13 ms·
Twitter policy: "We start from a position of assuming that people do not intend to violate our Rules. Unless a violation is so egregious that we must immediate
by Animats 6y ago
Twitter policy:
"We start from a position of assuming that people do not intend to violate our Rules. Unless a violation is so egregious that we must immediately suspend an account, we first try to educate people about our Rules and give them a chance to correct their behavior. We show the violator the offending Tweet(s), explain which Rule was broken, and require them to remove the content before they can Tweet again. If someone repeatedly violates our Rules then our enforcement actions become stronger. This includes requiring violators to remove the Tweet(s) and taking additional actions like verifying account ownership and/or temporarily limiting their ability to Tweet for a set period of time. If someone continues to violate Rules beyond that point then their account may be permanently suspended."
Somewhere a counter was just incremented. It's going to be amusing if Twitter management simply lets the automated system do its thing. At some point, after warnings, the standard 48-hour suspension will trigger. Twitter management can simply simply say "it is our policy not to comment on enforcement actions".
They've suspended the accounts of prominent people many times before.[1]
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twitter_suspensions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twitter_suspensions
- _ZeD_ 6y agofollowing the wikipedia article I found https://www.avclub.com/twitter-releases-statement-confirming-itll-never-ban-do-1818766712 https://www.avclub.com/twitter-releases-statement-confirming... "Twitter releases statement confirming it'll never ban Donald Trump"
- javajosh 6y agoMaybe. But there's probably a business model out there this is simply a Twitter clone that waits for the Trump account to move there, and bang, instant success.
- Tenoke 6y agoThere is and they (Gab) get an okay number of likes on every one of his posts promoting it. [0] Also Facebook is now well positioned to be his next platform if he moves off twitter. 0. https://twitter.com/getongab/status/1266347307391488002 https://twitter.com/getongab/status/1266347307391488002
- hn_check 6y agoTrump isn't moving to Facebook, regardless of Zuck's attempt to pandering to his childish outbursts. Twitter is precisely suited to Trump's micro-tantrum thoughts, where Facebook is orthogonal. I would argue that the brevity of Twitter, and the adversarial nature of it, made Trump and the imbecile-right (e.g. not conservative -- it's a bunch of flag wavers who have close to zero political lean of knowledge...they just want to hate). P.S. I know this comment is auto-dead, and that's okay.
- bambataa 6y agoOut of all the social networks, isn't Facebook the one that has the most Trump supporters? Twitter is notorious for being full of the woke left. Most people only find out about Trump's tweets because they get reported somewhere. Facebook is nowadays the preserve of older moms and pops.
- dr-detroit 6y agoFacebook banned epoch times so his financial backers wouldnt allow him to go there
- hn_check 6y agoGab has been the theoretical right-wing Twitter for years. It wallows in mediocrity. Trump and his cult are on twitter to try to bask in the legitimacy. If they're on their own, the raw charade of how childish and imbecilic their noise is becomes too obvious. It's also a bit hilarious given that Gab, created because of crybabies like Trump and Scott Adams, has hilariously restrictive policies, just as The_Donald is one of the most snowflake-moderated subs on Reddit. The right really can't stand each other.
- hoppla 6y agoOr mastadon! Whitehouse could have its own server, and would not need to worry about sensorship
- seesawtron 6y agoEven Jack Dorsey's account was suspended in 2016 mistakenly.
- clint 6y agoAs was Donald Trump's in 2017 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2017/11/02/trumps-twitter-account-was-temporarily-deactivated-due-to-human-error/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2017/11/02...
- hypersoar 6y agoThe headline is misleading. The "statement" is a Twitter thread, and it doesn't say anything about banning or not banning everybody. The body of the article concedes that it only "heavily implies" they'll never ban him. And that was three years ago. Some stuff has happened since then.
- dehrmann 6y agoSince Twitter and Trump seem intent on getting into a pissing match (Trump a bit more so), what's the worst each side could do?
- techntoke 6y agoTwitter could block him and Trump could continue to sell out America to foreign interests.
- fortran77 6y agoIt depends on who and what. And it's the inconsistency that will fuel the critics. They didn't suspend Spike Lee who caused direct harm to a private individual who happened to share a name with an infamous individual: https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/spike-lee-settles-twitter-mcclain-address-trayvon-martin-george-zimmerman-306315 https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/spike-lee-settles-twi...
- Simulacra 6y agoBecause suspending Spike Lee would have required someone at Twitter to make that decision, and they're not going to do that. But will leap at the chance for Trump. It's been a clear double standard for years.
- empath75 6y agoYou’re wrong on every point.
- pknopf 6y agoPlenty of left-leaning people get banned as well.
- Simulacra 6y agoBut not for tweets of violence, and they're not getting fact-checked like Trump.
- vkou 6y agoOnly accounts with a large reach get fact checked. Unfortunately, leftist lunatics don't have the same reach as him, so they aren't ever going to get fact checked. (Just banned for violating the TOS.) Edit: Don't understand the sentiment. Are there any radical left accounts with as much reach as the POTUS, that engage in similar behaviour that I am not aware of? If they exist, they should be trivial to link to. Looking at the top Twitter accounts, they consist of Barack Obama, YouTube, Modi, Bill Gates and a bunch of celebrities. Are any of those folks radical left? Will Lady Gaga or Katy Perry be opening the 2021 Superbowl halftime with "Internationale?"
- bryanmgreen 6y agoBetter leveraging Twitter's reporting feature is probably the most neutral way to solve this. When a tweet is deemed response-worthy, they should post the report numbers. Value in numbers shields them in many ways and could legitimize their actions as a neutral party. Then, if they miss something, they can simply say there weren't enough reports. This will then empower the feature in the future. I suggest this as active Reddit moderator with a community of 40,000+ subscribers who regularly has to enforce rules and uses auto-mod to help manage reports and shares that with the community. ----------------------- You can report tweets for: (1) Being not interested in it (you just get redirected to a mute or block button) (2)It's suspicious or spam ---> The account is fake ---> Includes a link to a potentially harmful or phishing site ---> Hashtags are unrelated ---> Uses the reply function to spam ---> Something else (3) It's abusive or harmful ---> It's disrespectful ---> Includes private information ---> Includes targeted harassment ---> It directs hate against a protected category (eg race, religions, gender, orientation, disability) ---> Threatening violence ---> They're encouraging self-harm or suicide (4) It's misleading about politics or civic events ---> It has false information about how to vote ---> It intends to suppress or intimidate someone from voting ---> It misrepresents it's affiliation or impersonates an official (5) It expresses intentions of self-harm or suicide. ----------------------- It's pretty good but I would suggest the very simple following updates: - Updating the main issue (It's abusive or harmful) to (It's abusive or encourages violence or destruction of property) - Adding a sub-issue to (It's misleading about politics or civic events) with (A political official is supporting false or unsubstantiated information as definitive truth.) - Adding a sub-issue to (It's suspicious, spam, or false) with (It's supporting false or unsubstantiated information as definitive truth.) - Adding chevron icons (>) as a visual cue that each main reporting issue has many sub-issues
- sytelus 6y agoThis doesn’t work for political tweets. Look at replies to even Trumps benign tweets and you will see 50% of the population would hate other guy no matter what they tweet. Every single tweet of Joe Biden and Trump will get flagged no matter what they were tweeting.
- ardy42 6y ago> Somewhere a counter was just incremented. It's going to be amusing if Twitter management simply lets the automated system do its thing. At some point, after warnings, the standard 48-hour suspension will trigger. Twitter management can simply simply say "it is our policy not to comment on enforcement actions". I wouldn't be surprised if Twitter has exempted Trump's accounts from all automated moderation. However, I'm half expecting them to ban him about twelve seconds after he leaves office.
- zapita 6y ago> However, I'm half expecting them to ban him about twelve seconds after he leaves office. At the top management level, they are probably weighing the possibility that he never leaves office (a plausible scenario at this point), and how that scenario affects their bottom line. They probably don’t want US institutions to dissolve into full-blown autocracy... But on the other hand, if that were to happen, then it would be better for the stock price if they hadn’t burned all bridges with the new leader for life. You can bet that Zuckerberg is making the same calculus - except that he seems to have chosen a side. Facebook is no longer pretending to care about preventing autocracy. They are betting on the GOP coup succeeding, and are building bridges accordingly. Note: no amount of downvoting by the alt-right fringe lurking here will make the facts go away. Downvote away since you don’t have the courage to write down and justify your true beliefs. You are an embarrassment to the technology community. You are the spineless, petty, cowardly foundation upon which all autocracies are built.
- logicslave 6y ago"they are probably weighing the possibility that he never leaves office" I think you are very far from reality
- BubRoss 6y agoWhen Trump leaves office he will be open to an enormous amount of investigation, litigation and prosecution. I don't know how probable it is that he tries to stay in office, but I don't think it is zero. Twitter planning around that possibility seems be less likely.
- seesawtron 6y agoI would imagine that accounts of "important" people are handled personally rather than by automated algorithm. As Jack Dorsey points out in this[0] Joe Rogan podcast, the reported tweets by public or algorithm are manually checked at some point. Approx. 4000 employees of Twitter all around the world. Every day 100k (edit: 100M) tweets are sent. The reports of tweets that violate the platform policy are (reported by public) enter a queue. These are then inspected by personnel hired by Twitter (number varies proportionally to the scale reports in the queue). The personnel then go through a series of steps to take an action such as making you verify again, delete those tweets, suspending the account, or in the last resort ban the user permanently. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DZCBRHOg3PQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DZCBRHOg3PQ
- andrepd 6y agoOnly 100k/day? That sounds quite low.
- arnvald 6y agoMaybe 100k tweets by people who are checked manually? I'm sure there are millions of tweets send every day.
- jwcrux 6y agoIt is low. Estimates [0] put the number closer to 500M/day. [0] https://www.internetlivestats.com/twitter-statistics/#sources https://www.internetlivestats.com/twitter-statistics/#source...
- seesawtron 6y agoYou are right, the volume is in millions, as I heard in the podcast from the Twitter executive. Corrected.
- ASalazarMX 6y agoTwitter is mostly retweets, though.
- 75dvtwin 6y agoUseful to know that this specific selective application of editorial bias by Twitter, was after Trump's executive order [1] on preventing online censorship of free speech. >"... Twitter now selectively decides to place a warning label on certain tweets in a manner that clearly reflects political bias. As has been reported, Twitter seems never to have placed such a label on another politician’s tweet. .." When a car manufacture represents their 18-wheeler fleet as a 'passenger cars' -- we understand that this is a lie and demand corrective action. When twitter manufactures opinions and hides them as 'public forum discourse' -- we are supposed to be ok with that? I would be ok if their manufactured opinions are displayed to paid subscribers only, who want to care what Jack Dorsey thinks about President Trump, obamagate or Brexit. [1] https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/executive-order-preventing-online-censorship/ https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/executive-or...
- tripzilch 6y agoHow is this "political bias"? Is everything that disagrees with Trump now "political bias"? I'm not even from the US and I know what "when the looting starts, the shooting starts" means and what outcome it envisions. > When twitter manufactures opinions and hides them as 'public forum discourse' -- we are supposed to be ok with that? What are these opinions? Can you speak them out loud? Which opinions are being hidden? Can you write down the message of these opinions in plain words? Could you write down these opinions as if they were your own, without violating HN's house rules?
- sytelus 6y agoYou cannot not have bias when you are talking politics. For Tweeter’s case, one would need to look at statistics for how many tweets from each sides are getting flagged. If one side is getting all the flake then it means that side is evil and other side is holy. In politics, this is not possible over long term if democracy is in full effect.
- belorn 6y agoThe outcome was clear the moment a president mentioned the use of the national guard in dealing with demonstrations. Using the military to quell civil unrest means people getting shot. Last time in 1992 on the order of George HW Bush, the resulted was 50 dead and 2000 injured. Unless a person is talking about using the military to assist with natural disasters, the person is envisioning the violence of "when the looting starts, the shooting starts".
- biolurker1 6y agovery naive to think that was a counter flagging POTUS tweet.