8 ms·
Facebook employees stage virtual walkout in protest of company’s stance
- adpirz 6y ago> Employees participating in the protest requested time off and then added an out-of-office response to their emails notifying senders they are protesting, The New York Times reports. Facebook has since acknowledged the walkout and said it will not require employees to use their paid time off. Is this really a protest when it amounts to a no-penalty day off from the very employer you're protesting?
- renewiltord 6y agoWell, no bastard ever successfully protested by imposing a cost on himself. He successfully protested by imposing a cost on some other dumb bastard. The ideal protest applies amplified damage to the other guy at low cost to yourself. I hope The Zuck stays strong, though. Let everyone speak.
- adpirz 6y ago> by imposing a cost on himself What would you say to people who have been arrested, beaten, or in some cases, even lost their lives in protests like these and those before it?
- frabbit 6y agoThat they stood up for something and paid a high price for it which made their protest more potent to many people?
- geodel 6y agoThat its good on them. Unlike these FB virtual protesters who will not put virtual mask and put their virtual health in danger to show they "stand" for something.
- renewiltord 6y agoThat they won or lost by the cost they imposed on the other guy, not the cost that was imposed on them. If they could have imposed the same cost without actually dying, they would still have won or lost.
- mc32 6y agoActivists want to eat their cake and have it too. On the one hand they say platforms may exercise “their” free speech by moderating posts or banning people and that’s okay because it’s a private co. and not obliged to be platform for everyone. Then on the other hand a different company also exercises its free speech (under their own argument) by not moderating posts and now that’s bad because some speech should be moderated and they disagree with those voices. So like basically they’re for corporate free speech when they agree with the controls but are against it when they disagree with the results. Just say it. We only want to allow our approved views — we don’t want free speech. And not only that but they protest free speech but totally don’t walk out when they unscrupulously slurp up data on everyone.
- joshuamorton 6y agoI acknowledge Facebook's right to not moderate such things. And support the laws that give Facebook that freedom. I think it's morally reprehensible and therefore support Facebook's employees movement to work to change Facebook's actions. These are not contradictory views.
- mc32 6y agoFree speech is morally reprehensible or just speech you disagree with? If we’re talking about the president’s post, look, there are people on the other side who also post things more incendiary are those reprehensible too? Or is it because we disagree with the poster? I don’t see how you square FB having that right but simultaneously disagreeing with what happens when they exercise that right.
- Talanes 6y agoYou don't understand AT ALL how someone could want an organization to make a choice, but not want the government to make that choice for them? I don't think people should wear socks with sandals, and I will not hesitate to tell them that should I see it. I'll still be the first protesting if the government starts making them take off their socks.
- thoraway1010 6y agoSo - the tesla driving facebookers get a day off from work - paid - not even using their vacation - and this is a walkout? Are they forfeiting their stock to protest facebooks offensive conduct? This is the look at me style of protesting. Quit your job and work a better company if you think facebook is a scum company.
- GaryNumanVevo 6y ago<parody> Even better, if you're a production engineer at FB reading this. Please erase a few database VM sets on the way out. </parody>
- geodel 6y agoErasing virtual machines to support virtual protest. Now that is very virtual.
- chickenpotpie 6y agoThe whole point of a walkout is to cost the company money. If they forfeited their stocks and used up vacation time it wouldn’t be nearly as effective. Also why go straight to quitting when you can keep your job and change the company?
- taurath 6y agoIt also less effective when one isn't shutting down a production line. The underlying business doesn't need new code shipped constantly - just the NOC employees to be paying attention. Facebook makes the same revenue on a day when half their employees walk off.
- geodel 6y agoChange the company? Is this an amateur hour? I do not know at this point that is FB fooling its employees or its employees are fooling the world.
- thoraway1010 6y agoThis I think illustrates nicely how privileged and out of touch Facebook engineers are. --- I demand the right to protest my own employer. Facebook: Sure I demand the right to take unplanned time off to protest even if it disrupts operations. Facebook: Sure I demand to post my feelings on my company email autoreply so other employees and customers are informed of my opinion via company resources. Facebook: Sure. I demand to get paid for my time off. Facebook: Sure - we give you lots of generous PTO and don't really track you that carefully in terms of hours worked. I demand to get paid for my unplanned time designed to disrupt operations to protest my employers actions and post my feelings on company email including communication with customers / partners and get paid for this WITHOUT using PTO (but as regularly working hours). Facebook: Sure!! ----- Wow!!
- justchilly 6y agoDozens of employees. Put in PTO. Facebook has 44k+ Employees. There are protests going on across the US/World. If anything the news should be how few employees are part of this.
- sys_64738 6y agoThey're virtually quitting their jobs by the sounds of it.
- dang 6y agoUrl changed from https://techcrunch.com/2020/06/01/facebook-employees-stage-virtual-walkout-in-protest-of-companys-stance-on-trump-posts/ https://techcrunch.com/2020/06/01/facebook-employees-stage-v..., which points to this.
- vsareto 6y ago>Silence is complicity I'd like to point out that the argument that you must choose a side or you're an enemy is a farce and bullying tactics (which is behind the spirit of this statement). Both sides can say this. Meaning, of course, they are both wrong because I cannot be complicit in both sides of this at the same time. Participation is optional. Non-participation implies silence. Silence is not complicity.
- MarkLowenstein 6y agoExcellent logic vsareto. It's hard to verbalize what you have done here so well...which is why they choose this weird phraseology to begin with. Netflix told me that I was complicit in this same way yesterday--so I canceled my subscription. Goodbye Netflix!
- TechBro8615 6y agoIt would be a more powerful statement if they were actually sacrificing something. Instead, they're taking a day off from their cushy $200k/year jobs that they're too scared to quit. If they really care so much about a lack of censorship, they could show it by quitting. But then how will they pay for their $3k/month SoHo lofts and their twelve person birthday dinners in Williamsburg? It's amusing to me when these overpaid employees think they're some kind of last bastion of intellectualism, looking out for the common man, when in fact they could not be more disconnected from reality, and comprise one of the most gullible flocks of sheep on the planet. Their mindset makes for the perfect employee, really.
- shaan1 6y agoCorrect, these guys want to have the cake and eat it too. If they don't like Facebook, they should just leave. They want the money. Its too attractive to them.
- KaiserPro 6y agoSome background Some head of content made a post defending not enforcing the rules on trump. Trump made a post that incorrectly stated how registration for mail in votes work in california They wrote 8+ paragraphs of nonsense, starting with "we have seen some upsetting videos, [..] we hope it spurs change" However, even though we know this post clearly violates our community standards, we're going to allow it, because well, he's trump. Then the post about "looting and shooting" which also violates the community standards as well: > Statements advocating for high-severity violence; or > Aspirational or conditional statements to commit high-severity violence The post came out, and people were already pissed off, knowing that something they were working on was partially responsible for the ratcheting up of violence. Twitter had given facebook cover to enforce it's own rules. but the management "team" chose not to. Zuckfuck then said "I'm going to spend $10mil on an indulgence" "stop hassling me, I'm not going to give in to employee pressure." (paraphrase) Then the head of HR made another long rambling post devoid of content along the lines of: "zuck has spaffed $10m on un specified charity for the black people what more do you want [..] blah blah blah freedom of expression" The management keep on banging on about "private companies shouldn't censor" If you have a set of community standards which are plain and well written, enforce them equally. Whats in them is up for debate, but we haven't got that far yet, because we seem to be allowing any politician to say what they like (from either side of the debate) THey don't seem to have noticed that the media have always been deciding what to publish, ever since thomas paine was wafting around being his annoying autistic self.
- sixstringtheory 6y agoA thought experiment regarding the "just quit" argument: You're placed in a room with a person who is raving about homicidal fantasies. A gun is placed in the middle of the room. You don't think they should have access to this gun because of their statements. Is the solution to: 1) leave the room 2) try to get control of the gun before they do Facebook is a tool, the same as that gun.
- bhl 6y agoThis is a bad thought experiment, because a solution could be to empty the gun and then to leave the room.
- sixstringtheory 6y agoYou'd have to gain control of the gun before them in order to empty it.
- dnissley 6y agoYou can certainly make a case for facebook being a weapon, but you could just as easily make a case that it's not. This is a terrible thought experiment that has us assume the former without considering the latter.
- sixstringtheory 6y agoI didn't mean to make the case that Facebook a weapon. I even said > Facebook is a tool, the same as that gun. But I chose a weapon to try to show something with high impact that is simple to understand. Try it with an unhappy neighbor, a tree on your property line and a set of garden shears.
- GoodJokes 6y agoDOZENS
- throwawaysea 6y agoWhenever the 'protesters' are counted in one of these activist employee actions, the numbers tend to be exaggerated. They say dozens, and I will take it to mean a couple dozen at best. Even so, this is a company with tens of thousands of employees. Why should leadership care about their voice, and why should outlets like NY Times amplify this message without any honest attempt to find differing views? These activist employees enjoy psychological safety from taking on views that align with the political culture surrounding them - namely progressive far left political views that are common in the Bay Area, Seattle, etc. But the reality is, there are still many employees, both who are progressive and otherwise, that would prefer that the company take a nuanced, preferably neutral stance on these matters. They aren't speaking up because they are either busy or afraid of social/professional fallout (due to the prevailing views at these companies about Trump). The only way to understand the true sentiment of the employee base is to take an anonymous poll of them, so that psychological safety is not an issue. Otherwise, what we'll see, and have been seeing at these big tech companies, is a tyranny of the vocal minority.