5 ms·
Rent control has a lot of unintended consequences. It is supposed to be a short term band-aid for bad zoning policies, but the zoning policies actually have to
by jedberg 6y ago
Rent control has a lot of unintended consequences. It is supposed to be a short term band-aid for bad zoning policies, but the zoning policies actually have to be fixed if you want to remove the band-aid.
- sjg007 6y agoI imagine there will be lawsuits on effective rent vs published rent. Imagine paying an official rent of $2400 but you get an extra month free for every rent payment. Your effective rent is then $1200. These types of teasers aren't within the spirit of the law. In fact, maybe they are already prohibited in the statute.
- jedberg 6y agoThe law specifically excludes discounts in fact: " In determining the lowest gross rental amount pursuant to this section, any rent discounts, incentives, concessions, or credits offered by the owner of such unit of residential real property and accepted by the tenant shall be excluded. " Civil code section 1947.12.
- sjg007 6y agoSeems like a loophole ripe for abuse.
- 0xffff2 6y agoJust like everything else, it's a two way conversation. The discounts have to happen with the tenant's knowledge and agreement. If you don't like it don't rent from a landlord who plays those games. If every landlord is playing extreme games with discounts to game the rent control law, it only points to the deeper problems that we all know exist but refuse to fix.
- sjg007 6y agoI'll rent to you at $5000 a month with a $4k discount month to month. That discount is renewable solely at managements discretion after 12 months. Seems egregious.
- 0xffff2 6y agoYeah, and if someone made me that offer on my current ($2k/month) apartment, I would turn it down despite it being a 50% discount because I don't want the uncertainty of having to move in a year. This is not a problem if both parties know up front. The only way it becomes a problem is if I think I'm renting an apartment for $1k/month and then a year later my landlord says "Oh, actually your rent was $5000/month but you had the $4000/month move-in discount for the first year, your rent is now $5250/month".
- sjg007 6y agoRight but when the market becomes red hot again why would they not? I think this will only impact units that fall under rent control more generally though.
- jedberg 6y agoIt's almost as if the law was amended by real estate lobbyists...
- refurb 6y agoWhat would happen if you included discounts as a part of rent control? I think you'd find more landlord's saying "no" when asked for a rent decrease.
- conanbatt 6y agoI'm willing to bet you more than a beer that a large share of people under rent-control are high earners.
- chrischen 6y agoRent control is trumpeted as some sort of protection for low-income people, but it actually has no such provisions that make it available to, or targets such people. The only beneficiaries of rent-control are people who happen to be incumbent residents.
- hkt 6y agoMuch if its value is in protecting existing communities who would be displaced by rising rents, so yeah, it favours incumbents.
- chrischen 6y agoI think existing communities is interchangeable with incumbent residents. There are probably better ways to protect mass displacement of low-income residents since rent control only applies to certain really old buildings. Preserving the community in itself is not a bad thing to do but a lot of these policies have also been blocking the building of higher density housing, which could satisfy everyone (keep old residents AND let in new residents).
- jonahbenton 6y ago...who are low/fixed income at the time. "Affordable housing" is a completely separate issue.
- imtringued 6y agoAlso incumbent landlords who are sitting on paid off properties. A landlord with an old building has less vacancies if he doesn't have to compete with new construction.
- 6y ago
- qqqwerty 6y agoIn defense of rent control, it provides a stabilizing force during a downturn. How many folks who live in an apartment that has been under rent control for 10+ years are packing up and moving into their parents basement right now? My guess is very few. It certainly has its issues, but there are much worse market distorting policies that I would like to see be fixed before rent control gets put on the chopping block.
- jonahbenton 6y agoRent control in NYC also enormously important for elderly population, which has been systematically exploited by owners for centuries. It is absolutely not in owner interests. But cities by and large have been built in accordance with owner interests.
- landryraccoon 6y agoI’m not sure this is a good argument. What landlords would try to raise rents or evict aggressively during a recession? Rent control prevents rents from aggressively dropping because landlords know the rents can’t be increased later. This is during a time when rents really need to go down.
- Psyonic 6y agoNot the OP, but I think his point was people aren't ending their lease and moving home til covid is over, because if they did, they wouldn't be able to get that low of rent again.
- nickik 6y agoIt helps the people in the apparent and hurts everybody else. Doesn't really change in a recession.