7 ms·
From the outside (I'm in the UK) the US looks really bad right now. I know plenty of people who have completely ruled out visiting.
by onion2k 6y ago
From the outside (I'm in the UK) the US looks really bad right now. I know plenty of people who have completely ruled out visiting.
- moduspol 6y agoConsider looking beyond the most sensationalized news coverage.
- xenyal 6y agoConsider looking at the CNN reporting team that was arrested live on television without reason? It's not a good sign if media is being censored like that.
- moduspol 6y agoTrue. Media coverage of these protests has been basically a blackout. We've heard almost nothing. C'mon. Of course they shouldn't have been arrested, but it's not some systemic suppression.
- nl 6y agoThere are at least 20 cases of credentialed journalists being attacked or arrested by police in the last 48 hours. While a few of these may have been mistaken identity, many weren't. https://twitter.com/N_Waters89/status/1267037176614838272 https://twitter.com/N_Waters89/status/1267037176614838272
- aww_dang 6y agoPeople can pick and choose where they stand on this incident or perhaps even choose not to participate in the partisan dialectic. I'd just like to point out that the opposing view on that incident would characterize it as exactly the kind of sensationalized coverage which the above poster could be referring to. One narrative suggests that it was staged. Worth looking at it from both sides. As we discuss this, let's not steam roll past those concerns. My personal view is that there's more than a little BS flying from all angles. CNN wouldn't be what I consider hard hitting or informative journalism. I don't know what really happened and I can't jump to any conclusions. Thanks.
- adjkant 6y agoSee other threads, but this is not an isolated incident. Trying to argue that it was staged seems incredibly disingenuous and an unreasonable standard of proof given the widespread occurrences of this and police brutality in the past 48 hours. https://twitter.com/GravelInstitute/status/1266929927116468225 https://twitter.com/GravelInstitute/status/12669299271164682...
- aww_dang 6y agoJust to be explicit, I don't take sides, I'm not interested in advancing any argument and I am skeptical of most claims. This goes doubly so for the extreme partisan takes, which are generally unreasonable. I'm sorry this disclaimer is seemingly necessary. My personal views are secondary to the point of my comment, which was: Perhaps we should consider both sides?
- nl 6y agoThe interesting thing about these claims is that in many there are multiple film views of the same incident, and in the CNN case there was an apology issued. What exactly are you skeptical about?
- aww_dang 6y agoIf you must pry, I'll say that CNN (a highly partisan outlet) has every incentive to have their reporter arrested. I'll also say that arresting a journalist is out of line and that the police could have let it ride. However no one is perfect, certainly not myself. Therefore I have little room to pass judgement upon police officers who are clearly under more than a little bit of stress. Similarly, I can't condemn the reporter even if he is indeed (which I can't know with certainty) advancing his career in a very cynical way. For me I'm comfortable just leaving it as an unknown instead of attempting to take sides or claiming an authoritative understanding of the event. Moral grandstanding for either claim would be a further leap too far for me personally. However you are welcome to argue your opinion with someone else. I just can't do that in good faith. Thanks for understanding.
- frobozz 6y agoAt what, exactly? The President's announcements? I think I'll stick to those parts of the world where opposing Fascism is legal.
- moduspol 6y agoCrime statistics. And then compare them to police brutality statistics to see if the outrage is warranted. Also, opposing fascism is still legal here. We do actually have legally enshrined freedom of speech.
- nl 6y agoI'm not from the US, but I used to be very much on the "things aren't as bad as they appear" thing too. The last 6-9 months has made me change my mind. The systematic firing of 5 inspector generals and the US Justice Department's reversal on the charges against Flynn and Stone have made me change my mind. The US has always had inequal access to law, but now it appears the rule of law is in doubt. It doesn't matter if you are left or right leaning - if the law is that corrupted there is something to be concerned about.
- moduspol 6y agoThere is something to be concerned about. We felt that way when Hillary Clinton avoided charges after using her private e-mail server for sending and receiving classified information, after Fast and Furious, and the IRS targeting of conservative organizations. But those weren't framed as "the rule of law is in doubt" because a different guy was in the White House. And if you're seeing the Flynn case as an example of a solid and reasonable case being dropped due to political interference, I don't think you've read enough about it.
- nl 6y agoDid you really just do a "what about Clinton's emails" and think that is an argument? Literally Whataboutism
- moduspol 6y agoI provided clear examples of laws being broken, people not being held accountable, and people like you not caring when it's someone on your side pulling the strings. Now another guy is in charge. This isn't new.
- nl 6y agoWhere did you provide clear examples? If you mean Hillary Clinton then you do realize there have been six separate investigations and no charges. Did you know that what happened in the Clinton case is not an uncommon occurrence? Did you know that Bush did the same thing[1]? And Jared Kushner and Ivanka Trump did the same?[2] In all these cases it's not the right thing to do, but nor is it criminal. And what is this "people like you" attack? The Marc Rich case is something I'll condemn Bill Clinton for any day of the week - it's a complete miscarriage of justice and I wish there was a way it could be reversed. I'm not aware of anything like that from the Obama era but it's possible I've missed it. Justice matters much more than politics. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bush_White_House_email_controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bush_White_House_email_controv... [2] https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/cummings-jared-kushner-and-ivanka-trumps-private-emails-texts-raise-security-concerns https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/cummings-jared-kushner...
- yostrovs 6y agoFrom the inside, the rest of the world looks like either anarchy or arbitrary despotism. Do you care what Americans think of you? That's how Americans feel about your opinion. It's just simply irrelevant.
- petargyurov 6y agoWhat's your point? They're expressing an opinion. Your response comes across as defensive, and dare I say irrationally so.
- andybak 6y agoYou as an individual might not care what the rest of the world thinks but it matters to America as whole what the rest of the world thinks. There are genuine effects economically, culturally and militarily that reaches every US citizen in some form or the other. Unless you retreat into some form of isolationism so severe it is without historical precedent then you will care.
- yostrovs 6y agoYou want us to care. You care, judging by the first half of any European news program being devoted to the United States. But you care because you think you're "citizens of the world". Well, you don't actually care. You just watch those news to be smug or to think you're smart, but it does nothing and nobody here thinks about your opinion when they go about their day. Really.
- andybak 6y agoYou missed my point entirely. It doesn't matter whether you think you care. Pride, chest-puffing and posturing don't matter either. The outside world has a habit of affecting things whether you pay attention to them or not.
- yostrovs 6y agoYou know, there's a saying that America is always predicted to become fascist, but Europe seems to be the one that always falls in that trap. Having the first half of every European news program start with the United States is the current evidence that this is again about to be the case. People should focus on their own countries and their own news. We, Americans, are certainly upset about the racism, police brutality, and the riots. We don't need to hear it from Europeans that are just watching it for the laughs, thinking they're somehow better.
- alabaster_punt 6y agoFrom the inside (UK -> US immigrant), it is really bad right now. From an American perspective, maybe it is not so bad as we think because of the difference in 'overton windows'. We now have the president essentially demanding the criminalization of left wing politics, and there is a large contingent of support in the Republican base, gorged on misinformation, frothing at the mouth at the prospect of throwing anyone to the left in Gitmo. Considering that the politics of most of Europe are considered to be communism by many in the US, it's worrying to say the least. The US is very clearly, very openly sliding into a degenerate fascist state.
- 0-O-0 6y agoIf news articles are to be believed, UK is a horrifying place to live too. It has it all: barely accountable politicians, unsolved racial tensions, massive police overreach, acute gang problem (and while there is almost no gun violence, acid throwing somehow feels even worse). I'm sure that it doesn't seem to be that way from insiders perspective - it's very much possible to live safely and not to suffer from above mentioned problems on a daily basis, but same is true for those living in US. Personally I wouldn't relocate willingly to either of the countries.
- pjc50 6y agoThe UK situation is weird: on a day to day basis you notice almost none of that in most places, and while the gang problem is real in certain places it's also massively overhyped by right-wing politicians. The big tensions are all anti-"immigrant" and of course Brexit and now the poor pandemic response. You can't tell people to ignore the deaths and hospitalisations of people they actually know. While most of the consequences of Brexit haven't hit yet, there is going to be a huge mess when the interim arrangements expire at the end of this year and the government has still done almost nothing to prepare.
- fault_lines 6y agoFrom the inside (UK -> US immigrant), it is really bad right now. From an American perspective, maybe it is not so bad as we think because of the difference in 'overton windows'. We now have the president essentially demanding the criminalization of left wing politics, and there is a large contingent of support in the Republican base, gorged on misinformation, frothing at the mouth at the prospect of throwing anyone to the left in Gitmo. Considering that the politics of most of Europe are considered to be communism by many in the US, it's worrying to say the least. The US is very clearly, very openly sliding into a degenerate fascist state.