3 ms·
The true hallmark of an ill-conceived law.
by shadowgovt 6y ago
The true hallmark of an ill-conceived law.
- Dylan16807 6y agoLetting companies opt-out of a regulation purely because it hurts their business model sounds much more ill-conceived to me.
- shadowgovt 6y agoGood law doesn't "let companies opt-out;" it is crafted with consideration for what is already happening and the consequences of the law. it doesn't appear, 2 years in, GDPR passes that test. If the goal was to minimize "privacy violation" by FB and Google, it's failing. FB and Google are stronger than ever, but their competitors are starved out of the market trying to comply with an onerous suite of policies. It's such a ladder-pulling set of laws it's surprising Google and Facebook didn't craft it.
- Dylan16807 6y agoDid we read the same article? Most fines are tiny. It hasn't fixed everything (yet) but that doesn't mean it's hurting competition. > Good law doesn't "let companies opt-out;" it is crafted with consideration for what is already happening and the consequences of the law. And sometimes the outcome of that consideration is "stop doing that".
- Nextgrid 6y agoIn this case you could say anti-drug-trafficking laws are ill-conceived because they go against the cartels' business models.
- shadowgovt 6y agoYou may want to choose another example. US drug law is a case-study in how law divorced from consideration of ramifications to existing businesses and societal norms is a disastrous way to craft law. https://www.aclu.org/other/american-drug-laws-new-jim-crow https://www.aclu.org/other/american-drug-laws-new-jim-crow
- Nextgrid 6y agoDrugs by themselves are indeed a bad example (I am personally in favor of legalizing drugs), but let's substitute them with violence: Would you say that anti-violence laws are ill-conceived because they go against cartels/mobs' business models of extorting money from people under threat of violence?