5 ms·
"According to the suit, the company collects information, including IP addresses and browsing histories, whenever users visit web pages or use an app tied to co
by simonw 6y ago
"According to the suit, the company collects information, including IP addresses and browsing histories, whenever users visit web pages or use an app tied to common Google services, such as Google Analytics and Google Ad Manager."
I'd really appreciate some more technical details here.
Does this include web server logs that record incoming IP addresses?
Is the expectation here that Chrome would set a DNT header in incognito mode and Google properties would then obey that header?
- t0mas88 6y agoServer logs with IP addresses are acceptable to most European privacy regulators if you only use them for a technical purpose such as debugging. And not keep them longer than needed for that. So practically: logs are fine, delete them after a while. If you store the same information in a permanent database and use it for analysis you're in trouble and should have asked permission. The fact that the user uses a private window or other means to indicates they don't want to be tracked probably makes this a more clear case.
- oefrha 6y ago> The fact that the user uses a private window or other means to indicates they don't want to be tracked probably makes this a more clear case. That’s a very confusing statement. My server logs don’t filter incoming log entries based on user agent, and certainly not on whether you’re using a “private window” or not. In addition, the goal of a private/incognito session is to be indistinguishable from regular sessions, otherwise websites can easily discriminate against private sessions (which they’re already trying as hard as they could). Edit: Wow the number of people on this thread claiming websites should be able to opt people out of logging based on whether they’re using a “private window” (which websites should have absolutely no idea about) makes me question if I’m even on Hacker News. Edit 2: Chrome sends an X-Client-Data header (which in a sense includes an installation ID, but allegedly has limited entropy) to certain Google properties, and rightfully got a lot of flak for it. It does not do so for incognito sessions. And now we have people arguing that Google should de-incognito incognito sessions to their analytics properties. Crazy stuff.
- t0mas88 6y agoBut you're not using the IP addresses in the logs to circumvent the fact that cookies are being deleted by your user's device right? Because it looks like that's what Google was doing, and that's actively circumventing the decision of the user not to be tracked which is illegal in many places.
- oefrha 6y agoI don’t use GA on my own websites, or analytics cookies, or tracking pixels, or whatever. But I sometimes use goaccess on my server logs which tells me the number of unique visitors (based on unique IPs) and such. Whether they visited in private sessions or not, of course. So I guess in a sense I’m “tracking” them through logged IP addresses, but it’s completely orthogonal to whether incognito mode is on.
- w7 6y agoMy interpretation of this article is it's related to incognito mode. How is it circumventing a "decision of the user not to be tracked" when "private" modes usually explicitly state they can't/don't stop websites from logging information.
- La1n 6y ago>explicitly state they can't/don't stop websites from logging information. Because it's not about the logging, it's about the linking to a cookie/information they do not have access to in incognito?
- tantalor 6y agoDetecting when users of any browser are using Incognito mode goes against the spirit of privacy, even if it’s not being done to directly track people as such, and any information that some browsers share and others don’t helps add to a browser’s fingerprint. https://nakedsecurity.sophos.com/2019/07/22/chrome-76-blocks-websites-from-detecting-incognito-mode/ https://nakedsecurity.sophos.com/2019/07/22/chrome-76-blocks...
- MattGaiser 6y ago> The fact that the user uses a private window or other means to indicates they don't want to be tracked probably makes this a more clear case. What about the fact that Incognito is so that "other people who use this device won't see your activity" and it doesn't do anything about tracking?
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoThis is actually no longer true: Google recently added third party tracker blocking when you're in incognito mode. Of course, every other browser does this even outside of incognito mode, but the point stands that Google has actively added features to prevent websites from tracking you in this mode.
- slowmovintarget 6y agoBut they have actively disabled the abilities of add-ons to do the job completely. There's a lot of except-Google going on in Chrome. I switched back to Firefox last year, and it's been a good change. uBlock Origin can do all of its job and not just some of the job.
- fpoling 6y agoAt GDPR presentation that I attended recently in Norway the message was that IP addresses must be masked if they go to a permanent storage. For IPv4 it could be OK to clear the last byte of the address, but in general the message was to save the least amount of information. For example, if IP is used for locating regions, then save the regions, not the IP itself.
- user5994461 6y agoLogs are not permanent storage. They're auto deleted after a few weeks.
- simonw 6y agoFound the full lawsuit PDF https://www.insurancejournal.com/app/uploads/2020/06/brown-v-google.pdf https://www.insurancejournal.com/app/uploads/2020/06/brown-v... It looks like this is mainly about the fact that Google Analytics still works even if you are in Incognito mode.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoWhich there is a warning of every time you open an incognito window. It's not fine print either, it's one of about six bullet points. "Your activity might still be visible to ... Websites you visit." This one is going nowhere I suspect. Just because a lawsuit asks for big damages does not mean the plaintiffs are likely to prevail on their claims.
- dvfjsdhgfv 6y agoYes, it's quite interesting, and it borders on semantics. I.e. someone misunderstood privacy in this context as understood in general, that you keep things for yourself. But private/incognito browsing on Chrome means privacy from other people using your computer, not from the biggest user-tracking company. Maybe instead calling it "incognito mode", which is totally inadequate, they should call it "temporarily disable browsing history" instead.
- coronadisaster 6y agowhile they do warn you, it is about time that they implement a real incognito mode, maybe using Tor by default... The current incognito only protects your privacy from other people that are using the same computer which is not really that helpful since you could just create another user to achieve basically the same (if your disk is encrypted)
- shadowgovt 6y agoWhy should they? Tor is already there.
- 6y ago