4 ms·
You do not use violence in a democratic protest. To use it is effective acknowledgement that you either want to destroy the democracy or do not believe that it
by marcosdumay 6y ago
You do not use violence in a democratic protest. To use it is effective acknowledgement that you either want to destroy the democracy or do not believe that it actually exists on the moment.
- evanlivingston 6y agoThe American revolution was a violent protest.
- marcosdumay 6y agoYes, and the people participating on it were pretty sure they weren't living in a democracy. I imagine that many people on those current protests believe they aren't in one either (or, at least, if one exists they are cast out of it). I'm in no position to judge if they are right, but on the case they are not, violence is no means to do a democratic protest.
- throwaway894345 6y agoAgainst a tyrannical, non-representative government, and it was a last-ditch effort. We have a democracy. People have opportunities to vote. Police policy is decided largely at the local level, so individual votes are powerful. Imagine if even 10% of protesters voted in their local elections...
- Mediterraneo10 6y agoLocal elections can be rigged against local voters. I wish I could find the link now, but I recall reading an article recently (was it in The Atlantic?) about how one American town with a huge African-American population was unable to get a single African-American councilman elected, because back in the heyday of segregation the local whites had managed to do some gerrymandering-like trick that made most local citizens’ votes now count for nothing. You can also see dirty tricks at local council meetings, where those in authority abuse the meeting’s rules of order to quickly shut down anyone speaking up about problems that those in authority don’t want addressed.
- standardUser 6y agoWhy would you think that the voter turnout among protestors is less than 10%? That seems absurd and at least a little offensive.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y agoIt was actually seeking to overthrows the government, and it was treason from the eyes of the British. If the British had won, likely every one of the signers of the Declaration of Independence would have been hanged or worse. If you want to change the way things are inside the system vote, organize, protest. But actually seeking to overthrow the government is opening a whole can of very, very bad things.
- standardUser 6y agoGay rights, women's rights, civil rights were all won by combating unjust power using every tool available, including violence. Oppressors don't self-limit the tools they'll use to maintain power. Neither can those who are oppressed.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- vzidex 6y ago>do not believe that it actually exists on the moment Precisely. People have been voting and non-violently protesting for decades, and it hasn't worked.
- eanzenberg 6y agoHow has it not worked?
- caterama 6y agoRemind me again... how do we elect presidents that don't win the popular vote?
- throwaway894345 6y agoPeople haven't been voting, which is why it hasn't worked.
- TomBombadildoze 6y agoMany of the people for whom the system "hasn't worked" have only had the statute right to vote for a generation, yet still face de facto barriers to exercise their right. For them, the system has never worked. You keep spouting bullshit absolutes but don't seem to realize (or you're just unwilling to accept) that there are effectively two systems; a more of less functioning system for people like you, and one in name only for the disenfranchised.
- throwaway894345 6y ago> You keep spouting bullshit absolutes but don't seem to realize (or you're just unwilling to accept) that there are effectively two systems; a more of less functioning system for people like you, and one in name only for the disenfranchised. Look, you’re not here in good faith. That’s cool, go off all you want, but I’m not here for it. Find someone else.
- sacred_numbers 6y ago
- ryandrake 6y ago> You do not use violence in a democratic protest. Tell that to the police. The current "don't use violence" rhetoric is cleverly being aimed at the protestors and seems to be giving a consistent pass to the other side's behavior. In many cases, these guys are suited up like shock troops, visibly excited and ready to bust skulls, and when they're unleashed they are going to find skulls (peaceful or not) to bust. This is a system that only knows how to use violent escalation to solve problems, and lo and behold, they're out there bringing on the violence. The protests are about police brutality, and the police are coming in and using the only tool they know: brutality. But it's OK because someone somewhere else is burning down a Target? > To use it is effective acknowledgement that you either want to destroy the democracy or do not believe that it actually exists on the moment. From your wording you seem to be agreeing that the police also "want to destroy the democracy".
- moolcool 6y ago> democratic protest It seems like the protestors have lost faith in the democratic process. Can you still call it a democratic protest?
- afiori 6y agoThen is it a revolution? What is the plan? The want to secede Minneapolis? It is either a democratic protest, domestic terrorism, or a civil war. I hope with all my being that it is a democratic protest.
- krapp 6y agoIt's the same justification many people used for voting for Trump, which was that?
- afiori 6y agoI am sorry, I am a bit lost, but if Trump election had to be one of those three it would have been a democratic protest against the establishment. Or were you referring to something else?
- krapp 6y agoMany Trump supporters (primarily the alt-right and white supremacist fringe) didn't simply protest against the establishment, and certainly didn't intend to do so democratically (as that would imply a belief in the legitimacy of the system and the views of their opponents.) They voted with the intent of seeing the system destroyed and an ethnostate emerging from the rubble. Reasonable people can disagree about the size and relative influence of this contingent on the election, but it exists. Drawing too many parallels between that and the protestors would be unfair, particularly where motive is concerned, but it is hard not to notice the energy is the same in a lot of ways. One side doing violence against the system and another doing violence against infrastructure, each because they feel the system has been irreparably damaged by the influence of the other.