5 ms·
I don't know the details of your project, but what if you open sourced under the GPL? I feels as though the world has soured on the GPL in recent years, but wh
by Wowfunhappy 6y ago
I don't know the details of your project, but what if you open sourced under the GPL?
I feels as though the world has soured on the GPL in recent years, but whenever I see this type of sentiment—that open sourcing work is just a gift from small developers to big tech companies, or something thereabouts—I think, wouldn't the GPL solve that problem?
Sure, big companies can still use GPL'd code, but they're forced to give back as much as they take, which is exactly the outcome you want.
(This doesn't necessarily apply to the situation with AppGet, however.)
- bluGill 6y agoBig companies are more likely to give back to non gpl code in my experience. The gpl scares them enough that when they use it they isolate it carefully so they don't have to make changes. Non gpl code (depending on license terms of course) get embedded where it is easier to need changes and then a desire to keep up with some other feature means they contribute back. Of course either way they are a business and will be careful. Their core business will not be contributed.
- rusticpenn 6y agoDual licensing helps. AGPL or Paid licence.
- SeeTheTruth 6y agoSo it's not worth it. Why be less careful than companies in the hope they will be good citizens, when it's easier to be careful and not have to hope?
- lostmsu 6y agoThat would not have helped MongoDB. I considered their new license, but it seemed tailored to their specifics. So maybe more research is required. Perhaps a variant of CC-BY NC would be better, but it is not tailored to code.
- colejohnson66 6y agoWhat’s wrong with AGPL?
- lostmsu 6y agoAFAIK AGPL permits linking without disclosing linked code like LGPL does. Meaning they can still distribute it as their own, train models and serve them with a simpler framework. Just can't build services powered directly by it.
- leonidasv 6y agoAGPL is as strict as GPL. It's just that GPL allows you to modify the source, serve them as a web application and not have to disclose the code. AGPL addresses that by putting code distributed as a web application in the same category as compiled code.
- hnick 6y agoIf my web server calls out to AGPL software (such as executing a transform on a PDF using Ghostscript) as an external binary is this covered even though the AGPL code is not directly compiled, linked or modified? I'd assume so otherwise it would be a very easy loophole and code could be firewalled into separate modules but I'm not sure what exact language covers this in the license.
- chii 6y agoIt's untested in court. GCC is written specifically to prevent this sort of firewalling of the compiler to prevent it from being plugged into another piece of software and avoid GPL requirements.
- hnick 6y agoGood to know, it'll be interesting if it ever does get tested. Even then there's always the analogue/human loophole I suppose, similar to captcha mechanical turks.
- na85 6y agoBy Eben Moglen's own admission[0], the GPL has never been successfully enforced in a court of law, even against criminal infringers. It seems toothless to me. A relic from a byegone era when companies cared about ethical behavior. [0] https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/enforcing-gpl.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/enforcing-gpl.html
- colejohnson66 6y agoThe GPL has been used successfully in courts of law. It’s not common as most violators just open source when called out, or settle when sued, but it has worked before. A famous example is D-Link using the Linux kernel in their routers. After a lawsuit in Germany, D-Link had to release their changes.[0] I don’t understand this idea that a license that the author willingly released his code under is unenforceable, but EULAs are? [0]: https://web.archive.org/web/20141007073104/http://gpl-violations.org/news/20060922-dlink-judgement_frankfurt.html https://web.archive.org/web/20141007073104/http://gpl-violat...
- tracker1 6y agoOf course with all/most US routers generally taking only signed ROMs, it's mostly useless to even have the code. I wish they'd just create something closer to tomato than the flashy, less useful interfaces.
- colejohnson66 6y agoThat problem is called TiVoization. It’s addressed with the 3rd version of the GPL. Sadly, Linus is adamantly against that clause.
- chii 6y ago> Linus is adamantly against that clause. oh i didnt know he was adamant against the clause - i thought that he didn't want to force it upon the many existing users of linux.