3 ms·
I think GDPR has its heart in the right place. I don't think it really helps and I suspect that is because users themselves really don't know what is actually
by duxup 6y ago
I think GDPR has its heart in the right place.
I don't think it really helps and I suspect that is because users themselves really don't know what is actually happening behind the scenes and no amount of banners or otter things changes their level of knowledge.
And I fear even if they know, users don't care and are happy to click past a banner / trade their privacy for free things.
GDPR seems to play out as a strangely legally mechanical beast that people are largely disconnected from.
- AndrewUnmuted 6y ago> GDPR has its heart in the right place I'm not sure we can jump to that conclusion. If the outcome of the GDPR was bewilderingly out of left field, and totally unpredictable, perhaps we could pass this off as being a big-hearted failure. The thing that I struggle to get past, though, is just how many of us warned of these outcomes _before_ the regulations were implemented. I fear very few had their heart in the right place. After all, it's pretty evident now, that those of of who saw this as a corporate effort to erect unnatural barriers to entry were correct. The people who designed the GDPR aren't idiots - they knew what they were doing too.
- Nextgrid 6y ago> users don't care and are happy to click past a banner / trade their privacy for free things. The GDPR explicitly mandates that consent should be freely given (it should not be more difficult to decline than to accept) and that consent should be informed, so you can't bury the information in 30 pages of ToS or privacy policies. The problem is that there is currently zero enforcement around those things. I'd argue that this is very bad for the intent of the law because even when enforcement starts happening and declining consent becomes possible users would've already been trained to just click accept to everything.
- chris_engel 6y agoIt gets even better: consent needs to be possible to be taken away as easy as its granted. Where are all the banners that nag me to take away ma consent?
- buboard 6y ago> users don't care and are happy to click past a banner / trade their privacy for free things. Are we discounting the possibility that users make a rational choice that we happen not to like?
- duxup 6y agoYes, they could be making a rational choice that we don't agree with.
- buboard 6y agoThen maybe we shouldn't be making laws to force things "we happen to like" to everyone
- duxup 6y agoI don't think GDPR forces you to choose not to share information. You simply get a a mechanism to make that choice. IMO it is a flawed and wonky mechanism. Still I'd prefer a the option, later if nobody cares then maybe remove the choice.
- buboard 6y agoIt forbids the exchange of information for providing service. There is no choice
- Dylan16807 6y agoIt's one of the few ways to negotiate back against contracts of adhesion. Giving that choice would theoretically be nice, but the status quo makes it not really a free choice, and the downside is bigger than the upside.
- luckylion 6y agoTough question. For some things, I'd say that informed consent is hard to give - if you consent, you're not informed. I don't believe that the average user is making informed choices. The choices may be rational as long as the users don't understand the consequences. It's perfectly rational to trade in your life savings for a fancy meal if you don't understand what "life savings" means.
- jsmith45 6y agoGDPR is poorly designed. It deliberately uses super vauge and imprecise wording. That is bad enough when operating in a common-law legal system where that is the norm. It is inexcusable in the Civil Law system that much of Europe operates in. Consider you offer the ability to users to voluntarily submit reviews of restaurants. One reviewer complained that person seated at table next to them was excessively noisy, and that upon asking the waitstaff to do something about it, they did nothing. It is actually entirely plausible for a company like Facebook to have enough information to be able to determine exactly who that other person is, given that review. For example if say both posted images of their receipts to Instagram. Why would they do that? Beats me, but plenty of people do things like that. Under a wide but not at all implausible reading of the personal information definition in the GDPR, that review qualifies as personal data of the person at the other table. The definition of personal data is "any information relating to an identified or identifiable natural person". And that review does include information about a natural person, and we have shown that the person is theoretically identifiable by Facebook. This means if that other person asks for all their personal info from the site, technically that review should be included. But most likely even Facebook does not yet have the ability to automatically identify this other individual. However, the regulation does not specify any applicable exception, so if you fail to turn over that data (despite having no way of knowing that review pertains to this specific individual), the supervisory authority could still legally fine you. Would you ever be fined for that? No of course not. Strictly speaking nothing in the wording of the regulation would prevent them from doing so. But obviously they have so many bigger concerns, and are unlikely to bother interpreting things so widely. After all, there is not a single large company that operates in Europe that is fully compliant with the GDPR if interpreted widely. There quite simply cannot be, since the costs of actually identifying everything that could count as personal data under a wide interpretation and ensuring the company can always look up 100% of it without ever missing any would bankrupt every such large company. And that is only touching on one little aspect of the GDPR, and one that is unlikely to actually be a major deal. Much worse is how vague the "legitimate interests" reason for processing is. That is the reason that many companies are relying on for much of their processing, and nobody can say with any certainly what cases are included in that, and what are not. So obviously the best the companies can due is attempt to follow the spirit of the regulation rather than the letter. But of course, if you do that, you cannot be entirely sure the regulators will agree with you.