7 ms·
I think the GP post was a bit overzealous when they said "ultra wealthy", because even the more-or-less middle class (I'm assuming virtually everyone posting on
by tombert 6y ago
I think the GP post was a bit overzealous when they said "ultra wealthy", because even the more-or-less middle class (I'm assuming virtually everyone posting on HN) could afford to pay the ridiculous rates for hand sanitizer and toilet paper. I would complain about the prices but it wouldn't bankrupt me.
However, imagine a single parent who just lost their job because of COVID, and thus living on a very restricted income. Is this person less important than me? I don't think so, the world needs service workers a lot more than they need yuppie software engineers like me, but I'm still more likely to be able to afford the necessities.
This is always my problem with people who defend price gauging; there's always this hidden implication that a rich person is more deserving of something vital than a poor person. You are entitled to that opinion, but I fundamentally and completely disagree with you.
- marshray 6y agoFor any system, one can always construct scenarios where resources are allocated sub-optimally or unfairly. We don't have to like capitalism, sometimes even its proponents refer to it "the worst system except for all the others." But usually the alternative to capitalism isn't perfection, it's something worse. Like a political boss who abuses his power to seize the goods and hand them out as political favors. The big mistake with COVID-19 was telling individuals to boycott masks and that it was wrong to buy or wear them. We could have opened whole new factories for producing them by now, if only demand had been encouraged rather than suppressed.
- tombert 6y agoI'm not a socialist, I more or less support capitalism, but there's a reasonable middle ground between Laissez-faire capitalism and Stalin-esque socialism. It's not like I found this really obscure edge case. Almost 30% of America has lost their job in some capacity; this isn't just some weird contrived example, and it's dishonest to act like it is. Service workers, at least in the US (I haven't lived anywhere else) are pretty damn vital to the US economy, but are also less likely to be able to afford price-gauged supplies like masks and hand-sanitizer than a yuppie like me. If we don't have some form of regulation to stop price guaging, we are sending a signal to 30% of America that they are simply less deserving of life than the yuppies that depend on them. I don't particularly care about people hiking up the price of bread machines and video games and whatnot, but I cannot in good conscience defend people who do things that will lead to poor people dying. EDIT: A few typos.
- marshray 6y agoIt doesn't matter who could theoretically afford them at centrally-planned prices. Where I live the shelves at hardware and drug stores had been empty of masks since mid-February. While Americans were being told not to buy them, organized groups were buy them out of American supply channels and shipping them to mainland China. It would have been better if Americans had bought them and kept them around. They could have been used here by individuals, donated to care providers, or even (horrors) sold for a profit.
- tombert 6y ago> The big mistake with COVID-19 was telling individuals to boycott masks and that it was wrong to buy or wear them. > While Americans were being told not to buy them They didn't tell people to "boycott" masks, they said that they weren't effective at stopping COVID and that people in hospitals needed them more than the average citizen. The initial research for masks indicated that they weren't helpful, due to Coronaviruses showing up on the outside of the masks after asking an infected person to cough. It wasn't until a few weeks later when they noticed that the petri dishes that the patients had coughed into had substantially more virus reproduction without masks than with the masks. The people doing the research weren't lying, it was a very logical sequence of events. Sometimes initial research implies an incorrect conclusion, that's why it's called "initial research" and not "conclusive research", which is why they "changed their minds" afterward. This is well documented and is not controversial [0]. The way you frame it, and the use of the word "boycott" is incredibly disrespectful to the people studying this. [0] https://www.acpjournals.org/doi/10.7326/M20-1342 https://www.acpjournals.org/doi/10.7326/M20-1342
- marshray 6y agoI have absolutely no problem with being considered 'disrespectful' of anyone who told Americans not to wear masks during a respiratory pandemic. (Go ahead downvoters, do your thing.) One cannot claim that both A) masks are "not effective at stopping COVID" and B) "people in hospitals needed them more than the average citizen". It's a laughably obvious contradiction. This is a lie (sorry, yeah, it is) pushed by people who wanted to bully individuals out of their own PPE in a misguided attempt to make up for the failure to plan by the larger organizations (government, healthcare orgs) that were responsible for doing so. The reality is that masks are effective in stopping the transmission of coronaviruses and every country in Asia knew this from experience with SARS-1. EDIT: If this isn't urging a boycott, what is? https://twitter.com/Surgeon_General/status/1233725785283932160 https://twitter.com/Surgeon_General/status/12337257852839321...
- marnett 6y ago> The big mistake with COVID-19 was telling individuals to boycott masks and that it was wrong to buy or wear them. We could have opened whole new factories for producing them by now, if only demand had been encouraged rather than suppressed. Classic market economics in a vacuum. Without the suppression of masks, mass chaos and social unrest would have ensued. The societal fear and unease was easily diverted towards non-essentials (TP, hand sanitizer) - proper public health advice could be given long after shelter-in-place, and thus societal order was established. People would have died had authorities came out the gate stating masks were critical to one’s health. So many people forget that you have to control the population in times of exceptional fear and anxiety or at any stage you risk a partial or complete societal collapse.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- WalterBright 6y ago> a rich person is more deserving of something vital than a poor person. Consider if there's a fixed supply X and Y people. (Y - X) people aren't going to get it. With rationing, the government is going to decide who is more deserving. Naturally, those government officials are going to decide that themselves are the most deserving. This happens under every socialist system. When the US government built nuclear shelters, who were they built for? Not you and me. They were built for government officials, and built with every luxury. The next tier of the "deserving" will be the supporters of those government officials. Next will be the politically popular groups of people who will be more deserving. Is that fair? But without rationing, the supply of X will increase to the point where everyone can afford it.
- TeMPOraL 6y ago> When the US government built nuclear shelters, who were they built for? Not you and me. They were built for government officials, and built with every luxury. And here I thought they were built for everyone. Oh wait, that was on the Soviet side, where you could expect to find a shelter in any given neighborhood (at least in larger cities). They likely weren't anywhere near as luxury, though. > But without rationing, the supply of X will increase to the point where everyone can afford it. That's an assumption that works long-term. In an emergency, you can consider supply as fixed. Ramping up production takes many weeks at best, and producers are unwilling to invest in it anyway, unless they can expect the emergency to last for all these weeks. There's no point in upgrading your manufacturing capacity if, by the time you're done, the demand will be back to normal. It's a point that was explicitly raised by at least one US medical supplies manufacturer in the last two months (probably many more, but I remember that one interview). In an emergency, your choices are to either a) ration the goods, b) let speculators hoard all the supply and make it unavailable until pretty much the last minute (and a big chunk of it not even then), or c) freeze prices, preventing hoarders from speculating on them while still maintaining basic market mechanisms.
- WalterBright 6y ago> In an emergency, you can consider supply as fixed. You could, but that would be a mistake. Consider gas rationing. Everyone gets 5 gallons. But everyone's utility for gas is different. Some need 10 gallons, some need 1 gallon. This reduces availability of gas, because the 1 gallon person is going to hoard the extra 4 "just in case". Don't believe me? Check out gas rationing in the US in WW2. Letting the price float means gas is reallocated from the least useful to the most useful uses, effectively increasing the supposedly "fixed" supply. (Hoarding is the least useful of the least useful uses, even if you're just hoarding the part of your ration you don't need.) As for the Soviet Union, it was notorious for housing shortages. I bet if the supply of air raid shelters had been tested in an emergency, you and I both know it would be insufficient for those who weren't Party members. > speculators hoard all the supply and make it unavailable Speculators don't profit if they don't make it available.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> Is this person less important than me? Consider the problem you're having. We'll stipulate this person isn't less important than you. But there isn't enough supply for both, so one of you will go without. If we use pricing to determine who it is, the result is arbitrary -- not based on importance. But if we sell at the non-shortage price until we run out, the result is still arbitrary -- you haven't improved it, it's still not based on importance and someone equally deserving still goes without. The arbitrary method used is different, but it's neither worse nor better. Meanwhile the higher prices deter the person who was going to go in and buy out the entire store, because they can't afford to do that at the higher price, and then the supply is at least more evenly distributed even if it isn't perfectly evenly distributed. Better yet, the person who had foresight and spent resources to create a stockpile ahead of time then has a large financial incentive to distribute it instead of continuing to hoard it, and people have a greater incentive to do that again next time (which is good).
- dogma1138 6y agoStores can and have limited the quantity one can purchase during this pandemic which is arguably a better method for preventing hoarding. Many of the supplies issues aren’t due to actual limited supply but due to behavior patterns that stem from either fearing that something would run out or people taking advantage of the situation buy all the toilet paper in town and set your own price on the black/grey market. The problem isn’t people having the foresight to spend resources it’s people creating artificial shortages. This isn’t the type of behavior you want to encourage. This is also not a free market, the free market doesn’t work at short time frames and emergency situations.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> Stores can and have limited the quantity one can purchase during this pandemic which is arguably a better method for preventing hoarding. At which point you're assuming everybody has the same need, which is completely wrong. Someone walks into the store to buy on behalf of six dozen people because their ordinary supplier is out of stock and you won't give them any more than what you will a single individual. Requiring every individual to come into the store one by one is both highly inefficient and, in this context, the exact opposite of social distancing. Meanwhile every individual who comes into the store for unrelated reasons then also buys the individual limit on the scarce good even when they don't need it, because the price is still low. > Many of the supplies issues aren’t due to actual limited supply but due to behavior patterns that stem from either fearing that something would run out or people taking advantage of the situation buy all the toilet paper in town and set your own price on the black/grey market. Which higher prices prevent, because hoarding large quantities is very expensive when the price is high, and arbitrage is unprofitable because you can't buy low and sell high if you have to buy at the higher price. > The problem isn’t people having the foresight to spend resources it’s people creating artificial shortages. This isn’t the type of behavior you want to encourage. You can't corner the market on a global commodity by buying out local stores. If it's selling for $50 where you are and $5 in other places then enterprising people will get in their cars and undercut you until the price is much closer to uniform. Meanwhile to make money the hoarders would essentially need to act as a cartel (not selling in order to keep the prices even higher), but with uncoordinated actors everybody has the incentive to defect and sell as soon as the price is above fair market value. If you're keeping prices high by hoarding that means somebody is going to be left holding the bag because the price came back down before they unloaded their hoard, and everybody has the incentive to sell first and not be that guy. The hoarder's greatest risk is a container ship full of product comes into port and resolves the shortage overnight -- and the higher the price the more likely that happens. > This is also not a free market, the free market doesn’t work at short time frames and emergency situations. There is no evidence for this. The amount of time it takes for people to respond to price signals and arbitrage opportunities is measured in hours, not days or weeks.
- sokoloff 6y agoI don’t defend price gouging because the rich are more deserving. I defend price gouging because it can help create supply. Next time your area is hit with a widespread electric outage and all the generators are sold out, call Home Depots 500 and 1000 miles away. Chances are they’ll have a normal supply on-hand. Maybe some of those will find their way into your area, but I can be pretty damn sure it would happen faster if they were selling at 1.5x the normal price in your area.
- nitrogen 6y agoSo charge appropriately for shipping from 1000 miles away.
- jdminhbg 6y agoI.e., price gouge?
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoI'm pretty damn sure that's very unlikely. Covid made this very clear. Countries that limited price gouging had far less panic buying and far fewer actual shortages than countries that ignored it. Far from "creating supply" price gouging is read as a signal that supplies are precarious and may run out at any moment. So buyers tend to stock up, just in case. The result is widespread shortages. And of course generators are useless if they're >500 miles away. No affordable markup is going to get essential goods into an emergency zone if they have to be trucked a long way. Bottom line is you're going to get much better results from organised community preparedness and intelligent collective response than from a few random spivs hoping to make some extra dollars.
- sokoloff 6y agoThe markup doesn’t have to “affordable meaning cheap”; it just has to “affordable meaning someone wants to pay it”. 500 miles is a one day drive away for a truck full of generators. 1000 miles is a team drive and still arrives the next day with a truck full.
- 6y ago