6 ms·
People complain about the lack of cell phone providers here in the US, but damn! Canada is way worse. The cost of phone plans is outrageous and the major tele
by refurb 6y ago
People complain about the lack of cell phone providers here in the US, but damn! Canada is way worse. The cost of phone plans is outrageous and the major telecoms do everything in their power to stop new entrants from messing up their gravy train.
- humanlion87 6y agoI think it's far more difficult to build a competitive network in Canada vs the US. Canada is as big as the US, but has 1/10th the population. Building and maintaining infrastructure for low-density population areas is extremely capital intensive. I am not saying the existing Telco oligopoly is a good or ideal situation. Just mentioning that US and Canada have some differences in this regard
- Scoundreller 6y agoMost of the low-density population areas aren't covered anyway. By landmass, it's single-digit percentages or low double-digit percentages of coverage (And often it's weak outside of urban/suburban area). One of the least dense provinces, Saskatchewan, has some of the best pricing in the country because the government has yet to selloff the provincial telecom to private investors. Manitoba too before they decided to privatize and sell off to an incumbent. And high-density is no panacea for cost. Tall concrete buildings everywhere can mean more infrastructure costs. Especially if regulations require you to fit infrastructure into the facade. Medium-density is the least engineering: Just put up a tower and call it a day. And in Canada, antenna permits are federal. Once issued, local govs can't stop you from putting up your monstrosity of white panels on a midrise or a big metal antenna. But you don't have to just compare Canada against the USA. Australia or Iceland have rates that Canadians can only dream of, with similarly geo-population situations.
- SuperPaintMan 6y agoThere's a reason we fight hard for our crown corperations out here in Saskatchewan, if this was left to the market we would be screwed. The farther away from populated centers you get, the harder it is to get decent service however. I grew up out in Melville, SK where the fastest connections at the time were 15mbps DSL connections (this was around the time that Google Fiber was starting to roll out elsewhere). Once you get farther out, copper isn't even an option so cellular and satellite links are needed. The only nice thing about fiber is digging up ditches is relatively cheap Some of us are excited to see how systems such as StarLink develop, maybe bringing decent rural access to the network is in the cards. Next time you make a page that requires 10Mb of assets before loading, please remember there are people dealing with terrible connections. I know my first 100mbps connection was a godsend.
- blaser-waffle 6y ago+1 for SaskTel. I've done work for them on their monitoring systems, seemed like a decent org. More imporatanly, as someone in AB I am jealous of their cheap phone plans... > Australia or Iceland have rates that Canadians can only dream of, with similarly geo-population situations I worked on the NBN in Australia -- they've got their fair share of ISP-related issues down under.
- kevin_nisbet 6y agoI agree with you in concept, but I don't know that the geography fully explains the discrepancy. As an example, there are government incentives to do the build out to more rural areas, but that might be true in the US as well. We also tried to implement more carriers several years ago, with a wireless spectrum auction that reserved spectrum for new entrants. These startups tried to focus solely on urban areas with their build outs, and then could roam on the big 3, but struggled immensely. IIRC, one of the big complaints was we don't allow foreign ownership, which made it difficult to raise the immense capital needed for a proper build out. How much that plays into it I don't know, but unless Canadians want to put together a massive amount of capital it seems unlikely to force stronger competition.
- Scoundreller 6y agoWind mobile was doomed because they were issued 1.7ghz spectrum. That’s going to make any urban-area buildout prohibitively expensive because it doesn’t penetrate well.
- smachiz 6y agoThat's actually the inverse of the problem. Yes, 1.7Ghz doesn't penetrate well, but in cities you want density, because you have population density. Low band is still useful, but not nearly as advantaged as in rural areas. In rural areas, using 1.7Ghz vs 600Mhz or 700Mhz spectrum means building 4x the amount of towers to cover the same square miles. That's opex, capex *4. It's really expensive, with no benefits at all as you're not capacity constrained at all on radios/spectrum in rural areas.
- DarthGhandi 6y agoCanadian and US urbanisation rates are essentially identical. This isn't a case of looking at a map and population count whatsoever. It's an incredibly moot point when you look at where 95% of people live in both countries.
- snowwindwaves 6y agoCoverage coast to coast along highways is the same distance but 1/10 the Canadians?
- deepspace 6y agoAustralia has similar population size and density issues as Canada, and yet they manage to provide plans at 1/2 the price we pay here.
- sumedh 6y agoAustralia is similar as well, most of the population is in few cities with huge empty outback. The rates here are around 25 USD for unlimited text and calls with around 30 gigs of data.
- Reason077 6y agoRight now in the UK I’m paying £30/month for unlimited 5G data. 30 day contract, 5G roaming in many European countries. I’ve seen download speeds as high as 400 Mbps. Streaming games on my Mac from Google Stadia in perfect lag-free 1080p!
- linker3000 6y agoRight now in the UK I’m paying £8/month for 7GB 4G data, 30 day contract, EU roaming, unlimited calls and texts (Plusnet, SIM only). Which works for me because I am mostly on wifi or (current situation notwithstanding) on a very short commute.
- Reason077 6y agoIn my case, 5G is my WiFi! With the added benefit of being a battery-powered router (Huawei E6878) which I can take with me for fast WiFi wherever I need it. Why pay extra for wired broadband? (7GB data would be no good at all for me - I'd burn through that in about 30 minutes!)
- kingosticks 6y agoWow, thanks for that. I just realised I was still paying £9.50 a month to Plusnet for much less. Took just 2 minutes to login and update the tariff (reduced the data too since I no longer have a commute). I wish they'd do this automatically but obviously it's not in their interests.
- nicoburns 6y agoGiffgaff is really good about actually getting you on to a plan that suits you. They'll automatically update you to the latest plan at the price point you've set. They'll email you suggesting cheaper plan if you're not using all/most of your allowance. I've even had them gift me an extra GB of data when I went over my plan's allowance.
- Reason077 6y ago> ”Building and maintaining infrastructure for low-density population areas is extremely capital intensive.” The solution is to share infrastructure in sparsely populated areas where it would be uneconomic for each operator to build it's own. The UK, despite being vastly smaller and denser than Canada, has long had poor mobile coverage in rural areas. The UK government is now requiring (and contributing funding towards) geographical 95% coverage by 2026. Operators will use shared rural infrastructure to achieve this. https://www.mobileuk.org/shared-rural-network https://www.mobileuk.org/shared-rural-network https://www.gov.uk/government/news/shared-rural-network https://www.gov.uk/government/news/shared-rural-network
- arcticbull 6y agoIs it really though? I mean, it used to be. Rogers wants $75/mth (CAD - $55 USD) for 10GB data and unlimited talk and text. Let's compare to the US: - AT&T wants 65++ USD ($87 CAD) for a comparable plan. - Verizon wants 70++ USD ($94 CAD) for a comparable plan. - TMo wants 70 (all in) USD ($94 CAD) for a comparable plan. And each network in Canada is dramatically better than AT&T and TMo, and roughly comparable to Verizon. Back in the day, there was a huge difference, these days, it's kinda the same. I remember when the iPhone first came out and you could get an unlimited AT&T plan for $60/mth and Rogers wanted $120++. Those days are long past, though.
- giomasce 6y agoWow, in Belgium you can get the same for around 15 EUR and in Italy you can get 50 GB for less than 10 EUR...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deepspace 6y agoYes, the US is one of the highest priced mobile markets in the world, so it is not exactly fair to compare to them. The rest of the world pays far lower rates than the US and Canada.
- seotut2 6y agoAnd in Romania you get 50GB for 2 EUR (basically the plan is unlimited data, but with speed limited to 256kbps after 50GiB.). The speeds are quite good too, I personally reached 100Mbps on 4G on my phone in some places. The 5G plan includes 80GB traffic for the same package. ++++++++++ I'm actually using this 2EUR plan as my main internet service at the moment, as I temporarily moved to the country side. I could get a 1Gbps FTTH connection for around 10 EUR per month ( or cheaper for lower bandwidth), but so far I decided not to bother. 50GB did last me for 20 days, with a lot of video content, some repos downloaded, arch package updates etc. The 256kbps limit I'm experiencing now is more than ok for anything text-based but YouTube only works seamlessly/without buffering in 240p.
- simlevesque 6y agoDepends where you live. I pay 22$ CAD for a nice plan with 2gb, unlimited texts and voicemail. I'm with Fizz.
- Scoundreller 6y agoIt's good as a Canadian plan, but atrocious elsewhere in the world.
- simlevesque 6y agoWe are acutely aware.
- noizejoy 6y agoI’m seeing CAD 32 [0] [0] https://fizz.ca/en/mobile https://fizz.ca/en/mobile
- velox_io 6y agoThat isn't a lot of data, at 4G speeds (~35Mbps) that will last less than 10 minutes. What benefit is there to make it run out even faster? The biggest issue with 4G is the price, with 5G's limited range it will cost a fortune to roll out, so I doubt it will make data any cheaper. Don't get me wrong, 5G does have it's pros. Rolling it out to areas that are saturated totally makes sense (plus better wifi). I don't see the benefit of rolling it out everywhere when we're not even fully utilising 4G. My router is providing both 2.4ghz and 5ghz wifi; 2.4ghz for range and compatibility with the smart devices. 5Ghz for speed within a limited range.
- hylaride 6y agoI'm not by any means defending the Canadian telecoms, but I'll say one thing about the networks of the big 3: they are rock solid. While visiting Germany, I was impressed by the cheap prepaid data plans, but I only got EDGE in the rural areas and the LTE connections in the cities were not great. At the time I was playing Ingress and I quit in frustration. I was so irritated I even tried Vodafone after trying T-mobile. In the US* the connections aren't great, either. Not as bad as Germany, but in general I got slower practical speeds almost all over the country (and the big cities like NYC were terrible). In Canada I got excellent 4G performance when driving the whole way between Saskatoon and Calgary as well as any time I take the train between Toronto and Montreal. * I've been told Verizon is the best quality network in the States, but I have only been able to get prepaid plans from AT&T and T-Mobile.