10 ms·
What's surprising is how often I encounter fellow Americans mistakenly asserting the first amendment extends beyond government and into the private sector. It'
by pengaru 6y ago
What's surprising is how often I encounter fellow Americans mistakenly asserting the first amendment extends beyond government and into the private sector.
It's like they've never even been to a movie theater where they need to shut the hell up or leave.
And here we have a US president signing an executive order in response to being moderated on a web site after years of arguably excessive tolerance of his b.s.
I'm not sure how much more embarrassed I can get for my country.
- takeda 6y agoMost people totally miss the point. The first amendment is there from preventing the government from controlling the speech. Exactly what Trump is doing to Twitter right now.
- outworlder 6y ago> Most people totally miss the point. Because 'free speech' is literally _all they know_ about the subject. If they did look it up, they would literally see the very first words of the first amendment: "Congress shall make no law (...)". Literally about the legislative branch. Every other consequence of the First Amendment comes from that. Other laws can be more specific and may grant more rights, but this just specifies what the government can't take away.
- greenyoda 6y ago> "Congress shall make no law (...)" The Bill of Rights has also been extended to apply state governments, based on the 14th Amendment: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incorporation_of_the_Bill_of_Rights https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incorporation_of_the_Bill_of_R...
- quicklime 6y agoApologies if this is a stupid question; I'm a foreigner so I can't understand freedom like Americans do. But if the first words are "Congress shall make no law", does that mean that the President and his executive orders are not bound by the First Amendment?
- javagram 6y agoThe president has no authority over this subject matter except that given him by congress. This executive order is a directive to the FTC and FCC, which are both bodies created by congressional law. As a result, neither has power to violate the first amendment since by virtue of being created by congress, they are subject to the literal reading of “Congress shall make no law”. For what it’s worth - the 14th amendment passed after the civil war has been read to extend the protections of the bill of rights beyond their literal sense anyway.
- nine_zeros 6y agoTechnically yes, other branches are not bound by the first amendment. By the spirit of the law, no. A lot of historical laws and constitutional writings were to limit power of the government in general. When the constitution was actually written, the executive was just a puppet with military commander powers. But over the centuries there has been power creep into the executive. Such battles end up in supreme court and the court decides ultimately what interpretation would hold up. The current supreme court is republican/right wing leaning which often ignores the spirit of the law FWIW.
- takeda 6y agoActually, the way it works is: legislative branch - writes the law judicial branch - interprets the law executive branch - executes the law FCC, FTC etc were created by legislative branch to make governing specific areas more streamlined, they are still bound by whatever legislative branch is bound.
- nine_zeros 6y ago> FCC, FTC etc were created by legislative branch to make governing specific areas more streamlined, they are still bound by whatever legislative branch is bound. I would recommend reading up on historical executive orders held judicial review and how they impacted operations of 3-letter organizations
- FireBeyond 6y ago> If they did look it up, they would literally see the very first words of the first amendment: "Congress shall make no law (...)". The great irony is that the same people will happily quote "... shall not be abridged" when it comes to the next Amendment.
- mrlala 6y ago>I'm not sure how much more embarrassed I can get for my country. Just wait until tomorrow, and the day after that, and the day after that...
- scaredtobeme 6y agoThat's because these companies function in a way that is between the private and public sectors, and are getting more so. There are plenty of precedents for this, e.g. utilities, and the way we generally address such gray areas is regulation. It's interesting in this case that the side that usually calls for regulation is citing the arguments of the side that's usually against it, and vice versa. (Corollary: no one actually has any principles about this. People care only about their side and pivot like a weathervane depending on its interests. Is there even a single example to the contrary? That would truly be a mutant.)
- meragrin_ 6y agoSocial media are the broadcasters of this age. I see no reason why they should be exempt from the same rules and regulations as old school broadcasters.
- kanox 6y agoI believe the correct model for large social media platforms (for example above 10m users) is that of a telecom provider. Comcast can't block CNBC or Fox and at the same time nobody assumes that Comcast is responsible for view expressed on the networks it carries
- javagram 6y agoPretty sure comcast is legally allowed to block CNBC or Fox. Cable channels regularly get dropped from lineups due to disputes over fees. Here’s a recent example of NBC in threat of being dropped. https://www.pressherald.com/2019/10/02/spectrum-may-drop-nbc-programming-in-maine/ https://www.pressherald.com/2019/10/02/spectrum-may-drop-nbc... Edit: that link has a paywall, but here’s another discussing cable channels being dropped https://www.post-gazette.com/ae/tv-radio/2016/02/14/TV-Q-A-Do-viewers-have-any-recourse-when-a-cable-company-drops-a-channel/stories/201602140021 https://www.post-gazette.com/ae/tv-radio/2016/02/14/TV-Q-A-D... There’s no general right to force cable providers to have your cable channel.
- meragrin_ 6y agoComcast pays to carry CNBC and Fox content. They can freely decline to pay the content providers what they wish and drop their content. It is not an uncommon occurrence. Fox and NBC cannot provide air time for one political campaign and deny air time for an opposing political campaign. Twitter is more like Fox and NBC rather than Comcast.
- gamblor956 6y agoTwitter is nothing like Fox and NBC, unless they've managed to pick up a broadcast license without anyone noticing. Fox and NBC are only required to provide political campaigns equal access because of their licenses to exclusive use of portions of the public spectrum. Cable channels like CNN and Fox News don't use this spectrum, and thus don't have the same requirement. Twitter is more like a cable channel than a broadcast station.
- ardy42 6y ago> What's surprising is how often I encounter fellow Americans mistakenly asserting the first amendment extends beyond government and into the private sector. It's a confusion between the First Amendment and the principle of free expression, which is kinda forgivable given how closely they are related.
- joshuamorton 6y agoNot at all, they're directly at odds in this case. The President using presidential authority to restrict what twitter can say on their own platform is directly violating the first amendment to restrict twitter's free expression. You can argue that twitter is also restricting others' free expression, but that is their right, while the government preventing twitter from doing so is a 1A violation.
- xiphias2 6y agoIt would be as simple as you write if social media companies would take responsibility for the publishing rights for what they publish, but they don't. For a long time they are picking and choosing the laws they want to abide by.
- joshuamorton 6y ago> It would be as simple as you write if social media companies would take responsibility for the publishing rights for what they publish What do social media companies "publish"? In this case, the only thing twitter published was a link to information about mail-in voting[0]. That's it. They did so in the context of a tweet. So at worst, twitter would be liable for any illegal content in either President Trump's original tweet, or in the content I linked at [0]. That is what current US law says. To change that would require an act of congress or a supreme court ruling. The court is unlikely to rule in favor of Trump[1], as the conservative justices favor businesses rights. So that leaves a new law/amendment to the existing law. That would need to pass the house, which seems unlikely as well. [0]: https://twitter.com/i/events/1265330601034256384 https://twitter.com/i/events/1265330601034256384 [1]: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20200528/01321044592/two-things-to-understand-about-trumps-executive-order-social-media-1-distraction-2-legally-meaningless.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20200528/01321044592/two-t...
- kace91 6y agoTalking as an outsider, what's really weird to me is how the things Trump clearly says or does on a whim result in serious, deep debate in all the media and public forums. He goes "I will build a wall spanning a continent to stop mexicans" and you see deep debate about how effective it would be, the price, the logistics of it... it's clearly a dumb idea, why does everyone pretend it's not and engage in deep consideration of it? Now I'm seeing the same thing. Extensive debates about public opinion, the first amendment and the difficulties of moderating a service with millions of subscribers, when it is painfully obvious that the only reasoning by the president is "they messed with me so I'm going to get revenge".
- kthxbye123 6y agoThe American Presidency is a storied and historic office, not just a job but a symbol of the nation, of its civic and cultural identity, so it has been difficult for a lot of people to come to terms with it being occupied by someone who is quite so openly and vocally a gibbering idiot. Hence the need to pretend that these pronouncements represent proposals into which serious thought and effort has been invested, rather than the momentary whims of a bloviating narcissist.
- thephyber 6y ago> it's clearly a dumb idea, why does everyone pretend it's not and engage in deep consideration of it? I've learned that Trump is an incredibly dull instrument, but the points he raises (when you get past the verbal diarrhea) tend to be things that some significant fraction of his "base" care about or that are not actually novel policy ideas. "The wall" as he describes it is dumb. But it has existed in some form since the 1990s (albeit only segments) and the way he describes it is a simple symbol for people that tend not to know how to "solve" problems related to (illegal?) immigration. Most average people don't care about policy details so they don't know how to argue them to "win the argument". Trump gives them a sports team to cheer for and simple slogans to shout so they feel like they are participating. > when it is painfully obvious that the only reasoning by the president is "they messed with me so I'm going to get revenge". The problems that Trump has with social media companies go back far more than 2 days and a fact checking link. His Attorney Generals (both Barr and Sessions) have been working with Republican state Attorneys General for years to craft a response to what they see is "liberal Silicon Valley techies banning (or shadowbanning or remonetizing or ...) conservative voices". Trump doesn't see a downside to taking this action. The interesting thing is that there are far more than just political American conservatives that want to see regulation of {YouTube, Facebook, Twitter, etc}. Elizabeth Warren wrote a detailed essay on medium.com about why they should be more strictly regulated. A crazy YouTuber from San Diego got so pissed at YouTube for banning her account or demonetizing her channel that she drove up to San Bruno (not sure exactly which city/location) and shot up the building. There are quite a few stories of vague ToS being enforced in a not-so-predictable manner which leaves end users with banned accounts (which may be the nexus to more important accounts like email accounts).
- FriendlyNormie 6y agoYour tears are delicious. Dumbfuck.
- wwweston 6y agoAdditionally, the intervention Twitter seems to have chosen here wasn’t actually to silence the user (who happens to be the current President), but to mark/annotate with a fact check label, which is essentially responding to speech with more speech. That’s entirely compatible with even far-reaching 1A readings and robust philosophical perspectives on it. And in fact, Twitter’s civil leadership policy has been allowing such users (including Trump) extra leeway. The fact that Trump is mad about this shows that what he’s concerned about isn’t his own freedoms of speech are being impinged on, but that his freedom from accountability in discourse might be threatened.
- Thriptic 6y agoExactly this and I'm surprised that I had to scroll this far down to find this comment. Extract this scenario out into meat space. Imagine if a town was running a bulletin board where anyone could post town news and a citizen posted a flyer talking about town crime statistics that were wrong. A town employee noticed and posted an addendum identified as being from the town right next to the flyer saying "actually the real data is X". Should town employees not be allowed to do that?
- busymom0 6y agoThe Cox-Wyden Amendment: Section 230 specifically stated: "encourage the unfettered and unregulated development of free speech on the Internet," as one judge put it;". https://www.eff.org/issues/cda230/legislative-history https://www.eff.org/issues/cda230/legislative-history
- tomohawk 6y agoWhy does the US government exist? The only reason is to protect the rights of the citizens. Once upon a time, the rights of citizens only protected them from the federal government's actions. States could (and did) infringe on these rights. Corporations were much less powerful at this time, so were not much of a concern. We ended up fighting a war over this, and one result was the 14th amendment, which binds the states to also protect these important rights. Now a days, corporations are powerful enough to infringe these rights. We've dealt with this in the past when "trust busting" was more of a thing. There is established precedent for not allowing monopolies to infringe on people's rights. There's nothing special about the "private sector" that allows big corporations to infringe people's rights without due process.
- ryanwaggoner 6y agoI’m sad to see this downvoted. I’m not entirely sure I agree with your point, as I think the gulf between “profit-seeking corporation” and “democratically-elected government” is a lot wider than the one we jumped between Federal and state government for the 14th. That said, I like that this line of thinking made me question some assumptions I didn’t know I was even making before.
- kickopotomus 6y agoYou do not have a right to use Twitter. Currently, in the US, you do not even have a right to use the Internet. Twitter and ISPs may decide not to service you. As it pertains to Internet services specifically, these services are also allowed to moderate content that you post. You are not guaranteed a right for them to host your speech and show it to the world. If you have an issue with how Twitter, FaceBook, YouTube, et al. moderate content, you are completely free to create your own Internet service which you may moderate as you see fit. The US government exists to insure domestic tranquility, provide for the common defense, and promote the general welfare. The government is not interested in protecting the rights of citizens. Instead, it is the rights of citizens which are meant to protect us from the government. Other laws may dictate how businesses are allowed operate but the first amendment absolutely does not apply to private businesses.
- 6y ago
- christophilus 6y ago> I'm not sure how much more embarrassed I can get for my country. Every election season, I’ve said, “These are some of the worst candidates I’ve ever seen. I’m not sure how much lower the bar can get.” And then it gets lower.
- newacct583 6y agoI submit one of the reasons our candidates are so bad is that our discourse refuses to hold them to account. Instead of taking a position and punishing bad acts, we excuse them by telling ourselves the other side "would have been" just as bad. So the lesson successful candidates take away is that they don't need to adhere to principles, because their voters will find some mental excuse (like you just did!) to vote for them anyway. If you don't want this to happen you can't vote for the administration (not "candidates") who did it. Nothing changes until someone starts losing elections. But my guess is you aren't willing to go that far, because of something about Biden.
- buzzkillington 6y agoRemember that Kennedy won because the mob stuffed ballot boxes for him. The only thing that's changed every election is that you're 4 years older an paying attention.
- irrational 6y ago>I'm not sure how much more embarrassed I can get for my country. I honestly used to be proud to be an American. Now I am so ashamed that when I travel (or back in the days when I traveled) I lie and say I'm a Canadian.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- nostromo 6y agoThis strikes me as shameful behavior. You should say the truth: you're an American, and Americans have a diversity of views on most subjects, just like every other country.
- revscat 6y agoWhen conducting business this is more trouble, and causes more discomfort, than it’s worth.
- lastres0rt 6y agoI'm not gonna say you're wrong, I'm just going to say I've been having some variety of this argument since 9/11. If you have to spend the better part of two decades trying to defend your country as NOT being a white trash dumpsterfire...
- grecy 6y agoFWIW, I've dozens of backpackers around the world with Canadian flags sewn on their backpacks who later admit quietly they're American. They said it just makes life easier while travelling.
- rwoodley 6y agoI used to be proud of our flag and would display it. Now (past 3 years) it has morphed into a symbol of hate and oppression. When I see armed 'protestors' terrorizing a state legislature and waving the flag, then the flag is no longer a symbol of freedom but of intimidation.
- malwarebytess 6y ago>What's surprising is how often I encounter fellow Americans mistakenly asserting the first amendment extends beyond government and into the private sector. I've only ever heard people complaining that people misunderstand the first amendment. I've yet to see someone say they believe the first amendment governs and protects against private censorship. However, I constantly see people conflating the concept of free speech and the first amendment. Free speech is an ideological principle, not a law. If you read the first section of the EO it is clear that they are attempting to make an argument that Twitter, by moderating/curating/screening, is no longer protected by section 230, as defined by the famous 90s court cases regarding prodigy, aol, and compuserve. [0] [1] Spurious argument or not you are mischaracterizing the situation. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stratton_Oakmont,_Inc._v._Prodigy_Services_Co https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stratton_Oakmont,_Inc._v._Prod.... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zeran_v._America_Online,_Inc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zeran_v._America_Online,_Inc.
- newacct583 6y agoI'd be curious to hear real lawyers weigh in on this, but... that sounds pretty dubious to me. Executive orders aren't laws, they don't get interpreted by courts in general and they absolutely don't override existing case law! I mean, who cares what the executive branch says about section 230? We know what congress wrote, and we know how the judiciary has interpreted it, because we've already had that fight.
- skeletor_999 6y agoI found the following video insightful: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gmBGFVUjCaI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gmBGFVUjCaI It seems like an executive order is more of a guideline on how they interpret the law. He mentions that congress would need to make changes to the law for it to have teeth. He also said there will be lawsuits on the way.
- downvoteme77 6y agoI suspect it is futile to persuade y-combinator's types that your own dreams of amassing wealth and power might be biasing your views on this matter. It's really unfortunate that appeals to morality are brushed aside because your neediness for wealth and power and status is so overwhelming. It is exactly the same phenomenon at work within the Chinese Communist Party. Your desire to use technology to push others beneath you and oppress them is no different than that of the CCP. The only difference between you and them, is that the population you seek to dominate has not been beaten into submission with generations of violence. The American people cherish their freedom and are heavily armed and they hate you as much as the people of China hate the CCP. I wish these conflicts could be resolved peacefully. But, unfortunately, they cannot. If you want a civil war, you will get one. You are on the wrong side of history. You will lose!
- jeffdavis 6y agoThere's the legality of freedom and the spirit. I'd be pretty disturbed if an ISP all of a sudden prevented me from contacting wikipedia, or throttled my access to competitors. The ISP is private, but it's not really in the spirit of freedom to do so. Similarly, if an airline said they won't sell me a ticket because I'm going to a rally for a particular politician. Or if the post office (or fedex) wouldn't carry my letter to the editor because they disagree with my opinion. Or if I couldn't get basic banking, insurance, or other business services because my legal business is politically unpopular. There also is some legal murkiness because a federal judge ruled that Trump couldn't block people on Twitter[1]. [1] https://www.governing.com/topics/politics/gov-twitter-facebook-censorship-blocking-government.html https://www.governing.com/topics/politics/gov-twitter-facebo...
- nautilus12 6y agoHis motivations may be personal but they laid out the reasons for doing it pretty clearly. 230 was being too broadly interpreted, can anyone on either side of the aisle dispute that fact?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jklein11 6y agoI think there are two issues at hand here. The first is related to section 230 of the Communication Decency Act. This section provides a legal shield to companies that act as an intermediary by hosting comments. This legal shield is effective even if the intermediary moderates the comments and provides editorials. The executive action is saying if you are providing editorials, you are no longer just an intermediary and should be held accountable for what your users post. In other words, if you fact check your users posts you are responsible if hate speech or misinformation or child pornography are shared on your platform. I think 2 reasonable people could debate the pros and cons of this. The second issue at hand is the catalyst for this change. Jack Dorsey picked a fight with a giant orange toddler. For some reason the American people entrusted this giant orange toddler with the full authority of the executive branch of the United States of America. The orange toddler decided throw a fit and use this power that is meant to better the American public to retaliate against this personal attack. This second issue is the one that makes me sad to be a registered Republican and an American.
- gowld 6y agoDon't be sad to be a Republican. Elect better Republicans, and kick out the carpetbaggers.
- gowld 6y agoThose people may know more than you think. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pruneyard_Shopping_Center_v._Robins https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pruneyard_Shopping_Center_v.... Twitter is a California company. > movie theater where they need to shut the hell up or leave. This has nothing to do with anything. The 1A has always been understood as a freedom of content, not form. Noise ordinances and rules are constitutional.
- TheBobinator 6y agoThe heart of this discussion is not the freedom of speech, it's the the ability to say whatever you want without consequence. What Twitter wants, though selective undocumented "curating" of its platform, is the ability to slander, intimidate, harass, terrorize and verbally abuse whomever they don't like, without actually being drug infront of a jury and tried for crimes. Telco's wanted the same government exemption that USPS had; someone mailed a letter with a bomb, they can't be held responsable. This was something the courts were likely to give them anyway. Intentionally promoting a user's post containing a manifesto about assassinating a standing president is no different than USPS mailing millions of manifesto letters to people. One mechanism is simply more automated.