6 ms·
Australian researchers set record for carbon dioxide capture
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Sabinus 6y agoTell me why this won't work.
- gonzo41 6y agoIt may work but it's probably hard to scale because you have to manufacture something. I think with Australia's vast flat lands we could probably farm algae on seawater and sunlight at scale as a way of scrubbing the atmosphere. Whilst this chemistry is exciting it seems like it would be of most use in ICE engines and coal fire plants where point source pollution is present. It may not have the impact people dream of like constructing a filter building and hoping all the CO2 floats past.
- boulos 6y agoYeah, before reading one of the carbon capture from the atmosphere papers, I hadn’t thought deeply about the challenge. Then I realized “oh, we’re talking about 350-450 ppm” which is less than 1 in 2000. Even though that CO2 is there and it’s damaging, you have to be really good at filtering to focus your energy on anything at a 1/2000 rate. By contrast, the tailpipe folks (like [1]) or the smokestack ones have >10% of the emissions as CO2! (Figure 3 in the paper, also directly here [2]). It’s literally “1 in 10” versus nearly “1 in 500”. You can be a lot less fancy when the density of your target is nearly 50x higher. [1] https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fenrg.2019.00143/full https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fenrg.2019.0014... [2] https://www.frontiersin.org/files/Articles/465010/fenrg-07-00143-HTML/image_m/fenrg-07-00143-g003.jpg https://www.frontiersin.org/files/Articles/465010/fenrg-07-0...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dukoid 6y agoIt will never be cheaper than avoiding co2 in the first place (or at least catching at the source) so while it might have applications, it seems impractical for making significant progress towards saving the planet at this point.
- posix_me_less 6y agoWhat do you mean by "saving the planet"? Do you mean keeping the population numbers and saving the western way of life at the same time? What would make significant progress towards that goal?
- canofbars 6y agoCapturing carbon takes a huge amount of energy. (Plants get it from the sun.) Its always more efficient to just use the energy generated to replace burning fuel.
- mhandley 6y agoThis process doesn't capture carbon, it captures CO2. Splitting CO2 back to Carbon and Oxygen does indeed take a great deal of energy, but if you can efficiently and cheaply store CO2 permanently (underground, in concrete, in greenhouse-grown plants, or wherever) then this can still be a net win.
- plerpin 6y agoAm I reading this right? 1.29 megajoules for one kilo captured? Uh, this doesn't seem feasible at scale.
- mkj 6y ago1kw of solar panels could do 5 tonnes a year. That seems feasible. 1000kw * 3600 * 5hr/day / 1.29e6 * 365
- zaroth 6y ago1.29 MJ/kg * 1kWh/3.6MJ = 0.3612 kWh per kg, or 361kWh per metric ton? For comparison, you get about 5 tons of CO2 produced driving 12,000 miles in an 22mpg vehicle. 361kWh * 5 = 1,805kWh, so maybe $100 of energy cost? Seems totally economical to offset the CO2 from a full year of driving. Now what I am wondering is if there’s any reason we won’t see a typical logistics curve / cost reduction pattern like we see with most tech whether it be solar panels, battery cost, etc. Is there a law of thermodynamics that puts a ceiling on how good this can get, and how close to the theoretical maximum are we currently?
- chrisco255 6y agoHow does this compare with just planting trees?
- lgrebe 6y agoTrees will die, decompose and release the CO2 back into the atmosphere. "Keep it in the ground" will need to become "Put it back in the ground"
- paranoidrobot 6y agoBy the same token: Power generators (solar panels, wind turbines, coal/nuclear/ whatever) break down, and need replacement. Trees have other benefits too - potentially very long lifetimes, self-repairing, self-replacing, improving water tables, improving/generating/retaining soil, and can be used for building and in other processes once they reach maturity.
- vajrabum 6y agoHere's the actual paper which has a lot more information including possibilities for improving the process. https://www.cell.com/cell-reports-physical-science/fulltext/S2666-3864(20)30023-0#secsectitle0065 https://www.cell.com/cell-reports-physical-science/fulltext/...
- pfundstein 6y agoI'm amazed to see the organization that invented wifi is still pushing the envelope after suffering so many budget cuts at the hands of the "Liberal" (conservative) government.
- somishere 6y agoguess there's a lot more hot air to work with
- orwin 6y agoIn most countries, liberals are considered at least center, if not rightwing and conservative. I don't know about australian politics but it seems like its the same there. By Liberal they mean liberal economically (small government, no regulations) and conservative socially.
- dmos62 6y agoAs someone coming from a political environment that doesn't use the term, I seem to periodically forget what is meant by liberal. Your concise definition is very useful.
- goodcanadian 6y agoIn North America, liberal generally means left of centre and conservative means right of centre. Of course, I've never liked the one dimensional left/right political spectrum.
- jwilliams 6y agoIn this case it's literally the name of the party (Liberals and Labor are the two major parties). You're correct on the economic and social axes, but that's become less distinct over the last decade.
- dependenttypes 6y ago> small government, no regulations looks at the encryption law
- sudhirj 6y agoThere was an article a while ago asking why stock prices have not priced in climate change, and I think this is why. As much as we hate to admit it, the solution to climate change will be as industrial as the industries that caused it. I'm planting trees whenever I can, but on a planetary scale I think this is going to be fixed only by manufacturing zero emission transport, and negative emission machines, all of which will increase stock prices of industrial companies with factories. Fusion will be the ultimate solution to all problems if it happens – we'll have enough effectively free energy to scrub the atmosphere to our exact specifications with this or any other halfway efficient method, and enough cheap energy to flood all land including deserts with desalinated water. We engineered our way into this problem, I don't think we can kumbayah our way out of it.
- dan-robertson 6y agoYou don’t necessarily need fusion or nuclear power to remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. At least theoretically, you get more energy from burning hydrocarbons than is necessary to capture the released CO2 from the atmosphere. So you can (in theory) burn hydrocarbons while capturing the emissions and still producing energy.
- peanutz454 6y agoAren't we running out of hydrocarbons?
- barry-cotter 6y agoNo. At the most trivial level they grow on trees or anything else that grows using photosynthesis. On a more pragmatic level usable reserves is not a fixed description of the world, it depends on technology. Fracking gets oil out of the ground at economic prices from what would have been unusable trash twenty years ago. You see the same thing in many different kinds of mining. There are places where they’re making a profit extracting iron from old tailings now, i.e. the waste from mining iron a hundred years ago is now itself profitable to mine for iron.
- opportune 6y agoWait a sec. Coal produces about 24 MJ/kg and this only takes 1.29 MJ/kg of CO2, or 4.73/kg of carbon. Even if coal were pure carbon this means we could burn coal to capture ~5x as much carbon as it generates. That’s amazing! I’m assuming there are significant energy costs in scaling production of these materials up to any scale at which it could have an environmental impact though.
- arethuza 6y agoThe efficiency of coal fired power plants is ~40% and there might be further inefficiencies in running this process at industrial scales.
- DennisP 6y agoWith global CO2 emissions of 36 gigatonnes annually, it would take 1.4 terawatts or about 7% of total annual energy consumption (i.e. not just electricity) to absorb all our emissions. That's a lot but fixing a problem for just 7% of the energy we used to make the problem strikes me as pretty good. A gallon of gasoline produces 9 kg CO2, requiring 3 kWh to absorb, at a cost of 30 cents. There'd also be capital cost. Avoiding emissions will often be cheaper, but for many sectors that's not so easy, so direct air capture could end up being an important part of the solution. We've also got a lot of excess CO2 right now that we'd be better off removing. Sequestering CO2 seems to be a solved problem by injecting into basalt formations, where it turns into rock in about a year.
- Scarblac 6y agoIs the problem of injecting CO2 solved to the point where we can do it at a rate of 36 gigaton per year, indefinitely? And how much energy does that cost?
- DennisP 6y agoI'm not advocating we do that much, just that we use it for the amount of emissions that's less practical to avoid. There's enough basalt for a very large amount, and energy to pump gas underground wouldn't be a major factor. Another option though is to turn the CO2 into liquid fuels. That wouldn't reduce ambient CO2 but to whatever extent we keep using liquid fuels (e.g. for airliners), it'd be nice if they were carbon neutral.
- Myce 6y agoI am not a native English speaker and the article seems to use a decent amount of scientific language. Therefore I've might have missed it, but what do they do with the captured carbon? Can it be used for new materials or products, or will it need to be stored indefinitely?
- jabirali 6y agoHere are relevant links to Wikipedia on CO2 storage: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_capture_and_storage#Sequestration https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_capture_and_storage#Seq... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_sequestration https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_sequestration To curb global warming, the best option is likely to store it underground, e.g. in reservoirs previously used for oil or gas production.
- foobar_ 6y agoA packet of seeds is 5$. I think what is needed is exact monitoring of emissions and policy to replenish it. I'm still not sure how efficient carbon capture technology is in terms of number of trees. If we go by the most common sci-fi themes, the 0.1% can give little to two shits of the climate, escape to mars and use earth as a mining colony. The military sheep will serve the 0.1% and enforce the apartheid happily. This is exactly how the 1st world uses the third world anyways, earth would just be the third planet. From a programming perspective ... how costly will it be to get rid of COBOL code ? Well machines that use oil are the same thing.