4 ms·
Study Refutes the "Long Tail" Theory
- mattmaroon 18y agoChris Anderson's own blog has a post more or less debunking his own theory.
- dgreensp 18y agoThe article uses YouTube as an example of a new "cultural category" that has nevertheless settled into the old "winner-take-all dynamic". What??
- tuukkah 18y agoDepends on what they mean by a cultural category. User-generated, online, social, video content has new cultural aspects even if the popularity dynamic is old.
- khafra 18y agoYes, I can name several youtube competitors that do quite well, focusing on a specific niche youtube ignores (but I can't visit them from here at work).
- cwp 18y agoYeah, that's a bit bizarre. YouTube is a great example of the long tail in action. Instead of considering YouTube a hit compared to the rest of the web, consider its content. If I post a video of me and my friends goofing off at the beach, only a handful of people will watch it. But there are a ton of those "niche" videos available on YouTube. That's the long tail, and YouTube is successful precisely because it exploits the long tail of video.
- Anon84 18y ago> That's the long tail, and YouTube is successful precisely because it exploits the long tail of video. Considering how much money they lose everyday, I would argue that's why they are not successful (without the all mighty Google to pay the bills, of course).
- KevBurnsJr 18y agoLong Tail = Bubble ?
- coglethorpe 18y agoI listened to the audiobook of "The Long Tail" and maybe I misunderstood it. I thought it was showing how the internet can lead to better choices for consumers and give an outlet for niche content creators to sell their wares. In my mind it's done both. If it acts as a rising tide, lifting the fortunes of the head as well as the tail, all the better. There are big winners among sites, like YouTube, but there also are niche winners like TechCrunch which has done very well against big media companies by finding its niche. Not to mention places like Hacker News which I visit far more often then TechCrunch and YouTube combined.
- davidw 18y ago> "The Long Tail" seems to have followed the template of many Wired articles: take a partly true, modestly interesting, tech-friendly idea and puff it up to Second Coming proportions. That template is true for many business books, which is why sites like my own Squeezed Books, and others exist: it's easy to extract the meaningful bits.
- jackchristopher 18y agoI don't mean to go off topic, but thank you, that's a great site. Too many books are like padded out Wikipedia entries. Its great when people on HN, distill a post to its essentials.
- jraines 18y agoLet's review. The long tail exists because links and traffic on the web (roughly approximating attention/buying intent/market size) follow a power law. So of course there are still going to be hits that seem to be "winner take all"; if it weren't for the "fat head", we wouldn't need to talk about the long tail. The long tail becomes important in the age of the web because it's more accessible. Just because it's accessible doesn't mean it is going to make you rich -- but it's more possible than it was before the web. You really don't have to look very hard to find business that could not exist without the web. So the long tail as a "theory" is almost self-evident. So, I just don't understand what there is to refute or debunk.
- Goronmon 18y agoSo, I just don't understand what there is to refute or debunk. What the study is trying to debunk is that publishers/etc should cut down on their focus on the blockbuster hits and focus more on the "long tail" titles. From what the study is showing, doing the exact opposite may be the way to go.
- jraines 18y agoFair enough. However, it seems obvious that if you're capable of big hits, that's what you should be going for. But if, for example, your only competitive advantage is the acuteness of your awareness that big-footed women have trouble finding heels, then the Long Tail is your friend.
- giles_bowkett 18y agoIntellectual laziness. Study disputes Long Tail theory.