4 ms·
There is no point in me saying this, because people are literally living in parallel universes at this point, but I feel that hatred for Trump and anything asso
by ilaksh 6y ago
There is no point in me saying this, because people are literally living in parallel universes at this point, but I feel that hatred for Trump and anything associated with the right is blinding people.
What most young people or people on the left seem to want very badly is for tech companies to remove viewpoints they disagree with. Unfortunately the reality is that this is in fact political censorship. And it will lead directly to the type of censorship that China has.
Go ahead and click the downvote button until my viewpoint disappears. It doesn't matter anymore. I actually think that the possibility of real free speech online, if it ever existed, is dead anyway. Because, bizarrely, people are begging for more censorship.
- w3mmpp 6y agoIndeed in a parallel universe but in the end they'll lose those battles one after the other because they are on the wrong side of history. People on the right need to be more vocal here and elsewhere, we can't let the children and their feelings, run the ship or it'll end badly.
- peteforde 6y agoCondescension is not a good look when you're conflating conservativism with paranoid conspiracies and equating really basic fact-checking to censorship.
- akvadrako 6y agoI’m doubtful that it does any good to provide opposing viewpoints in these threads unless you have something surprising to say, either facts or insight. The effect on reality of a HN thread isn’t much and it’s not really a place for nuanced discussion. The twitter thing doesn’t matter because the solution is obvious - we need decentralized platforms where such behavior isn’t possible.
- blisterpeanuts 6y agoIronically, back in the 1980s techies were fiercely pro-free speech and anti-censorship. The older companies like Apple and Microsoft still have some remnants of this culture, whereas newer ones like Google etc. are curiously ambivalent about freedom of speech.
- javagram 6y ago> What most young people or people on the left seem to want very badly is for tech companies to remove viewpoints they disagree with. Unfortunately the reality is that this is in fact political censorship. And it will lead directly to the type of censorship that China has. Trump is in power and he has repeatedly requested that cable news be censored by the FCC. 2017: https://www.wired.com/story/fcc-chair-finally-says-agency-wont-censor-trumps-enemies/ https://www.wired.com/story/fcc-chair-finally-says-agency-wo... “FCC Chair Finally Says Agency Won't Censor Trump's Enemies: Six days after President Trump suggested revoking broadcast licenses, FCC Chair Ajit Pai says agency won't act based on content.” 2018: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/donald-trump-nbc-broadcast-license-fake-news-attack-a8522651.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politic... “Trump suggests revoking NBC's broadcast license amid attacks on 'fake news'” 2020: https://assets.donaldjtrump.com/2017/web/hero_images/Redacted_PUSA_Letter.pdf https://assets.donaldjtrump.com/2017/web/hero_images/Redacte... his campaign threatens to sue TV stations who allow an ad against him to be aired So just saying, let’s not just blame young people or people on the left. There are very loud right wing voices demanding that the media be censored in their favor as well right now by government force. Personally I’d be more concerned at this point about government censorship than twitter adding a link to a post. There are many different websites on the internet, but only 1 US government.
- geofft 6y ago"Viewpoints" is a very broad word. I do not want tech companies to remove political opinions I disagree with (e.g. "We should go to war against Iraq," "Brexit is our only hope," "If you reduce taxes, society will be better off," etc.). I want tech companies to remove lies that do harm (e.g., "Someone should really investigate whether so-and-so killed so-and-so," "You should drink fish tank cleaner," "If you vote by mail, your vote won't be valid and you risk committing a felony"). Our society/culture has ample precedent that lies that do harm are not worth protecting and are worth penalizing. I do not want tech companies to give special protection to lies that do harm simply because the liar has a particular political affiliation or a particular political office. I want everyone to be treated equally regardless of their political affiliation and office. (If there happens to be a nonzero correlation between political affiliation and the telling of lies that do harm, well, that seems like a problem worth sorting out for the good of society, but tech companies should not put their fingers on the scale. They should remove lies that do harm without regard to political affiliation of the liars.)