5 ms·
This article is trash. In one breath, the writer lambasts IE9 for supporting a compatibility mode (while not mentioning that other browsers also have a quirks m
by quotemstr 16y ago
This article is trash. In one breath, the writer lambasts IE9 for supporting a compatibility mode (while not mentioning that other browsers also have a quirks mode) --- and then goes on to criticize the decision not to support XP, the most insecure operating system on earth. The article is a classic example of what results when you start with a conclusion and work back to the evidence.
- shin_lao 16y agoWindows XP is certainly not the most insecure operating system on Earth.
- robin_reala 16y ago…still in mainstream use.
- roryokane 16y agoThat would probably be Damn Vulnerable Linux (http://distrowatch.com/table.php?distribution=dvl http://distrowatch.com/table.php?distribution=dvl).
- pbhjpbhj 16y ago>lambasts IE9 for supporting a compatibility mode (while not mentioning that other browsers also have a quirks mode) I thought that quirks mode was to accommodate non-standards compliant markup. Also, isn't compatibility mode to fudge things to work by accommodating errors in the rendering engine?
- bad_user 16y agoYou comment is also trash. I have a Win XP desktop (besides my Ubuntu one, on which I spend most of my time lately). It's legit (paid money for it), all the software I care about runs on it and I never have had it infected with a virus (in 3 years since I bought it). So tell me, why the hell should I upgrade from the most popular OS on this planet and PAY for that upgrade? Because it doesn't conform to the perfect world you want? And if IExplorer 9 won't run on it, that's fine. There's always Chrome, Firefox, Safari and Opera. And about compatibility-mode, having that mode in IExplorer 9, but disregarding compatibility for Windows XP is inconsistent. Not to mention their competition is doing the exact opposite.
- isleyaardvark 16y agoWhile I don't particularly agree with him on the compatibility mode, I don't see the contradiction. His argument is that getting rid of compatibility mode provides an incentive for innovation and eliminating old unsupported code from the web. The more people that use IE9 (without a compatibility mode) would put pressure on site owners to make sure their code met current standards. Supporting IE9 on XP would increase that number.
- cooldeal 16y agoAnyone remember the hoopla when IE8 was initially going to follow strict standards mode? They had to backtrack because site owners were up in arms about changing millions of sites to render properly. IE9 uses a lot of technology and APIs that don't exist on XP, recoding all that for a 10 year old OS so that people can continue to keep running it beyond its lifespan(and holding back progress in other areas) doesn't seem to be a good thing.
- contextfree 16y agoWhile I think Microsoft's decision not to support XP makes sense from their perspective, I also think it's perfectly fair for others to complain about it (I don't think people should be obliged to adopt the POV of platform vendors, whether it's Microsoft or Apple. We saw this before with some of the defenses of Apple's language restrictions in their App Store developer agreement. I also think PC users should be free to upgrade, or not, on their own time). But I wish, instead of helplessly complaining about a Microsoft decision that's unlikely to change, they'd focus more on the opportunity this presents to promote other browsers.