16 ms·
This week I went to a gym that just recently opened up. While attendance was way down (I'd say ~1/3 of usual) there were still a good amount of people there, an
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
This week I went to a gym that just recently opened up. While attendance was way down (I'd say ~1/3 of usual) there were still a good amount of people there, and I was the only person, besides staff, wearing a mask.
At this point I see another explosion of coronavirus cases as just math. I mean, it's like stamping out most of a fire so you're left with only a few burning embers, so you say "Great, time to reopen, lets dump these giant bags of dry leaves onto these embers."
Yes, many (most?) people are still staying home where I live, but for many places that have opened up I see zero change in behavior - there were some viral videos last weekend of packed bars and events. I contrast that with other places (like Germany) that actually appear to have a plan in place of how they will be able to open up safely. AFAICT our plan in the US appears to be "thoughts and prayers".
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoI would say I've almost felt a degree of peer pressure to not stay home after the stay at home order lifts here. Even though I really am not comfortable with the measures everyone has taken here. I agree I think a second wave is imminent.
- throwaway122378 6y agoI’d love to hear your argument for doing anything other than opening up back to normal (not the new normal) while the elderly and at risk continue staying at home (in addition to anyone that feels more comfortable staying home).
- majormajor 6y agoHow do you propose to go back to "normal" because of your own "(in addition to anyone that feels more comfortable staying home)." It would get worse, there, too, if people did return to normal and cases spiked. Versus cities that are now in "new normal" and still full of people being much more cautious. If cases didn't spike - there are those who believe the flattening of case rates isn't a result of behavioral changes but was some hidden factor - then "the new normal" will continue, but you won't be back to the old one. If cases do spike, "the new normal" will get even less close to the old normal, because more and more people will self-select back into staying home. Otherwise you have to get a way more coherent government plan to get on top of the spread. Like tracking and finding and isolating cases fast. And doing more to protect the people in essential jobs which are conducive for big outbreaks.
- brewdad 6y agoMy wife and I planned to ride the local rails-to-trail bike path today. We pulled up to the main lot and even the overflow parking was full. Tried the entry point 5 miles up trail and it was just as packed. At that point, we decided to head home. Technically, reopening phase 1 doesn't begin until Monday here.
- nradov 6y agoThe lockdown orders imposed on many beaches and parks were totally counterproductive because people ended up more concentrated in the few recreational areas that remained open. At least they're getting some exercise.
- DoofusOfDeath 6y agoI share your sentiment. I recently noticed that many people in my area are returning to pre-pandemic behaviors; especially teenagers and young adults. I pointed out to my kids that sometimes you can, and sometimes you can't, estimate how dangerous a behavior is based on whether or not lots of people are doing it. Especially where there's a delay between the behavior and observable consequences. E.g., smoking cigarettes in the 1930's, or unprotected promiscuous sex in the 1980's, or (I'm guessing) pre-pandemic behaviors right now.
- nikofeyn 6y agothe first wave never ended. we did almost nothing to actually stop it and have instead just rode it. now, it's going to keep going or even pickup speed. imagine if a terrorist attack killed over 100,000 people in just a couple of months. instead, we're just like "wasn't so bad" after doing hardly anything. it's an embarrassment in the u.s. to see people in south korea and china returning back to life as almost normal without danger. and the numbers are incredibly damning to the u.s.
- chrisco255 6y agoImagine treating a virus the same way as a terrorist attack. Stop pretending that governments can regulate viruses out of existence, or that armies and lockdowns are going to prevent microscopic, nanometer-sized viruses from traveling in the air. This is beyond asinine. By the way, SK just kicked the can down the road, they are continuing to get spikes because they have no herd immunity: "Coronavirus: South Korea closes schools again after biggest spike in weeks" https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-52845015 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-52845015
- nikofeyn 6y ago> Imagine treating a virus the same way as a terrorist attack. i didn't. i said imagine the situation. i'm saying that people would pay attention and treat it seriously. > Stop pretending that governments can regulate viruses out of existence isn't that exactly what south korea did? the point is that there is no excusing the u.s. response to the virus. > By the way, SK just kicked the can down the road, they are continuing to get spikes because they have no herd immunity point me to scientific evidence of herd immunity. or any evidence they've kicked the can down the road. look at their graphs and compare them to the u.s. how in the world is their response kicking the can down the road but the u.s.' isn't? that quite literally makes no sense.
- chrisco255 6y agoI pointed to an article from today, where SK tried to re-open their schools and immediately shut them down again thanks to another outbreak. They have nothing under control. Their population is still vulnerable and has no antibodies. The U.S. did not have a monolithic response. Many states never shut down, and never experienced overrun hospitals. Many states had light restrictions and never experienced overrun hospitals. Some states sent sick people to nursing homes and then had overrun hospitals.
- puranjay 6y agoHow are people talking about a second wave? You have over a thousand people still dying daily and over 20,000 cases/day. When did the first wave even end?
- UncleOxidant 6y agoReally depends on the state. I think here in Oregon we have a pretty solid and (properly) cautious phased re-opening plan. Counties have to meet certain well-specified criteria before entering these phases.
- ken 6y agoNext door in Washington, we also have a properly cautious phased re-opening plan, with per-county metrics to meet before applying to move to the next phase. My county is still in Phase 1, and even so I've seen a fair number of people in close proximity in public without masks. The universe tends toward maximum irony. If I had a nickel for every time I heard some variant of "That won't happen here"...
- chrisco255 6y agoNo, sorry, states that never locked down (WY, SD, AR, etc) have followed the same curve as those that did lock down. States that re-opened early (GA, FL, TX) have not seen a huge spike in cases. Vast majority of deaths were caused by nursing home incidents. Almost half the deaths are in three states (NY, NJ, and MA), which have had strict lockdown procedures. The curve was flattened back in April. There is no objective criteria being used to justify masks or lockdowns. There has been no threshold set where once hospital usage is below a certain amount, all restrictions are set. For this reason, I cannot support arbitrary lockdowns. They are violations of liberty and an abuse of state of emergency policy. In the meantime, 40 million people are unemployed, our economy is in tatters and it's going to take a decade to recover.
- kittiepryde 6y agoNearly every law is a violation of liberties, I don't think that's a good argument.
- CGamesPlay 6y agoAny thoughts on any of the other mentioned points against the lockdowns?
- kittiepryde 6y agoNope, I don't necessarily disagree with OP's overall conclusion. I just thought that one point wasn't very good.
- roenxi 6y agoWhile that is true a 'right to work' is recognised in the International Charter of Human Rights as one of the big ones. Along with free movement and probably there is an implicit if not explicit right not to be mandatorialy isolated from other people. These aren't "I want a house with 3 stories and I can only build two" style liberties. These are the "if I don't have these I literally do not have any liberty" incursions on liberties. The important ones.
- 6y ago
- recursivecaveat 6y agoIn the US excluding New York, deaths have been basically flat for a month and a half. If we couldn't even stop the spread under quarantine, we're deluding ourselves if we think there's not going to be a huge spike over the next month or two. Most people are just not willing to take this seriously it seems, they flaunt the precautions, engage in all sorts of wishful thinking about 6-foot distances or cherry-picked stat declines, are unwilling to make personal or communal sacrifices. Its going to be a real shame when 1+ million americans die because we were unwilling to cut our own hair for a year.
- ptero 6y agoYou make it sound like cutting your own hair is the main hardship, which I suspect is not quite honest. What about being forced to walk outside in a mask, deferring medical care, not being able to hug your own {parents, grandparents, kids, grand kids} see other relatives and friends, not visiting many places you want to visit. And a pretty huge economic hit. And seeing more and more folks on the streets on the previously friendly town getting angrier and snappier; etc. etc. I am not saying we should not "take coronavirus seriously" as you say. I do. But after taking it seriously I still see the current lockdowns in the US as counterproductive. Even if we could get this genie back into the bottle 3 months ago (which is not a given), you cannot now. Many states are open and people travel. Instead of forcing wide lockdowns we should focus on supporting those at high risk or worried and let others back to leading normal lives. My 2c, no offense intended.
- shreyansj 6y agoI am not aware of any restrictions on hugging your family. Either way, the virus is not going to worry about anyone's constitutional rights if they catch the virus from another family member.
- toast0 6y ago> I am not aware of any restrictions on hugging your family. If your family lives in elder supportive housing, there has been plenty of no visitor policies. Regardless, if you don't live in the same house with your family, visiting them may not be following the policies.