2 ms·
I'm stunned that this article was published just a few days ago, because recent events have illustrated just why it can be important to think about strange, unr
by SpicyLemonZest 6y ago
I'm stunned that this article was published just a few days ago, because recent events have illustrated just why it can be important to think about strange, unrealistic hypotheticals. How much easier would lockdown debates have been, if we had the conceptual frameworks in place to talk frankly about how many lives must be saved to justify suspending certain freedoms?
- sukilot 6y agoHow does that help. "By my weightings, freedom is more important than public health." "My weightings say the opposite." That's where we are today. Putting numbers on it, numbers that can't be determined except by our personal biases, doesn't help. Here's a fun story about cost benefit analysis in the real world, a bureaucrat deciding which kinds of rape hurt enough to be worth preventing: Criticism: https://gulcfac.typepad.com/georgetown_university_law/ https://gulcfac.typepad.com/georgetown_university_law/ Defense: https://www.theregreview.org/2013/09/13/13-sunstein-cost-benefit/ https://www.theregreview.org/2013/09/13/13-sunstein-cost-ben...
- darawk 6y agoThe value in these things is being able to consistently extrapolate from weightings, and to understand all of the consequences of different weights. Most people just have vague moral intuitions that lack consistency.
- downerending 6y agoI've been thinking about the Trolley Problem these days as well. It's not just "How many lives must be saved to justify suspending certain freedoms?". More importantly, it's "How many lives must be forfeit to save someone from dying of COVID-19?". Based on the collateral damage estimates I'm seeing, we might be forfeiting five or ten for each save. And if one switches to quality-life-years as a measure, the picture might be even worse. Anyway, long live the Trolley Problem.