5 ms·
This works because European countries are very corporatist. There is a high degree of labour organisation and governments, unions, and employers often work toge
by Barrin92 6y ago
This works because European countries are very corporatist. There is a high degree of labour organisation and governments, unions, and employers often work together to maintain say, employment rather than responding to market fluctuations.
This is why German unions say in the early 2000s during Germany's "sick man of Europe" period, negotiated stalling pay raises to maintain employment.
In the US (and also often here on HN) this will just be described as inefficient, ignoring market signals or something like it. I don't think it's even possible to coordinate the economy like this in the US.
- hogFeast 6y agoIt requires a level of corporate control over politics that just doesn't exist in the US.
- dathinab 6y agoOh, it does exist. Just not for labor unions and similar. From what I can tell corporate induced bs* laws seem to be more common there than here. (i.e. caused lobbying, not in the interest of the population)
- joe_the_user 6y agoThe problem is corporations exert huge influence in the US but only indirectly through feeding various ideologies. These ideologies the exalt the market and enterprises, certainly but they tend to also.not understand how actual business works (the average American politicians has been claiming government should work like a small family lumber mill for generations). Today, I can't help but think the super rich of America (at least those not slaves to ideology themselves) must be rethinking their support for extreme polarizing positions and "market fundamentalism" as the Federal government abjectly fails to meet the challenges of unified approach to disaster and conflict that is it's overall purpose.
- hogFeast 6y agoThat makes no sense. Look at the largest donors, unions are absolutely huge, and have a very outsized role in the US (although that isn't unusual).
- jacobush 6y agoI don't know what to make of this comment. On the one hand, it makes sense, on the other, corporate control over politics in the US is near complete. Maybe it just goes to show to show that corporations can not control themselves. They need to be guided.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cat199 6y agoI believe OP means corporate in the sense of 'collective' rather than in the sense of 'legally created limited liability entity'
- hogFeast 6y agoIt isn't anywhere near complete. In the US, corporations fight with the state. In most Nordic/North European countries, corporations are the state (the history is just totally different, large corporations have run those countries for decades). I will give you an example: Germany we can agree is a fairly rich economy, the average German citizen has the same net wealth as a Greek citizen...a country where the economy basically doesn't function, unemployment has been in the high teens for two decades, etc. I also knew someone who run a chemicals business in Europe. In the UK, unions fought every step the way, they negotiated huge salaries for members, they would make threats, they would strike. In Germany, they just rolled over. As long as you paid the right people off, low wages, subsidised loans, etc. They just did whatever management told them (I think people who talk about worker representatives on boards assume that there is some scrutiny going on...I have never seen this occur). The closest comparison is probably China. Very similar.
- kazen44 6y agoare you serious in your reply? because claiming german unions didn't fight every step of the way is absurd. Unions and other left winged organisations played a major role in german history. Germany was the first country with a state supported pension and healthcare system. The SPD has been in power for a majority of germany's post-ww2 history together with CDU in the grand coalition and the average greek does not have the same net wealth as the average german.
- throwaway2048 6y ago"corporatism" != control by corporations, or anything at all do do with the concept of the modern concept of privately owned corporations necessarily. The term for that is corporatocracy, among other things.
- cma 6y ago> I don't think it's even possible to coordinate the economy like this in the US. Seems pretty easy for some industries. After years of demonizing OPEC we essentially joined them in "OPEC+" after just a short time of being a net exporter of oil.
- 082349872349872 6y agoBefore OPEC wrested control away, the Texas Railroad Commission used to set output. (well before the TRC, Rockefeller bet heavily on Pennsylvania oil. Luckily for him, no one found oil outside the state until after he'd cemented his monopoly) Crude Rules Everything Around Me (barrel, barrel oil, you all)
- cglace 6y agoAs a southerner. . . Crude Rules Everything Around Me (barrel, barrel oil, y’all)
- ineedasername 6y agoCoordinating output in a single industry is orders of magnitude less complex than doing so across a large country, or all of the EU.
- kazen44 6y agoThis structure is very similar to the "polder model" used in the netherlands.[1] As far as i know, this has grown historically out of a post world war 2 tendency to keep a fragile balance between the various organisations in society as a method to prevent the enormous turmoil of the pre world war 2 period. 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polder_model https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polder_model
- pcurve 6y agoI think it also works partly because the wages are more egalitarian. Developers and doctors don't make $200-$400k like they do in the U.S.
- DaiPlusPlus 6y agoI don’t understand why we get paid so much here. I’m from the UK but have been working in the US since I got my degree and my total comp - after adjusting for cost-of-living is easily 2x-3x what it would be in the UK for the exact same work. It’s similar if you compare Seattle with Vancouver, BC - it’s only a 2-hour drive away, but salaries for the same work are around 50-66% of Seattle’s.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoBecause you participate more in the value of the product you produce? What would you prefer, than the executive board should keep all that instead?
- DaiPlusPlus 6y agoIn my current business at least: the market is 5x bigger than the UK’s (5x the population after-all). But that doesn’t explain other disparities.
- apta 6y agoIt just means that they're heavily underpaid in the UK.
- jackcosgrove 6y agoI would argue developers in the UK and Canada are underpaid. Silicon Valley is unique even in the US in that the companies see developers as revenue sources rather than costs.
- mehrdadn 6y ago