6 ms·
It looks like Take-Two studios didn't want to pay the the premium of having another studio do the work, so they switched to recruiting the employees directly in
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
It looks like Take-Two studios didn't want to pay the the premium of having another studio do the work, so they switched to recruiting the employees directly instead. And it worked.
> The LinkedIn message went on to say Take-Two was setting up a new studio to keep working on the same game Star Theory had been developing, a sequel to the cult classic Kerbal Space Program. Take-Two was looking to hire all of Star Theory’s development staff to make that happen. “We are offering a compensation package that includes a cash sign-on bonus, an excellent salary, bonus eligibility and other benefits,” Cook wrote.
I won't go so far as to condone Take-Two's actions, but I don't see this entirely as a negative for the employees involved if (and it's a big if) Take-Two chose to pay the employees extra compensation and bonuses instead of giving the money to a middleman.
As someone who went through an acqui-hire only to see our founders walk away with millions while the employees' salaries remained unchanged, I wouldn't be opposed companies directing those acqui-hire funds to hiring bonuses given directly to the employees.
- ashtonkem 6y agoAlso, for a lot of those devs a successful launch of KSP2 is going to be a career booster; they don’t want to walk away from it.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoBut if they worked for Star Theory they would likely benefit a lot more than if they worked for Take Two directly (I believe the article touches on that).
- ashtonkem 6y agoFor sure, but the former is off the table. So they’ve got to decide which is more valuable to them: finishing KSP2, or the extra comp they could get somewhere else.
- diggan 6y agoGuess that depends on your definition of "benefit". As one developer (from the article) puts it: > he didn’t want to work for a big company where he wouldn’t have the same degree of influence or financial benefits if the game were a hit. “I was at a small studio, where the work I did had a massive impact on our success,”
- gamblor956 6y agoAs a developer, he would never have had a stake in the financial outcome of KSP2's sales. Didn't he bother to look into the history of the first KSP? The owners made bank (and are still making bank) and many of the developers didn't even make the equivalent of the US minimum wage for their work.
- simias 6y agoThe way I read what he said he seems more interested by having his work matter and influence the final game than immediate monetary reward. Given what I keep hearing about the working conditions in the videogame industry it seems like most videogame devs are in it because they like making games and want the reward of telling people "see this cool game everybody plays? Well I made (some) of that!". Otherwise with their skillset they'd probably have no trouble finding work in an other branch of the software industry that'd have better compensation and working conditions, if a lot less cool to explain during parties.
- Jare 6y agoI would think that this engineer's ideas of how things were going to change were mistaken. I don't know the insides of this case, but generally, the impact you have on the game you work on depends on three things: - the trust and empowerment that project leads give non-lead staff - the amount of non-lead stuff with a voice - the ability of said leads to have a say in how the project is run In this case, the leads remained, the project owner (the publisher) remained, and doesn't sound like the staff increased much if at all; so I really doubt things would change much in that sense. Given what happened, someone thought that something in the studio/project had to change, but I just doubt it would be the presence of staff's voice.
- IMTDb 6y ago> As someone who went through an acqui-hire only to see our founders walk away with millions while the employees' salaries remained unchanged I have always understood acqui-hire as "Big company sees a team of talented devs with good cost structure (aka: manageable salaries) so they pay a one time flat fee to get that team working on their problems" At no point have I ever expected developers salaries to change during an aqui-hire. They might get a boost after the aqui-hire if they have trouble retaining the devs for whatever reason. But usually the whole point of an aqui hire is the relative low salaries of the employees compared to their performance.
- marcosdumay 6y ago> compared to their performance That one part is key. Acqui-hires are justified because the teams display high performance, not low cost. If the truth is that they happen for the second reason, expect a lot of fighting back against it once the word gets out.
- philipov 6y ago> the teams display high performance, not low cost Performance is relative to cost; you can't have one without the other. Trying to spin it as being only about performance is an attempt to deceive the labor.
- marcosdumay 6y agoIf it helps, add "abnormally" before "low" and "high". As of now, I don't have any certainty that there is any mass deceiving going on. Creating a team with very high performance is not easy, and it makes sense to reward it. But if there is deceiving, it is of one of the worst possible kinds.
- hnick 6y agoAnd teams is the important bit - not individuals. The whole is greater than the sum of the parts etc. They might all be top tier workers but there's a benefit to getting a fully functional team with institutional knowledge and processes rather than starting from the ground up.
- whatsmyusername 6y agoshrug It made me completely lose interest in KSP2 almost instantly.
- nvr219 6y agoThe core fan base of KSP is super passionate and if the game is good they'll play it regardless of the studio name.
- edw 6y agoPassion can cut more than one way. It’s quite possible that the poster you replied to is, as you said, super passionate and is turned off by Take Two’s hardball tactics to the point that they don’t purchase the game when it’s released.
- whatsmyusername 6y agoI enjoy KSP1 and have a bunch of hours in it. But if they Take2 it I'll just skip 2 and keep playing 1. The last couple years I've gotten real good at passing on games. ex: I thoroughly enjoyed doom 2016 single player, was ambivalent to snap map, and was extremely turned off on the MP. In immortal my understanding is they took all the parts I didn't like from 2016, and built those up (with a healthy dose of being a jerk to the guy who made the bang'n music for 2016 on the side). I've played doom since doom 1 shareware (pre v1.666) but I'm skipping immortal entirely. There's just way too much content out there for me to bother with people who make me feel bad for doing business with them.
- willis936 6y agoPassion is goodwill. Goodwill is profits on the table. With this new studio they are not beholden to prior promises of not having microtransactions.
- _chris_ 6y ago> The game had been set to come out this year [me: March 2020], but the company said last month it was delaying the release until the fall of 2021. Is delaying the release by over a year and a half a win? I wonder how much in royalties/costs they're really saving.
- gear54rus 6y agoWhat infuriates me is that how can you not see that you need another YEAR right up until a few months remain wtf. Why not announce it sooner.
- BorisTheBrave 6y agoI suspect once you realize the release date is gonna be missed no matter what, you might as well go for a year and uncut all those extra things that were sacrificed in an attempt to make the original reelase date.
- lrem 6y agoOne example: you might miss the fact that your company will be torn apart by your dominant business partner.
- foobiekr 6y agoThat is a failed acquihire. The whole point of an acquihire from the acquirer's point of view is that while business-unit-specific OPEX budget is used for salaries, bonuses and other overhead, retention packages and equity arrangements are generally covered by the central budget. Otherwise you would just hire people directly, possibly using special packages. What an acquihire gets you, as an executive, is that people you otherwise wouldn't be able to hire, because you can pay above market without wrecking your budget. These people are either vesting out equity or they are on explicit retention packages, but from a budget standpoint _they aren't on you_. Another way to think about it is that this buys you the time necessary to, using the normal levers available to you, get employees to the point where a set of overlapping RSU grants are vesting quarterly, thereby both avoiding a steep compensation cliff and getting the total compensation to where it needs to be in a way you could not do on day one.
- afterburner 6y agoAren't acquihires really about the IP?
- goseeastarwar 6y agoNo, they’re soft landings for talented people in failing businesses.
- m463 6y agoThere are very few soft landings in the Kerbal Space Program.
- dpeck 6y agoNo, then it would be an acquisition.
- foobiekr 6y agoIP, if it can be re-used, is considered a bonus at best. In practice, the IP you want is in the experience of the people you're getting, not their random patent portfolio or source code.