7 ms·
I still don't understand why they thought they would get away with it. Did they think they could draw a confrontation with the publishers and somehow come out
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
I still don't understand why they thought they would get away with it.
Did they think they could draw a confrontation with the publishers and somehow come out victorious? Or that the publishers and their legal teams would voluntarily look the other way?
I still can't tell what their plan was. Or what point they were trying to make. Or how they expected to handle the legal challenge.
It's a shame that they tied this to the Internet Archive. I seriously doubt the people who donated to the IA wanted their funds to be used on this.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> I still don't understand why they thought they would get away with it This smells of a lack of risk management more than bad risk management.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoOr maybe they're getting exactly what they wanted. Maybe they let their political goals eclipse their IA goals, and they thought that tying this lawsuit to the life or death of the IA would force IA fans to donate?
- tsomctl 6y ago> I seriously doubt the people who donated to the IA wanted their funds to be used on this. I'm not annoyed that my donation is being used for this. I trust them to do what they think is best. Although I do have my doubts.
- Cerium 6y agoI'm in the same boat. I am considering donating more to help them, because I truly want the IA to succeed. I also have doubts and feel that this is the wrong fight at the wrong time.
- PragmaticPulp 6y ago> I am considering donating more to help them, because I truly want the IA to succeed. I'm beginning to suspect this is why they tied their actions to the IA in the first place. It's a good excuse to get people to donate who otherwise wouldn't support this action.
- mcguire 6y agoIt may be the wrong fight, but with physical libraries closed, it was definitely the right time. Perhaps they thought the situation would last longer?
- wl 6y agoThey could have partnered with those closed libraries and virtually lent out those copies. But they didn't.
- mark-r 6y agoI'm conflicted. The wayback machine is a huge good for the world, and I've donated in the past to support it. It would be a huge loss if it were to disappear. On the other hand I can't support stupidity, and picking a fight with the universe of book publishers is about the stupidest thing I've ever heard of.
- rolandog 6y agoI think they were considering being charitable by taking into account people's feelings and situations during a trans-national emergency. I myself borrowed an old book (which I already owned, but I wanted to compare differences among versions), turned a few pages, but then got distracted and didn't open it again (the virtual loan expired). I think it's a shame that people are trying to crucify an exemplary organization for doing a charitable act (no good deed goes unpunished, and all that). And, to be quite honest... Most of the books are at least 20 years old... So it's not like they were distributing best sellers that were actively being sold. I think it's a situation where publishers "are being forced" to be litigious, because they have an obligation to their shareholders to always take the option that yields more money; the Internet Archive just happened to leave themselves open to being a target, so they _have_ to do it. This reminds me a bit of Commander Chris Hadfield's cover of Space Oddity, and if I recall correctly, that David Bowie didn't own the rights to his own song and thus was unable to approve or deny an extension for Cmdr Hadfield's video on YouTube (and the controversy of the takedown).
- xhkkffbf 6y agoYeah, it's generally a great organization, but that doesn't mean you can't do bad things. When they announced it, I wrote a friend at the IA and told him it was a big mistake. I tried to get them to change their mind. They had plenty of warning and thought their good works would insulate them.
- marnett 6y ago> doesn't mean you can't do bad things They did bad things in regard to endangering their institution. There is nothing objectively, morally "bad" about the National Emergency Library though.
- xhkkffbf 6y agoIt is bad if you're an author. (Or if you're a reader who wants the authors to stay in business.)
- kick 6y ago> I still can't tell what their plan was. Or what point they were trying to make. Or how they expected to handle the legal challenge. I like the idea one of the Dreamwidth people threw up: it was probably intentionally aiming to bait a court case: https://twitter.com/rahaeli/status/1244257620548038656 https://twitter.com/rahaeli/status/1244257620548038656 (Thanks to 'Apocryphon for posting it originally on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22734145 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22734145 ) This doesn't necessarily seem out of line with something Brewster et al. would do, and it is the simplest explanation, so I tend to be on the side of it.
- nine_k 6y agoIt's a very reasonable explanation. I wonder what they had thought their chance of winning was at GHG height of the panic, and what is it now. I also wonder why would they risk their other, very valuable and unique work, knowing full well that the chance of turning bankrupt is definitely nonzero.
- musicale 6y ago> I still can't tell what their plan was If they win (seems unlikely?) they expand fair use. If they are destroyed, then they become a poster child for the excesses of $150K statutory damages.