12 ms·
This article seems to be based on only a few transactions, as not a lot of people are actually moving right now. I manage a couple of properties in the Bay Are
by jedberg 6y ago
This article seems to be based on only a few transactions, as not a lot of people are actually moving right now.
I manage a couple of properties in the Bay Area, so I keep a close eye on these things. What I'm seeing is not a drop in rents, but an increase in $0 deposits and many weeks of free rent upon move in (sometimes 6+ weeks).
Landlords are very reluctant to lower rents, because with the statewide rent control that limits increases to 5% a year, we're incentivized to keep the rents high and give months of free rent, just so our base rate doesn't drop.
- notyourwork 6y ago> Landlords are very reluctant to lower rents, because with the statewide rent control that limits increases to 5% a year, we're incentivized to keep the rents high and give months of free rent, just so our base rate doesn't drop. How is it that Mission Bay apartments are not subject to these rent control regulations if this is state wide? Asking because when I lived in Mission Bay, UDR properties each year tried increasing my rent much higher than this.
- ejcx 6y agoMission Bay apartments were built after 1979 (or whatever the exact date is). It's all new construction, which isn't subject to rent control: https://www.sftu.org/rent-control/ https://www.sftu.org/rent-control/
- creddit 6y agoNot starting in 2019: https://la.curbed.com/2019/9/24/20868937/california-rent-control-law-bill-governor https://la.curbed.com/2019/9/24/20868937/california-rent-con...
- creddit 6y agoBuilding needs to be 15yrs old
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jedberg 6y agoThe law just passed last year, mostly in response to exactly what happened to you. Also there are a lot of exemptions, one big one being that the building needs to be 15 years old to be subject to the law.
- BigCatStuff 6y agoStatewide rent control in California wasn't enacted until January 1, 2020 (with a retroactive period of several months I believe). So, if you rented before Jan 1, and your rental unit was built after 1979, it wasn't covered by any rent control. Landlords could raise rent as much as they wanted on those types of units.
- notyourwork 6y agoThanks for clarifying, I wasn't aware this is a recent change.
- rootedbox 6y agoI live on 22 block Valencia.. I've had 4 neighbors move out in the past month. So as far as price.. I can't say. But as far as folks moving out. I can.
- jedberg 6y agoPeople are moving out but not in. Move-ins determine the rental market price.
- foxtr0t 6y agoThis is an oversimplification of already simple market dynamics. What sets the market is the supply and demand. If demand drops sharply after an event like covid-19 and supply is held constant, prices will go down except in extremely distorted markets like the ones ISPs and telcos play in.
- jedberg 6y agoThere are two parties to the transaction. The market clearing rate is set when the two parties agree. When one party is not showing up, there is no market clearing rate. The intrinsic value may in fact be down, but there is no way to know for sure without two parties in the transaction.
- pascalxus 6y agoOver time, he's right in principle. But maybe, there just hasn't been enough time yet for it to play out. if we're seeing price declines, then it's already playing out.
- tedivm 6y agoMy coworkers in Berkeley are all telling their property managers that they need to either lower the rent or they're not going to renew. Once the UC system said they weren't opening back up for physical classes in the fall demand for places near campus dropped considerably. My landlord hasn't lowered rent, but to incentivize us to stay he replaced our washing machine and upgraded some stuff around the property. That being said if my company ends up going fully remote (which looks likely) I'll probably be leaving the bay area anyways.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- vmchale 6y ago> Landlords are very reluctant to lower rents, because with the statewide rent control that limits increases to 5% a year, we're incentivized to keep the rents high and give months of free rent, just so our base rate doesn't drop. God what a short-sighted policy. Not that I expect rent control to go well but that's nuts.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 6y agoThere's a reason rent-control is almost universally despised among economists. That said, of all the rent-control policies I've seen, I think the least-bad is what they've been using in Spain: no rent increases for 5 years after move-in, then increases are only allowed every 3 years after that. They've implemented a time-based stabilizing mechanism, instead of an arbitrary percentage-based cap. Moving is a huge cost for a tenant, so if a landlord raises rents every year, expecting people to be able to move every year to a fairly-priced place is insanity. But, I do think most people can handle a move every 5 years to a cheaper neighborhood if they need to.
- jedberg 6y agoRent control has a lot of unintended consequences. It is supposed to be a short term band-aid for bad zoning policies, but the zoning policies actually have to be fixed if you want to remove the band-aid.
- sjg007 6y agoI imagine there will be lawsuits on effective rent vs published rent. Imagine paying an official rent of $2400 but you get an extra month free for every rent payment. Your effective rent is then $1200. These types of teasers aren't within the spirit of the law. In fact, maybe they are already prohibited in the statute.
- jedberg 6y agoThe law specifically excludes discounts in fact: " In determining the lowest gross rental amount pursuant to this section, any rent discounts, incentives, concessions, or credits offered by the owner of such unit of residential real property and accepted by the tenant shall be excluded. " Civil code section 1947.12.
- yalogin 6y agoIts just another way of saying landlords need to incentivize renters. So the market has definitely changed. I feel this is a stopgap measure and that rents must come down eventually. At that point the incentives will stay too.
- jedberg 6y agoDuring the last downturn in 2008, only the highest rents in SF dropped. The rest of the Bay Area just stayed flat for a few years. This downturn may be different because of the shift to work-from-anywhere in tech, but it will be interesting to see. A lot of people like their tech offices, with their free lunches and snacks and gyms and coffee and so on.
- mv4 6y agoPeople liking their tech offices won't be the deciding factor here. The tech companies like the prospects of hiring people on completely different terms now, outside of the Bay Area. Expect things to change dramatically.
- raincom 6y agoThat's the first step, and this has happened many times before. No REIT drops rents; instead, they offer "$0 deposit", "no rent for the first 45 days", etc. Once these tricks are exhausted, rents will drop. The issue is: how long does it take for these tricks to exhaust?
- ksec 6y agoAnd its the perfect time to build more housing. If those tricks dont exhaust, you can then apply pressure with additional supplies. Given Housing is now primarily an investment rather than a home for everybody. I would guess most government would likely not pass such proposal.
- jedberg 6y agoIn 2008 rents in the Bay Area just stayed flat for a few years except in the most expensive parts of SF. So in 2008 at least, those incentives were enough. This time may be different though, with a fundamental shift to work-from-anywhere for tech companies.
- nostrademons 6y agoIn 2009 rents dropped rapidly in Mountain View. I moved here in early '09 and my employer paid a realtor to show me around for a day. Told him my budget was $2000/month, and asked about a fairly swanky mostly-corporate-housing-but-a-few-individual-tenants complex. "Oh, that one's out of your price range", he said. Ended up taking an apartment there for $1400/month six months later, and it stayed at that level for 3 years. (And then shot up rapidly afterwards - I left when it hit $2400/month 5 years later, and it's currently renting for $2900/month.) It had gone down so rapidly that its price was underneath the less-swanky complex a block down the street which normally rented for ~$300/month less and had itself cut rents from about $1800/month to $1450/month over those 6 months. Rents are sticky - landlords try to avoid cutting if they don't have to. But when there's a choice between letting the apartments go vacant and servicing your debt payments, they have to cut, and if there's a shortage of tenants at that time (because everybody's left and gone home) the cuts can be pretty drastic.
- billjings 6y agoMy friends in property management tell me that people are indeed moving. My neighbor had a turnover just last month. Job losses plus no rent relief pretty much require that people will move.
- jedberg 6y agoPeople are moving out but not in. Move-ins set the rental rate. A lot of people are leaving for lower cost areas or to move in with family.
- dan-robertson 6y agoNot everyone is stuck at home with no income. If I were working in the Bay Area for a company that was still doing ok, and I were already planning to move around now, I would definitely see this as an opportunity to get a good deal on rent by moving. Maybe some other people are thinking this. Or maybe they are thinking that there is no point moving elsewhere in the Bay Area and are moving further out. Though I would certainly expect the number of transactions to decrease a lot.
- jedberg 6y agoUp until the new modified shelter in place orders, you couldn't move unless your lease expired or you already had the move planned. Also moving companies were allowed to stay open if they provided their movers with PPE, so many chose to shut down. So for the most part people just couldn't move, even if they wanted to.
- dan-robertson 6y agoBut if few people are moving anyway (for reasons above) then it doesn’t matter if there are fewer moving companies because of the above. Obviously some people are moving or the OP wouldn’t have been written
- nostromo 6y ago6 weeks free rent is a 10% drop in rent for that year though, which is in line with what the article says. Obviously landlords are hoping that it's a temporary measure, but who knows what next year will bring.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pmiller2 6y agoPeople not moving is literally the problem. This is part of a broader negative demand shock in the economy at large. Where exactly do you expect people without jobs, or with significantly reduced income to move to?
- jedberg 6y ago> Where exactly do you expect people without jobs, or with significantly reduced income to move to? I mean I personally hope that the government steps in and helps them stay where they are, but that will also keep rents artificially high and would be a transfer of wealth from the treasury to landlords. So pros and cons. Realistically what seems to be happening is people are moving to lower cost areas within California or outside the state, or moving in with family.
- pmiller2 6y agoYou've missed or failed to acknowledge the actual point I was making. I think any reasonable person would agree that forcing double digit millions of people out of their homes is a very undesirable outcome. Most of those people would agree that something needs to be done (exactly what being dependent on one's political and economic ideology). Many of those people would probably also agree that the government is the one that needs to do something, simply because almost all political ideologies agree that one of the purposes of government is to do things that private citizens cannot. Let's just agree on this, unless I'm grossly misinterpreting what you're saying. What I'm actually saying is that you can't simultaneously agree that "people aren't moving to SF," and that "the market is fine, because it's a thin market and these prices reflect very few transactions." The latter is a consequence of the former, and the root cause of both is that people just don't have the money to move. This, in combination with the coronavirus eviction moratorium in California, leads me to believe that people aren't moving anywhere, not that they're moving to lower cost areas. I hope I'm wrong, because unless the government steps in with something radical like a debt jubilee, those people staying in their SF apartments with no income and incurring debt are just going to suffer more down the road.
- war1025 6y ago> we're incentivized to keep the rents high and give months of free rent. That's basically a fancy way of lowering the rate, right? Our friends just bought a new house in a development and the builder did a similar game where they added in some bells and whistles instead of coming down on the price. Their reasoning was that they couldn't drop the price because that's public data and it would put pressure on them to accept lower prices from other buyers in the neighborhood.
- jedberg 6y agoIt is, but it doesn't affect the base rate, so it allows a bigger increase when things get better again, because the increase limit is a percent of the current rent (not including discounts).
- rainyMammoth 6y agoThe only reason rents are not dropping yet is human psychology. Landlords don't want to accept that rents need to go down so they leave it up at the same price even if it means that places go vacant for multiple months. In a perfect market rents would be down 15/20% already.
- ilyaeck 6y agoDoesn't an increase in $0 deposits and many weeks of free rent constitute a drop in effective prices?
- raincom 6y agoYes, if you want to move out once the lease is over. No, if you want to stay for another lease term.
- tmpz22 6y agoI'm moving to a new location in SF and I'm seeing rents plummet. My landlord dropped rents across the board by about %20 (after ignoring my email for a rent decrease...). My new apartment is a pretty big down size but is nearly 1/3 of my previous. Rental groups on Facebook are showing a similar decrease in pricing. More anecdata, but as a resident who IS moving I really disagree with your take - we're probably both right in different ways.
- jotto 6y agoCurious, from what neighborhood to what neighborhood?
- tmpz22 6y agoTenderloin, I mainly looked in the Russian Hill / Marina / Lower Pac heights areas for private 1 bedroom situations in 2/3 additional roomates. I ended up going for a place in the Presidio. For the most part the opportunities I was seeing were for subleases where a tenant moved out hurriedly, which seems to be VERY common right now. FWIW all private room + 2/3 roomate situations were in the range of $1200 - $1500 vs. my current 1 bed room apartment (no roomates) @ ~$2800 previously.
- ccktlmazeltov 6y agoWeird question, but how is it living in the Tenderloin?
- tmpz22 6y agoNot weird - though its really just the same as downtown SF: 2-5 days a week you will have some combination of a screaming and manic individual immediately in your walking path, see someone injecting themselves immediately in your vicinity, and nearly (or actually) step in dog/human poop. It by no means is the end of the world but over time it wears you down and desensitizes you to the point of completely ignoring all homeless activity always. After being here for ~2 years I would not recommend the TL because the cost savings and walking commute to downtown are not enough given alternative choices. If you need to save money you need to move further away to realize real savings, there are too many hidden fees living in the city. If you have money you'll want to either live in 0-commute distance i.e. near the embarcadero or in literal downtown, or live in the Marina / Presidio / Anywhere else and have a 15 minute drive in.
- alexpotato 6y agoThe same thing happened in Manhattan back in 2008 due to the financial crisis. - 13 month rents for the price of 12 - $0 deposits - etc In practice, this meant that a lot of young people who were living in Brooklyn decided to move back into Manhattan. This was one of the main driving forces behind the transition of the Financial District (basically almost the southern tip of Manhattan) from an office only area to a residential area. I actually knew someone who lived in an "apartment" building that had been converted from an office building. The layout was of an apartment but if you looked up you saw the classic perforated drop ceiling tiles of an office.