6 ms·
The Long, Painful History of Police Brutality in the U.S.
- Ididntdothis 6y agoI think to a large part this is a consequence of the racist policies the country had for a long time creating a permanent underclass. This will probably take some more generations to heal. I also think that the US in general celebrates violence much more than other developed countries (on TV nudity->bad, violence->good). I am always horrified when even very liberal people seem to be OK with people being raped in prisons "because they deserve it". And I think a lot of people are totally OK with rough treatment by police.
- TazeTSchnitzel 6y ago> racist policies the country had for a long time The US still has racist policies, they just usually can't be overtly racist now. > This will probably take some more generations to heal. Will it ever heal without affirmative action? Even if racism and racist structures magically disappear tomorrow, there will still be segregation and significant wealth and power gaps that capitalism has no interest in alleviating.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- wpietri 6y agoI think that's reasonable. I strongly recommend Kendi's booked "Stamped from the Beginning", which is basically a history of racist ideas. One of the things that's really striking about it is the extent to which the ideas commonly in circulation are ones useful to the powerful. One clear example from the book is the various theories of natural inferiority. During long periods when white slavery of Africans was common, Europeans claimed that Africans were naturally inferior because of the much hotter climate. But earlier, Greeks thought that northern peoples like the Slavs (from whom we get the term "slave") were inferior because they were from a cold climate. The US had a lot of that going on, with different ideas about religion, culture, biology, and society shifting to be what was convenient for the rich. Given how much US wealth came from chattel slavery and after that labor exploitation, it's not a stretch to suspect that police, whose basic job is using violence to enforce the status quo, would have a lot of ideas and habits that match.
- groby_b 6y agoThe history of the US police is firmly rooted in slave patrols, so your suspicion is pretty much spot on.
- gamblor956 6y agoThat is wrong. Police forces originated in North, where slavery was outlawed. Slave patrols were not formed until nearly 70 years later. https://plsonline.eku.edu/insidelook/history-policing-united-states-part-1 https://plsonline.eku.edu/insidelook/history-policing-united...
- groby_b 6y agoDid you bother to actually, you know, READ the article you shared? "It was not until the 1830s that the idea of a centralized municipal police department first emerged in the United States" vs. ". The first formal slave patrol was created in the Carolina colonies in 1704" Slave patrols predate municipal police departments by 100+ years. And for additional clarity, let's draw the link: " Following the Civil War, these vigilante-style organizations evolved in modern Southern police departments primarily as a means of controlling freed slaves who were now laborers working in an agricultural caste system, and enforcing "Jim Crow" segregation laws, designed to deny freed slaves equal rights and access to the political system." You're right in that northern police forces were more interested in protecting mercantile interests. And that's where we get the core functions of our police system: Protect the interests of the moneyed class (north) and suppress minorities (south) But citing this article as evidence that US police isn't rooted in slave patrols is... bold choice, Cotton.
- gamblor956 6y agoYes, especially the part where it states that private police organizations were formed in multiple Northeastern colonies in the 1630s...or more than 70 years before the first slave patrols. (See also https://time.com/4779112/police-history-origins/ https://time.com/4779112/police-history-origins/ which does a better job with its terminology.) Unlike slave patrols, the Northeastern police organizations were the model for the formal police organizations formed in the 1800s. If you're going to make an argument about timing, you need to get a better grasp on how time flows. (Hint: 1704 is a bigger number than 1630, so it comes later in the progression of time.)
- every_time_6m 6y agoIt's very difficult to take seriously when many opportunistic people so readily turn every case of blacks behaving badly into police brutality. In the coverage of Floyd yesterday, I even saw a black man (with a PhD) continuing the absurd narrative that Arbery was just out for a jog. It's difficult not to laugh sometimes. While black collectivism is admirable, and something we Whites could learn a thing or two from, they must temper it with an ounce of reason and sense. They must accept that there are an awful lot of extremely dangerous and violent black men who our police must contend with every day, and that their behaviour in those situations is very often directly linked to the consequences they experience. In the same way Whites feel a sense of justice when a bad White is roughed up by the cops, blacks will need to do the same. Their unrighteous indignation every time a thug is often rightly removed from our streets does nothing but reveal how wide our cultural gap really is.
- beloch 6y agoI'm not an American, but there does seem to be some value in a contrarian opinion here. Namely, it isn't just police brutality that's the problem, but the whole cycle of violence. Yes, the officer who killed George Floyd needs to be prosecuted. Yes, the officer who wantonly pepper-sprayed protesters while driving past needs to be fired and charged. However, the riots and burning of police precincts have reinforced an "Us vs Them" mentality in the police and primed officers for the next round of brutality. Imagine that a mob of people of mostly the same ethnicity came to your place of work, threatened you with violence, and burned the place down after you and your co-workers fled. No matter how justified the mob's anger may be, this is how you create racist cops. The riots in Minneapolis are rooted in mutual suspicion and lack of respect between the black community and police. Both sides can point to awful things the other side has done, but both sides need to be better in order to break the cycle.
- Ididntdothis 6y agoI totally agree that the looters are hurting the cause and I wish some of the leaders would step up and tell the looters to stop. But considering that one side is doing this professionally and has the right to use lethal violence I think we should apply higher standards to them. Government has to break the cycle. From what I have read police training is severely lacking and they also let get bad cops away with a lot. Instead of cleaning up from inside they circle the wagons and defend bad guys.
- ookblah 6y agono, i don't agree with this take. it's just chicken/egg then and figuring out who started it first. i don't condone the riots or excuse the people obviously trying to take advantage of the situation sow chaos/loot stuff, but the spirit of riots are a manifestation of a failure of a system. people don't just riot as the default response to injustice. imo, cops that are "racist" didn't become that way because of mobs like this. they joined the force because, like other positions of power, it allows them that arena to act out their beliefs. you remove these people by removing the structures that allow them to proliferate. i feel like no matter what black people do to protest there is always someone critical of how they protest. had this been an open letter from the community nobody would pay attention. look at the repeated times this has happened in the country and what eventually happened to the perpetrators, even after going thru the formal legal process. look at the ire drawn toward kaepernik for kneeling. in the end it is a complex issue and it's not like we can just put everyone onto a "side" and make it one-dimensional. and i agree that there has to be a mutual respect among the community. but, i'm of the belief that if you're in an elevated position like a cop you need to be held to a higher standard than the average citizen. my .02
- rcurry 6y agoWe have a systemic problem in this country when it comes to policing, and it’s not about racism - it’s far worse than that, if there even is such a thing. It’s called “qualified immunity” and it’s NOT in our country’s constitution. It’s a fabrication, a lie, a horrifying farce that allows our cops and DAs to operate with near total impunity for any malicious activity they choose to engage in. Our “system” is hopelessly broken and we have an obligation to rectify it. I don’t want us to engage in more “dialogue” with law enforcement, I don’t want more “transparency”, I don’t want more “synergy” with “the community”, I just want this shit to STOP. There is no excuse and I’m sick of it.
- raincom 6y agoI always wonder why Democrats, while in power, don't something about this and other problems that African Americans face? It is okay to accuse Republicans for blocking some reforms. Why can't Democrats address systemic injustices when they had numbers? Leaving everything to the Supreme Court does not help, as it takes 100 years for SCOTUS to make a change, as Justices take baby steps. Politicians can take a faster route, yet they don't. For instance, the State of Minnesota can get rid of "qualified immunity", and that state is not in the hands of Republicans.
- Craighead 6y agoWhataboutism as a propaganda technique at it's core is leading a reader to believe in a false reality of the world. Shame on you.
- vsskanth 6y agoPolice Unions
- rcurry 6y agoIf you’re not part of the solution there’s good money in prolonging the problem.
- gamblor956 6y agoThey do... Some things are hard to change, even when you control all the branches of government.
- 7532yahoogmail 6y agoThe following enters into the OP's link somewhat sideways, but in an important way I think. There's an old 60's analogy attributed to Fritz Pearls: you can touch the menu; you can read the menu; you can lick the menu; you can eat the menu. But you didn't each the meal. That is, let's not confuse the model of experience with experience. Extending that analogy I cannot argue that my life experience is similar, equivalent, or exchangeable with African Americans because I haven't lived their experience under, say, American police. Still I am concerned that if this analogy is taken too far, there will arise an insuperable gap that will work against binding each party into the whole we seek or ought to be seeking. Our -- or THE - American Constitution sets forth equality among us all regardless of creed, color, sex, or religion, but when some of us go to the restaurant we aren't served or, worse, there's no food and no kitchen for us. America is not living up to the goal despite having fine goals. I recall Cornel West saying civil rights was due not because the Blacks wanted a piece of the pie -- a backhanded reference to government handouts for undeserving people -- but because preferential treatment based on color was never part of the deal. There's no white guilt at play here anymore than there's handouts going on. So, let's be clear: violating civil rights is morally, ethically wrong. And all the more when it's perpetrated by sections of society that have greater power, money, and institutional agency. And all the more when cops are supposed to hold the line on justice. Justice is the good line: if you're on the wrong side, you should have to pay in the criminal or civil penalty. And if you're on the right side then all to the good. Either way, then, there's no room to take offense. As I understand it the cop with the knee on the throat of a handcuffed black man was finally charged. Well, big deal: it took them long enough to get to the stunningly obvious. I am hoping the FED charges will follow. And then civil charges. There's also the issue of the other officers on the scene and whatever games were played by the DA and its affiliates. Hackernews is primarily about technology, tech corporations, and business. However, let's over master the lesson so that we realize the ultimate money lesson with plenty of banked savings to boot: money is not the measurement of all things. We can and must insist there's equality under the law for each and everyone of us. Let's all work to make sure there's enforceable norms which is also, beyond income, an important piece of security for us and our families. I have kids; I know why their skin color is like mine. They had no choice in the matter. And for those parents, sisters, or brothers of African Americans who fell into this society, we cannot be using and abusing and violating their rights. Standing by in a dismissive stance --- a Canadian guy who works as a FTE at my/our American company said we Americans need to get our ____ together like it wasn't his problem too --- is not help. Maybe I cannot eat the menu. But I am not helpless, nor am I apart from this problem. I also have agency. Let's not lost in silos here.
- every_time_6m 6y agoWhy is my comment flagged? Is the only allowed take on this to be that blacks are always innocent angels and police are bloodthirsty thugs roaming the streets looking for sweet, pure saints to murder for no reason?
- dang 6y agoWe've banned this account. You can't do race war on HN.
- alex_s93 6y agoGenuine question: Is there any attempt at impartiality in the application of these policies on HN, or is it as ostensibly anti-White as most large internet platforms? Is someone with my views - White Nationalism, namely - as welcome here as others, or is HN as anti-White as most other internet platforms in practice? I'd be very interested in participating in good faith here in these kinds of discussions, yet things get a little disjointed when I need to keep making new accounts. And sometimes that can lead to frustrated comments that test the rules too, I admit. Do you have any guidance? I've reread my comment and I genuinely can't understand why it would attract a ban, all else being equal. tldr- Am I allowed to disagree, or should I go elsewhere?
- dang 6y agoYou should go elsewhere, because prosecuting race war on HN is against both the site guidelines and the spirit of curiosity that we want to animate this place. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- alex_s93 6y agoIt's very difficult to take seriously when many opportunistic people so readily turn every case of blacks behaving badly into police brutality. In the coverage of Floyd yesterday, I even saw a black man (with a PhD) continuing the absurd narrative that Arbery was just out for a jog. It's difficult not to laugh sometimes. While black collectivism is admirable, and something we Whites could learn a thing or two from, they must temper it with an ounce of reason and sense. They must accept that there are an awful lot of extremely dangerous and violent black men who our police must contend with every day, and that their behaviour in those situations is very often directly linked to the consequences they experience. In the same way Whites feel a sense of justice when a bad White is roughed up by the cops, blacks will need to do the same. Their unrighteous indignation every time a thug is often rightly removed from our streets does nothing but emphasise how wide the gap is between our people.
- 2019-nCoV 6y agoWhere were the riots after white woman Justine Damond was brutally killed by a black police officer in Minneapolis just a few years back? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shooting_of_Justine_Damond https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shooting_of_Justine_Damond
- dang 6y agoYou've been flaming up a storm on HN. That's against the rules and I've banned this account. If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html