3 ms·
I believe the entity that would have to bring any suit against Google would be the Free Software Foundation or their representatives. However, I don't believe
by joe_the_user 16y ago
I believe the entity that would have to bring any suit against Google would be the Free Software Foundation or their representatives.
However, I don't believe the FSF would have an interest in having an interface be declared copyrightable - just the opposite.
Most GPL suits are extremely forgiving. They give the party the option of removing the code or making it available.
The absolute worst case scenario I could imagine given this is that Google would be forced to make a "cleaner clean-room" implementation of the interface.
The last thing I could imagine the Free Software Foundation wanting is a demonstration that it is impossible to construct proprietary software that runs on Linux.
All this just has the feel of anti-Google FUD...
Edit: yes, gpl-violations.org seems to have done the last Linux I found of but I don't think any Free Software Entity wants to be Oracle's stalking horse against Google.
- kkowalczyk 16y agoNitpick: FSF doesn't own copyright to Linux kernel, Linux developers do. But your main message is right on: Linux kernel developers have no reason to sue Google for what at best is very minor issue.
- cschwarm 16y ago> The last thing I could imagine the Free Software Foundation wanting is a demonstration that it is impossible to construct proprietary software that runs on Linux. Not yet, maybe. Since he started his movement, Richard Stallman made it absolutely clear that he considers proprietary software to be evil in a literal sense of the word. He repeatably said it "should not exists" [1]. Recall that when Richard Stallman introduced the GPL for GNU, there was no LGPL. It was introduced later. Here's the announcement from the GNU bulletin [2]: "We should by now have finished a new alternative General Public License for certain GNU libraries. This license permits linking the libraries into proprietary executables under certain conditions. The new library license actually represents a strategic retreat. We would prefer to insist as much as possible that programs based on GNU software must themselves be free." Note also that any GNU system (and therefore Linux) is based on the GCC, distributed under the GPL. It's not just a compiler but also provides a runtime library that most programs need to link to when compiled by GCC. To make this possible, it has a special exception to the GPL. However, since the copyright is completely owned by the FSF, the exception can be revoked, anytime -- making it impossible to compile proprietary software with GCC (unless a fork proves to be viable). In other words, the FSF has the means and the motive to make proprietary software impossible to run under Linux. All they lack right now, is the political power -- that is, the opportunity to do so. [1] http://www.networkworld.com/news/2011/031411-richard-stallman.html?page=3 http://www.networkworld.com/news/2011/031411-richard-stallma... [2] http://www.gnu.org/bulletins/bull10.html#SEC6 http://www.gnu.org/bulletins/bull10.html#SEC6