5 ms·
Google has largely made the internet a safer and more efficient system by pushing standards through their market dominance. Is this a bad thing?
by verdverm 6y ago
Google has largely made the internet a safer and more efficient system by pushing standards through their market dominance.
Is this a bad thing?
- MattGaiser 6y agoThere is always the trade-off between higher quality through what is essentially regulation and standards and squeezing out those who don't comply (which disadvantages new entrants). With drugs, we weight that trade-off heavily towards higher quality over new entrants. The question is, is that an acceptable trade off on the web? Reading this, I now think I should go put AMP on my personal blog. Before that, I needed an HTTPS cert. Before that, I needed to confirm I owned the site to Google. All things which may make the web better, but it certainly increases the operational burden and may discourage others from bothering in the first place.
- verdverm 6y agoPush a static site to netlify for free and all of this is taken care of you for free. The burden is necessary given the proliferation of bad actors I would not recommend AMP, but there are dozens of standards that are not part of what the public sees, low level enough they don't care to see. These are the important things Google has caused the world to adopt as best practices. You don't have to have http, but you are telling users you don't care about their security. This was largely pushed by green/red indicators in the URL bar.
- freedomben 6y ago> Push a static site to netlify for free and all of this is taken care of you for free. The burden is necessary given the proliferation of bad actors This heavily pushes the web toward centralization, which I see as a really bad thing, in many ways the cure is worse than the disease. It's happening in so many ways (have you tried standing up your own email server?) and this sort of thing drives it the hardest. I don't think Google is all bad, in fact I appreciate a lot of what they have done for the world (you mention some of these things). But as with nearly everything in life, it's complicated. I worry a lot that we're headed towards an internet where the individual is at the mercy of organizations to allow them to have a voice.
- luckylion 6y ago> The burden is necessary given the proliferation of bad actors But the bad actors don't really abuse technical standards. They abuse links. The only part in Google's list of criteria that has largely remained untouched in the last two decades and is still the factor for ranking. So much so, that I'm confident that, if ranking factor relevance was a search result, the first page would just be the same result over and over: Links. That's the reason for the centralization of power: those with more links will be ranked on the top, will have more visibility and, you guessed it, get more links. Guess what happens: they then start to sell either links or they rent out subdomains and folders on their website. Google, as a company, does not care about bad actors. Some teams in Google do, but they are not the ones setting the policies.
- kickscondor 6y agoMy biggest problem with Google is that in the 2010s they began flagging sites that had too many links as "link farms" - this discouraged bloggers from posting blogrolls and killed many directories. This really damaged the Open Web that the author is talking about. You saw a widespread abandonment of blogs during 2011-2015. (People stopped seeing traffic to their blogs and just assumed blogs had died due to lack of interest.) In a way, yeah, they made the Web safer. And cleared it out almost completely in the process.
- verdverm 6y agoWhat about the people who abuse Google search to promote bad things? Should Google not adjust their algorithms to demote bad or harmful content. There are two sides of the coin. Is it really much different from the security cat and mouse game?
- Covzire 6y agoNo, unless illegal.
- verdverm 6y agoIt is a private platform, correct? Would you prefer no search or what we had before Google? What would search look like of they did nothing? What would the world look like over the last 20 years?
- iseanstevens 6y agoI think Google is dipping below the standard of Altivista (adjusted for amount of content). It was out there you could find it but it it might take clever search strings. But it was a tool that worked for the user and priority was helping people find what they want. Vs helping people find what advertisers want now.
- giantrobot 6y agoYou can't really say "before Google" like they've been the same for twenty years. Google's search used to be really good. They would actually use what you typed in the search box to perform the search. Then Google started adding more portal-like features and using NLP to perform searches on what they wished you had entered in the search field. They also started tailoring search results to your past search history and whatever profile they constructed about you. Some people might want a natural language question answerer, others might want a search of only current events, but some definitely just want to search for content. Google has catered to the former at the expense of the latter. They try to stuff all their different modes into a single text box and display them on a single results page. There's no segmentation to clearly different functional modes. For me I'd love to see Google go back to actual web searches. Support Boolean operators and term quoting. Return me only search results without offering me shit they think I want to see. I abandoned Google as my main search engine in favor of DuckDuckGo years ago. While not perfect they at least show me actual search results. If I want other modes of search like video or news I can click those tabs but they don't force that content on me.
- mhh__ 6y agoWhat did Google ever do for us?
- buboard 6y agonah buddy, google is a leech in the way the Romans weren't. Not even a comparison, google is not taxing you it's stealing your content and your users
- verdverm 6y agoHow many Google services and systems do you rely on each day?
- dooglius 6y agoI'm pretty sure it's a reference to https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qc7HmhrgTuQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qc7HmhrgTuQ
- stonogo 6y agoMy answer is zero, but most people's answer is much larger. Having said that, how many Google services and systems are there for us?
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoNone. And I would not trust a service today that depends on any Google service either. I'll visit YouTube for free entertainment sometimes, but I hardly depend on it for anything, and I really wish more creators posted their content elsewhere, even at a price.
- solinent 6y ago
- asjw 6y agoYes Because of the market dominance
- verdverm 6y agoHow did they come to have that market dominance? I don't recall them advertising until recently
- reaperducer 6y agoHow did they come to have that market dominance? By purchasing potential competitors before they got big.
- asjw 6y agoEhmmm.... Google launched AdWords in 2000 But I agree, not your fault for not looking.
- buboard 6y agoBut google isn't pushing, it's baiting. And what you get is all websites look and act the same. A lot of creativity is falling through the cracks. And it's not just google. Why did we need og: tags and twitter:cards when meta tags are already there
- zapzupnz 6y agoIf by "made the Internet a safer and more efficient system" you mean "a non-stop barrage of Pinterest results", sure.
- verdverm 6y agoThat is not what I meant, please see my other comments.