3 ms·
The dissent explicitly lists: > "factories, offices, supermarkets, restaurants, retail stores, pharmacies, shopping malls, pet grooming shops, bookstores, flor
by fastball 6y ago
The dissent explicitly lists:
> "factories, offices, supermarkets, restaurants, retail stores, pharmacies, shopping malls, pet grooming shops, bookstores, florists, hair salons, and cannabis dispensaries. "
I think saying religion is equivalent to sports is pretty strange. People clearly place way more importance overall on religion than they do on sports, even in a country that's pretty crazy about sport.
I would definitely argue that church is more important than pretty much everything in the latter half of the dissent's list.
- joshuamorton 6y agoThe question isn't one of importance, but of the danger to individuals from partaking in the activity. Yes, speaking constitutionally, shopping malls are less important than churches. But that doesn't matter if a church service is a religious concerts and concerts (religious or secular) aren't allowed.
- kmonsen 6y agoJust note that shopping malls are closed in California so that is not a reasonable argument. But for example Tesla manufacturing is reopened, is that a comparable activity? I think this whole case is clearly subjective and should not be of course. It would be useful to have a general rule what a church is comparable to.
- fastball 6y agoIt is obviously not purely a function of danger. It is a cost-benefit of danger/importance. Clearly importance is relevant to this discussion. Supermarkets are open everywhere because they are very important (vital), even though they might be a ripe vector for transmission. I would agree that on the graph of danger against importance, supermarkets are obviously going to be less dangerous and more important than church. But my point was that it's not clear where to draw the line on this graph, and even if you do have a clear line, I think church is going to be higher on the cultural importance scale than concerts or sporting events, so it could make the cut even if they do not.
- kmonsen 6y agoThat list is not really accurate, shopping malls, bookstores, florists, hair salons, and cannabis dispensaries are still closed I believe. Pet grooming is open, and to some extent I agree with you (although I have used one). In my opinion the difference is that social distancing is trivial. We left the pet in the trunk and they picked her up from there and delivered her back there. No human interaction. I find this fascinating in that there is no legal argument on either side (even in the supreme court!), but it is an argument about what church services are comparable to. I think this should go into law and would sort of be fine with any reasonable outcome (lower than supermarkets, but potentially equal with manufacturing), but if I got to decide it would be like a sport arrangement.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoAll those businesses are allowed to open under the current state order. A few of them weren’t allowed until the middle of last week though.
- kmonsen 6y agoI stand corrected it seems, it is still not happening in most of the state and not at all in Santa Clara where I live. In that case it seems a little bit inconsistent, but that is up to the governor to decide. I do feel he implemented this a bit badly, but not bad enough that most of the supreme court felt it was illegal.
- chadlavi 6y agoIt's functionally equivalent to a sporting event in terms of crowds and space usage. A large group of people gather to observe something on a regularly scheduled basis. It even has more important events that typically draw larger crowds (high holidays/playoffs).
- thephyber 6y ago> I think saying religion is equivalent to sports is pretty strange. Attending "church" is functionally different from "religion". The performance aspect of church is much closer to actors participating in a common theater. The other aspects of religion can be performed outside of church and usually without gathering physically in a communal room.