6 ms·
Calling it "WinGet" was the real punch in the gut. Does Microsoft select for assholes or something? There's a thousand other package manager names [1] in the w
by dmix 6y ago
Calling it "WinGet" was the real punch in the gut.
Does Microsoft select for assholes or something? There's a thousand other package manager names [1] in the wild and they chose that one.
So much for "developers, developers, developers"...
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_software_package_management_systems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_software_package_manag...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- TAForObvReasons 6y agoIn all fairness: - "NuGet" is super-popular in .NET circles (included in Visual Studio by default) - "apt-get" is the classic tool for Windows Subsystem for Linux So "WinGet" certainly "makes sense" as a name without being a direct ripoff of AppGet
- imhoguy 6y agoWait! apt-get is not Microsoft's invention https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/APT_(software) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/APT_(software)
- banger180 6y ago> "apt-get" is the classic tool for Windows Subsystem for Linux APT is the classic tool for debian-like Linux distributions. FTFY
- teekert 6y agoGet used to it, this is going to be the bulk of the "Linux" users from now on. Edit: Imo not a bad thing, it's just how it is. A lot of people will learn (of) Linux through WSL. Linux as a runtime.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- knolax 6y agoConsidering the fact that there are five times as many Android devices as Windows devices, and the greater ease of use of Termux compared to WSL. I find that highly unlikely. Anecdotally every newbie programmer I've seen try to use WSL has just ended up installing Linux in frustration.
- teekert 6y agoTermux is a terminal emulator, WSL is a subsystem. Did you try [0]? And WSL2? It's pretty compelling, I predict they will pull in a lot of Apple (who use it for the terminal) devs and make a lot of Windows first devs very happy. And there are a lot. Btw, am I downvoted because my original comment in not constructive or do people not agree with me? [0] https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/p/windows-terminal/9n0dx20hk701?activetab=pivot:overviewtab https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/p/windows-terminal/9n0dx20hk...
- knolax 6y agoTermux is a lot more than just a terminal emulator.
- PascLeRasc 6y agoBy the way, every terminal application you're used to (Terminal.app on macOS, iTerm, the Windows Terminal, Ubuntu's Terminal application) is a terminal emulator. I've tried WSL1 and 2 and couldn't get past the typing latency, awful font rendering, incredibly slow downloads, apt/dpkg bugs, and not syncing with the actual filesystem like Linux/macOS do. For example, I like to copy my dotfiles to ~/Dropbox/dotfiles. This isn't possible on Windows, and if you force it to do so it will corrupt the files.
- VibrantClarity 6y agoI doubt it pulls in anybody in the unfinished state its in. WSL does not integrate very well and is miserably slow. My 13yo thinkpad runs circles around WSL running on my workstation. WSL2 is still beta, and given how buggy 1909 still is, I am not installing 2004 on anything I care about. And I recently tried Windows Terminal, but it couldn't even give me an admin prompt without giving every single session elevated privileges, so I gave up after 5 minutes.
- nailer 6y agoYour point is solid ('get' is a common name for packaging systems) but if you're not familiar with Linux, apt-get is from Debian.
- sillysaurusx 6y agoI’m not sure you could have illustrated their point more perfectly than this. But please don’t feel like people are amused at your expense — it’s just such a perfect demonstration of exactly what they were saying. FWIW, I agree with you that WinGet is an entirely logical choice, catchy, and ultimately unrelated to AppGet. Yeah, it may seem like the choice was made intentionally / in spite of AppGet, but anyone who knows a bit about big company dynamics will tell you that the explanation for situations like this is usually mundane, innocent, and often dysfunctional — much like a toddler. A toddler that happens to have a billion dollars and can reshape the world with its decisions, but still similar. “The name is catchy and I like it” is akin to “I see red ice cream and I want it,” and it’s probably nothing deeper than that. It was rather unfortunate to use apt-get as an example and then say it was for Windows, though. :)
- deno 6y ago> "apt-get" is the classic tool for Windows Subsystem for Linux Hello darkness, my old friend…
- foolmeonce 6y agoYeah I hope the TLD read is that this article has nothing to do with Microsoft embracing Linux and Debian distribution related tools are safe? I would have preferred irrelevantGet but WinGet is unambiguous enough. Don't work for free on proprietary systems or single sponsor opensource is a lesson cheaper learned by watching others.
- yoz-y 6y ago> Don't work for free on proprietary systems or single sponsor opensource is a lesson cheaper learned by watching others. Well in the author's case the tool was just as useful for them than for the others. Nothing wrong with helping the community, regardless of the ecosystem.
- dmix 6y agoIt still looks really bad. If you're going to copy and kill off [1] an OSS project, when you're a major company who owns the platform, with a long history of this sort of thing, after baiting the developer for information, then copying the name on top of it is just cruel and in poor taste. Context matters. That's the key point here. Plus your two examples out of a hundred or so examples doesn't make it common either (or maybe one in a half examples since apt/apt-get/apt-cache are the three Debian programs under APT umbrella). [1] there was no way this project was going to continue despite their nonsense about "broadening the options in the community", they knew what they were doing
- microtherion 6y ago> If you're going to copy and kill off an OSS project Many OSS projects (and pretty much all of mine) were started to scratch a particular itch, so if that itch gets scratched by another project, I'm not terribly concerned. It's more problematic if the competition is a half assed solution that, by virtue of being backed by a larger company, still sucks the oxygen out of the space you're trying to serve.
- mikorym 6y agoThis comment should have a dualised state: downvotes that push it higher and upvotes that push it lower.
- hanselot 6y agoThis is how MS operates. EEE Windows Subsystem for Linux has Zero bearing on the existence of apt-get,aptitude,synaptic,apt,dpkg or any other package manager that ships with a mainline linux distribution.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- michaelt 6y ago> Calling it "WinGet" was the real punch in the gut. I feel for the guy, but someone who called their package manager "app get" in 2014 when "apt get" has existed for since 1998 is in no position to take umbrage at a competing package manager having a six-letter name ending in get.
- ttsda 6y agoHow does AppGet compete with apt-get?
- hoffs 6y agoIt's not about competing, it's about naming
- arcticfox 6y agoTo me, context matters. 'AppGet' sounds like a friendly hat tip to the legendary apt-get, given that they don't compete. 'WinGet', a direct copy of 'AppGet', is not a friendly reference IMO.
- ThrowawayR2 6y agoAnd why is "WinGet" not also a reference to apt-get? I've never even heard of AppGet before this morning.
- fluidcruft 6y agoAppGet sounds like "apt-get". On the other hand "WinGet" sounds like "wing-it" i.e. release any piece of junk and fix later. Maybe. Which TBF does seem to be how Microsoft works anyway.
- efreak 6y ago> release any piece of junk and fix later. Maybe. Which TBF does seem to be how Microsoft works anyway. It's been a while, but I managed to corrupt oneget/package management on windows within a month of it being released; I spent about a week trying to fix it and eventually figured out what the problem was (though I've since forgotten the details) only to find it unfixable without reinstalling Windows. Unfortunately, reinstalling Windows means Office won't reactivate--I've taken it into a Microsoft store, and they couldn't help me.
- SkyBelow 6y agoI would think that their old system of stack ranking would have had that selection impact. It has been gone for a long time but could it have had a lasting impact on company culture by who was being kept and who was promoted into positions that are responsible for the culture today? I don't think such a thought is unreasonable.
- asdf21 6y agoI only know a tiny bit about stack ranking, but I would think just the opposite... wasn't it designed to (at least partially) select for more conscientious employees?
- joncrane 6y ago>Does Microsoft select for assholes or something? Probably, but it's not limited to Microsoft. Any company where revenues are the highest goal (and all publicly traded companies should be this way; it's an obligation to share holders) will, generally speaking, select for assholes and sociopaths. How strong that selection is, how pervasive, and how quickly it happens are variables in the equation, but the effect is the same, and it sucks.
- GoblinSlayer 6y ago>Calling it "WinGet" was the real punch in the gut. Should they name it "wget"?