4 ms·
Too much transparency can result in people "gaming the system" if the full workings are known.
by HPsquared 6y ago
Too much transparency can result in people "gaming the system" if the full workings are known.
- naasking 6y agoIf the rules are solid, 'gaming the system' means they're rule-abiding members. If there's a problem with that, then improve the rules and don't blame the users. Reducing transparency because you're relying on tricks is a great way for users to begin hating your mods.
- jfengel 6y agoHating mods is not necessarily a problem. If you boot a user, you don't care about their opinion of you. Mods select the community, and their goal is a comfortable place for that community. Booting easy cases should be easy. There will also be edge cases, and almost by definition there's no easy way to make the rules crystal clear for edge cases. You can't be consistent because consistency doesn't exist. The best you can hope for is to encourage users to avoid getting close to edge cases. For those who are uncomfortable with that, there are many unmoderated forums elsewhere. It's all a question of the the site owner's goals. Maximum traffic and maximum content are not everyone's goals. Often they are seeking a community to deal with that community's concerns, and to shut out the overall problems of the world that attract the most attention.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoUnfortunately, rules for humans don't work that way. It may be helpful to read up on "work to rule" strikes - they provide good context on what kinds of problems happen when people start trying to act up while staying within the letter of the rules.
- elliekelly 6y agoThis is the same argument I hear against open-source software but in practice it seems transparency helps identify and solve problems more quickly.
- CogentHedgehog 6y agoTransparency helps with normal "people problems." The opposite is true with bots, spammers, paid trolls, and other attempts to subvert the platform itself. It's the same reason why open source projects try to fix security vulnerabilities privately before they disclose them publicly: they don't want bad actors to be able to take advantage of the information. Except with social platforms, they can't ever truly "fix" the problem, just mitigate it by trying to detect and remove offenders. If you provide transparency into how bad actors are removed, they'll just adapt to hide better.
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoAn example of this is bot-detection. All the major social media sites face the problem of malicious bots, and to my knowledge, all are secretive about how they combat them.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y ago> All the major social media sites face the problem of malicious bots, and to my knowledge, all are secretive about how they combat them. Leading, inevitably, to all the major social media sites regularly banning humans and refusing to say why.
- at_a_remove 6y agoIt's odd, I usually see that consequence ("rules lawyering") given as a reason why they avoid being specific about the rules to begin with. It is often followed up with almost everything moderators called on saying that the comment was "on the bubble" or that the commentator failed to "read the room" or some other such nebulousness.
- heisenbit 6y agoKeep in mind that while the focus is often on individual posts the moderator may well look also at other posts and other moderation decisions related to that in the past. A post by a new member is treated differently from a post by a member with a good record and that is treated differently from a post of a member who has been warned repeatedly.
- Lammy 6y agoSo let’s remove the game. Why should it be a challenge for two people to work around censorship automation before they can communicate?. It feels like we have normalized caring for the well-being of ads over the well-being of actual humans.