with harsher statutes don't matter unless the conviction rate goes up. Right now, convictions of officers for actions done while in uniform are astronomically low. We need to work the other parts of the problem (gathering evidence, getting police to stand witness against other police, getting DAs to actually charge and push for convictions, firing of officers for conduct unbecoming an officer, etc).
- zucker42 6y agoWell a big problem not included in your post is that police officers can't face liability for violating people's rights in many cases because of qualified immunity.
- cxr 6y agoThis is the kind of comment that makes reading through incredibly frustrating. What do you _mean_ that's not included in the parent post? What else do you think the parent is saying if not exactly that?
- zucker42 6y agoHe didn't include ending qualified immunity under the list of things he thought have to change, even though it's one of the most important. Plus, all the things he included are social changes or executive policy changes rather than a specific legal change like ending qualified immunity. There are specific efforts to end qualified immunity [1], while his suggestions amount to "we need to change culture", which is completely true but not as actionable. It could be that he meant to include ending qualified immunity, but being specific doesn't hurt. [1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/nicksibilla/2020/06/03/new-bill-would-abolish-qualified-immunity-make-it-easier-to-sue-cops-who-violate-civil-rights/#232ced116fbc https://www.forbes.com/sites/nicksibilla/2020/06/03/new-bill... (direct source at https://twitter.com/justinamash/status/1267267244029083648 https://twitter.com/justinamash/status/1267267244029083648)
- sukilot 6y agoWhich should be penalized more? Shooting a journalist for journaling, or shooting a Black person for being black? Ranking victims by status is a dangerous game.
- rumanator 6y ago> Which should be penalized more? Shooting a journalist for journaling, or shooting a Black person for being black? Both? I don't believe anyone was asked do pick. It's a false dichotomy.
- siphor 6y agoI'd like a law that makes policing without a body camera illegal and a low felony/misdemeanor
- pnw_hazor 6y agoThis is a tough one. In Seattle police are directed to not use their body cams unless they are doing crime investigation stuff. The policy is designed to protect the privacy of people not under investigation or otherwise not involved in crime. In pre-body cam days Seattle PD got caught video taping protests or demonstrations. The current policy prevents that. Thus, Seattle cops generally have their cams turned off while dealing with demonstrations or protests.
- trhway 6y ago>The policy is designed to protect the privacy of people not under investigation or otherwise not involved in crime. Obviously lame excuse by the PD as the delete button can do the same.
- CamperBob2 6y agoThe policy is designed to protect the privacy of people not under investigation or otherwise not involved in crime. And conveniently, you don't know if you'll be under investigation or accused of a crime until it's too late to turn the camera on. Sorry, that excuse doesn't fly. This concern should be addressed by controlling the custody of the footage, not by preventing it from being captured in the first place. In reality, body cameras protect good cops.
- Ididntdothis 6y agoBetter to enforce the current laws. That should be sufficient.
- rolph 6y agousing weapons or injurious force to facilitate: interfering with the evidence of, or the report of a crime? for the purpose of evasion of prosecution? tampering with a witness?
- lhorie 6y agoI don't really understand comments that ask for heightened penalties for [topic-du-jour]. In my mind, the justice system should not strive to be _more punitive_, but rather to be _fair_. If we follow the logic of making punishments harsher (say, adding years of prison to a violent cop), what then do we as a society expect is supposed to happen when said cop finally attempts to reintegrate into society after doing their prison sentence? We can't keep "wishing away bad guys" as if real life was a movie that conveniently ends at a happy ending. If anything, a revamp of the current system needs to _do away_ with special protections and other dis-equalizer factors. For the matter of police violence specifically, I feel that the courts are not even the best medium for change. For example, why is the topic of police training largely absent in these discussions?
- freeone3000 6y agoI'm not for this reactionary sort of rhetoric. Assault of a journalist shouldn't be worse than regular assault any more than assault of a cop should be worse than regular assault. Your job is not a shield. All people are equally deserving of protection, and qualifiers based on identity screw that ideal up massively.