3 ms·
The physical principles behind criticality calculations are not fiendishly complicated. The computations are computationally intensive, yes (Slotin was around
by SamReidHughes 16y ago
The physical principles behind criticality calculations are not fiendishly complicated. The computations are computationally intensive, yes (Slotin was around in a time where experiments were cheaper and easier than simulations), and (maybe -- I don't know) the exact nature of physical materials involved was not well known, and needed to be measured.
Prove it.
Why don't you prove it? It's not other people's job to do all the work for you. It is provable that a sphere is the optimal shape. If somebody on the internet suggests that you're wrong, you don't win the argument by saying it's their responsibility to do all the hard work of convincing you you're right. You're still the one who is wrong.
- timr 16y ago"Why don't you prove it?" Because I'm not the one making extraordinary claims. I'm also arguing that you can't 'prove' anything in this situation; there are too many unknowns.
- lobster_johnson 16y ago> > "Why don't you prove it?" > Because I'm not the one making extraordinary claims. You are, though. You're the one suggesting a nuclear catastrophe, contrary to apparent scientific evidence.