8 ms·
> I wish free software advocates would stop calling proprietary software immoral. I was very surprised by that sentence, because "immoral commercial software"
by toyg 6y ago
> I wish free software advocates would stop calling proprietary software immoral.
I was very surprised by that sentence, because "immoral commercial software" is absolutely not a common term in FOSS circles, afaik. This is the first time I heard it. Most FOSS developers are employed by commercial companies and have no problem developing commercial software - in fact, most people decry the lack of commercial software on FOSS platforms. Please don't build it up into a strawman.
I suspect this formulation has something to do with this particular reporter being from China, where there is still a lingering link between morality and industrial production.
- simonh 6y agoThat particular phrase may not be common, but over the years I've come across plenty of free software proponents who absolutely do believe that proprietary software is immoral.
- AsyncAwait 6y agoThis belief is usually based on the imbalance between the developers and users, such that the developer is able to change the software in unexpected ways, backdoor the user machine via rootkit DRM, spy on users and collect telemetry without the users being aware of what exactly is being collected etc. In that sense, the sentiment isn't wrong. This does not mean all proprietary software is like this, but the developer/user power imbalance is present in all proprietary software to a much greater extent than free* software. *Free does not mean non-commercial, it's cool to want to get paid for software, including free software.
- eps 6y agoA more accurate term then would've been "potentially-immoral proprietary software". Though it doesn't roll off the tongue quite as well and its trolling factor is laughable, so I can see why it wasn't employed.
- simonh 6y agoIn my experience it's generally based on the Stallman concept of software freedom, in which the freedoms Free/Libre software is intended to respect are seen as rights, and the power that a proprietary software vendor wields over users is fundamentally unjust. This is the basic philosophy on which the Free/Libre software movement was founded, so it's not just a peripheral view. He outlines this pretty clearly here: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-software-even-more-important.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-software-even-more-impor...
- enriquto 6y ago> I was very surprised by that sentence, because "immoral commercial software" Being commercial is independent to being proprietary; there is a lot of non-commercial proprietary software and there is also some commercial free software. Regarding the immorality, it is definitely common to justify the necessity of free software on the grounds that proprietary software is immoral towards the users: they cannot know, verify, or control what the program does to them. In the writings of Richard Stallman you certainly find the notion that free software is a necessity precisely because proprietary software is unethical.
- oehtXRwMkIs 6y agoMan it's crazy how to this day even FOSS advocates will confuse proprietary and commercial. It's like confusing ethics and law, where at this point I have to assume the person I'm talking to still holds this false equivalence in their mind because it's so common and clearly not going away.
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoStallman's position is pretty extreme. One can reasonably object to proprietary code in all sorts of domains, such as medical devices say, but it seems a bit much to say that all proprietary code is necessarily unethical. The GameBoy used proprietary software. Was that unethical?
- fsflover 6y agoYes, it was. The developers of any proprietary software have unjust power over its users, i.e. they could implement any anti-features they wanted and the users cannot not do anything about it. In this sense, the users do not own the device if it runs proprietary software.
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoSure, you don't get to easily make any changes you wish, but even this has real upsides. Modern consoles are able to offer a multiplayer experience free of the cheating that plagues many PC games. That's because they're bolted-down and deny users the freedom the modify the software. To the customer, that has real value.
- grliga 6y agoThe purpose of the GNU system is to give users the freedom that proprietary software takes away from its users. Proprietary operating systems (like other proprietary programs) are an injustice, and we aim for a world in which they do not exist. To improve the use of proprietary systems is a misguided goal. Our aim, rather, is to eliminate them. We include support for some proprietary systems in GNU Emacs in the hope that running Emacs on them will give users a taste of freedom and thus lead them to free themselves. https://www.gnu.org/software/emacs/download.html https://www.gnu.org/software/emacs/download.html
- amelius 6y agoAlso, a lot of FOSS developers use a liberal license like the MIT one, so companies can use their free software too without even needing a lawyer!
- grahamlee 6y ago"Without needing a lawyer" is a strong assertion: https://writing.kemitchell.com/2016/09/21/MIT-License-Line-by-Line.html https://writing.kemitchell.com/2016/09/21/MIT-License-Line-b...
- seba_dos1 6y agoYou misrepresented the quote. It's "commercial developers of immoral proprietary software", not "commercial software". That's a huge difference - commercial software isn't immoral and nobody says it is; proprietary one is and that was a consistent stance of FSF since the very beginning.