16 ms·
The main reason for this is innovation in dedicated cameras has slowed to a crawl. No dedicated camera I'm aware of will take 128 full res frames within half a
by londons_explore 6y ago
The main reason for this is innovation in dedicated cameras has slowed to a crawl.
No dedicated camera I'm aware of will take 128 full res frames within half a second, and align and stack them to reduce sensor noise. Yet all modern phone cameras do something like that.
You couldn't even really do the above in postprocessing - the Canon EOS 4000D can only do 3 fps, and only has a buffer of 6 frames.
The reason phone cameras have caught up despite 'worse' physics, is that dedicated cameras electronics are lacking functionality that phone cameras have had for a few years now.
- cesaref 6y agoWhy would a dedicated camera need to take huge numbers of photos to overcome sensor noise when it's not there in the first place? No, I think that's a bad example to choose. I do take your point, dedicated camera development is more conservative, but their market is different. If you splurge £10k on a camera system, you are likely a pro, and you want consistency, and longevity to the design and the operation of the system. Thinking about it, dedicated cameras have mainly been innovating in video production rather than stills in the last 5 years.
- StavrosK 6y agoI agree with the GP but for a different reason. It's unacceptable to me that I have to buy a separate trigger so I can take exposures 31 seconds long. There's no reason why the timer should only go up to 30, or that I shouldn't have better bracketing, or a timelapse mode, etc etc. Basically, all of Magic Lantern (a considerable feature set) should have been standard.
- sukilot 6y agoThat's a weird nitpick. My phone doesn't even have a headphone jack or an SD card tray. A free aftermarket add-on isn't a blocker.
- StavrosK 6y agoIt's a blocker for me because I don't want to pay Canon $160 for something that was deliberately left off the software so I'd have to pay Canon $160. Also, it's a literal button. I'm paying $160 for a button with a timer on it.
- c9fc42ad 6y agoI agree that the camera software should just let you pick any shutter speed, but you can get a pretty cheap remote button or intervalometer for <$30, or even DIY one for cheaper. What does the $160 canon button give you that a cheaper version doesn't?
- StavrosK 6y agoThe cheaper ones don't come with a timer, do they? Besides, it's not that I haven't found a solution (Magic Lantern lets me set the speed to however long I want), but I dislike the gesture. It's obvious that they're gating features so they can release them in the next model.
- andromeduck 6y agoDynamic range and motion blur/shake reduction.
- londons_explore 6y ago> Why would a dedicated camera need to take huge numbers of photos to overcome sensor noise when it's not there in the first place? Except there is noise. There is always some dark spot that could do with a little more detail. There is always a bright reflection that saturates the sensor losing its color information. With a decent burst and enough computational photography, you can recover all that information.
- throwanem 6y agoFirst, that's not noise. Second, modern ILC sensors have dynamic range to spare; you can usually pull a couple stops of detail on both sides in post. Third, if you want HDR, which is what you're talking about here anyway, modern ILCs can do it and have been able to for years. You set it up like bracketing and it assembles the shots in camera just like a phone does.
- hn_check 6y ago"Why would a dedicated camera need to take huge numbers of photos to overcome sensor noise when it's not there in the first place?" You have clearly never looked at unprocessed RAW data from the sensor or you wouldn't be saying something so completely wrong.
- centimeter 6y agoSignal to noise ratio on any “real” camera format (FF, APSC, MFT) is vastly superior to SNR on a cell phone camera. It’s not even in the same ballpark. PhotonsToPhotos has a lot of numerical comparisons available.
- hn_check 6y agoFirstly, I was responding to the claim that sensor noise "isn't there" on a dedicated camera [1], fullstop, which is ludicrously wrong. Without processing what comes out of the sensor is an ugly beast. Secondly, strange that you don't actually link anything to demonstrate this noise advantage. Much less that it's "vastly superior" and "not even in the same ballpark". Hint -- because it isn't. [1] - which is a revealing bit of cargo cult analysis. Sensor quality across "dedicated" cameras have enormous variations, and a lot are simply terrible. One of the reasons smartphones do burst and computational photography is for extended dynamic range, yet the iPhone 11 already has a sensor with more dynamic range than the significant majority of SLRs/mirrorless cameras. There are obviously better sensors, like the A7R II+, but there are many that are worse, sometimes much worse.
- centimeter 6y ago> Secondly, strange that you don't actually link anything I told you the name of the website where you should look. How explicit do I have to be for you? Here's a link if it helps. https://www.photonstophotos.net/Charts/PDR.htm https://www.photonstophotos.net/Charts/PDR.htm Compare an iPhone XS Max to a an A7R4 or something. At ISO 100, The A7R4 has 11.6 bits of dynamic range and the iPhone has 6.4 bits. HUGE difference. > Without processing what comes out of the sensor is an ugly beast. RAWs from a large sensor without denoising look fine. On my camera I only have lens correction and color correction - zero denoising. I've done statistical analysis of dark frames using LibRaw to make sure this is actually the case, and indeed I exactly replicated the results from PhotonsToPhotos. > yet the iPhone 11 already has a sensor with more dynamic range than the significant majority of SLRs/mirrorless cameras Hahahaha, please, show me one even APS-C camera from Sony, Fuji, Nikon, Canon, or any other reputable manufacturer made in the last 4 years that has a worse PDR than the iPhone 11.
- frooxie 6y ago> dedicated cameras have mainly been innovating in video production rather than stills in the last 5 years. Well, not Sony. Their mirrorless cameras have gotten much better autofocus and battery life and slightly better ergonomics, usability, speed and weather-sealing, but there has basically been no change in their video capabilities.
- codazzo 6y ago> Innovation in dedicated cameras has slowed to a craw Agreed! A dSLR with the same hardware/software sophistication of modern iPhones would be a marvelous product. If camera manufacturers are unwilling or uncapable to deliver this, I wonder if Apple would ever consider entering that market. Imagine: an iPhone with an APS-C sensor and replaceable lenses! The sad truth is that it would probably be a product with too long a lifespan for Apple to build it.
- _visgean 6y agoThe problem is two fold: > while large cameras have powerful special-purpose image processing engines, they have relatively weak programmable processors. At the same time, they have more pixels to process than cell phones, because their sensors are larger. These two factors made innovation difficult. from https://graphics.stanford.edu/~levoy/ https://graphics.stanford.edu/~levoy/ Also I think HDR+ and other similar stuff uses only around 12 pictures.
- Ciantic 6y agoVery true. For me the only thing I want from regular camera is amazing zoom capabilities. However if I compare pictures from e.g. Nikon Coolpix P950 which has small sensor but big zoom, the picture quality is not nearly as good as with phone cameras with smaller CMOS. I wish camera manufacturers started to mount these cameras on a phone hardware, maybe even run Android directly, if they can't get their act together.
- cesaref 6y agoAndroid was originally designed as an OS for cameras, if I remember correctly...
- hawski 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Android_(operating_system)#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Android_(operating_system)#His... > Android Inc. was founded in Palo Alto, California, in October 2003 by Andy Rubin, Rich Miner, Nick Sears, and Chris White.[16][17] Rubin described the Android project as "tremendous potential in developing smarter mobile devices that are more aware of its owner's location and preferences".[17] The early intentions of the company were to develop an advanced operating system for __digital cameras__, and this was the basis of its pitch to investors in April 2004.[18] The company then decided that the market for cameras was not large enough for its goals, and by five months later it had diverted its efforts and was pitching Android as a handset operating system that would rival Symbian and Microsoft Windows Mobile. Emphasis mine. It sounds like it was intended as an OS for cameras, but in the end it was not designed as one. However source from [18], confirms OP's memory - https://www.pcworld.com/article/2034723/android-founder-we-aimed-to-make-a-camera-os.html https://www.pcworld.com/article/2034723/android-founder-we-a... >The creators of Android originally dreamed it would be used to create a world of "smart cameras" that connected to PCs, a founder said, but it was reworked for mobile handsets as the smartphone market began to explode. > "The exact same platform, the exact same operating system we built for cameras, that became Android for cellphones," said Android co-founder Andy Rubin, who spoke at an economic summit in Tokyo.
- 6y ago
- dvfjsdhgfv 6y ago> The main reason for this is innovation in dedicated cameras has slowed to a crawl. That's not entirely true, althoughI'm not sure I like the direction. A good example if Fuji's X-T* line, where, as one reviewer noted, "I had thought I'm buing a camera, but it turned out I bought a computer with lens attached". It does all creative tricks to compensate for inaccuracies coming from the hardware, especially the lens - but at the price of draining the batteries exctremely fast, and each lens need a firmware update. Is the final result good? Yes. Do I like it more than more standard solution from Canon and Nikon? Not necessarily. It seems cheaper though.
- arvindch 6y agoAgreed, I wanted to do astrophotography with a DSLR, but the experience is so bad compared to just using my Pixel's inbuilt mode. Considering that Android was originally aimed at cameras [1], maybe that's something Camera OEMs can finally look at again. [1] https://www.dpreview.com/articles/0013837043/android-was-originally-designed-for-cameras https://www.dpreview.com/articles/0013837043/android-was-ori...
- sukilot 6y agoWhat's your setup?
- Neil44 6y agoI don’t think this is a meaningful example, the canon does not need to take 128 pics to reduce noise in the first place since it has a massive sensor.
- adwww 6y agoI'd agree with this. I have a Fuji X100F camera which produces lovely photos that look noticably distinct from my Pixel phone camera. However, even on innovative features that it does have - like WiFi or face recognition, it implements so poorly that I kind of wish they hadn't bothered. Fujifilm simply don't have the quality of software engineers that Apple and Google have access to. Nor do they place the same importance on software. The actual physical feel of this camera is sublime, it's a shame they don't think the software is worthy of the same attention to detail.
- qzw 6y agoI’m sure it’s not that they think software isn’t worthy, but simply that it’s not their traditional area of competence. It took a monumental effort for a lot of them just to make the film to digital transition, and they were only competing with each other. Now they have to compete against a whole different industry that’s faster moving and more software centric. Plus great software engineers don’t come cheap, and we’re talking about a market size that’s a few orders of magnitude smaller. So if they made the necessary investment in software, how much would the cameras end up costing? Maybe 2x to 10x their current prices, and thus further shrinking an already shrinking market? It’s a no-win situation.
- aikinai 6y agoSony's been pushing things forward quite a bit, and after catching up on most of the fundamentals, they're now working in AI/ML. Their latest cameras have incredible eye-autofocus built with ML, and they also recently announced and AI imaging chip.
- slantyyz 6y ago> the Canon EOS 4000D can only do 3 fps, and only has a buffer of 6 frames. If you're going to use a single camera as your example for the industry, I don't think that's fair. Canon makes great cameras, but my Nikon V1, circa 2011, is a camera "serious photographers" like to laugh at, and and outperforms your example. It was 5fps with a mechanical shutter, up to 60fps with the electronic shutter. At the time, some people used the 30fps burst to make 4K video clips: https://vimeo.com/61441075 https://vimeo.com/61441075 And FWIW, I used a command line tool to do image stacking to reduce sensor noise on my Nikon 1 cameras years ago. That was until I started using DxO, which does an adequate job of sensor noise reduction on a single RAW shot without as much work. Also, the DSLRs I used more than 10 years ago (Sony Alphas) were able to do 5fps, but back then, nobody really took you seriously as a photographer if you used a Sony.
- _ph_ 6y agoThe Olympus E-M1X and teh E-M1.3 will take 8-16 full resolution pictures at 60fps and process them together. There are two options, one for macro photography, where the pictures are taken with different focus settings for increasing DOF and the other is high-res modus, where the pictures are taken with a minimal sensor shift and combined for higher resolution and have less noise. This even works hand-held.
- AuryGlenz 6y agoIn a nice, high end DSLR 6400 IS0 is perfectly acceptable. I'm no hardware person, but I believe there are serious constraints on how quickly you can take images with larger sensors. The D6 can do 14 frames a second, and the D850 can do about half that.