13 ms·
Attaching a disclaimer to the speech of another though is not straightforward. Will they get into the business of fact checking everyone over certain number of
by mc32 6y ago
Attaching a disclaimer to the speech of another though is not straightforward. Will they get into the business of fact checking everyone over certain number of followers? Will they do it impartially world-wide? How can they even be impartial world wide given the different contradictory points of view, valid from both sides? Cyprus? What’s the take there?
- Talanes 6y agoWhat requires them to be impartial?
- 2019-nCoV 6y agoOpen a history book.
- Talanes 6y agoA history book would seem an odd place to find legislation.
- 2019-nCoV 6y agoA great place to see what lies ahead for a divisive society
- pasquinelli 6y agoWhat is a divisive society?
- Avicebron 6y agoA society that can't agree on what a divisive society is. In all seriousness, when actors with influence on public thought are having public arguments about politics, social roles, virus response plans. Now you can argue society has always been divisive, but instead of an Athenian public square with have platforms with millions of people getting involved. Amplified divisiveness.
- heromal 6y agoYou just described a modern society...
- moralestapia 6y agoIt's not a "requirement" but by policing/editing content (other than what is explicitly illegal) you open yourself to a whole new set of obligations/liabilities that no one really wants to deal with. IANAL but an example could be: Someone posts a pirate ebook on their facebook profile. They can hide behind the "yeah but it was the user" harbor. vs. Someone posts a pirate ebook on a facebook profile, facebook staff thinks it's cool and puts it on a special themed section called "Pirate picks from today". They will be in trouble.
- zem 6y agothey didn't police anything; the guy's tweet got posted without any sort of gatekeeping they didn't edit anything; it was very clear what he posted and it was his exact words as written. there weren't even any dark ui patterns to make it look like the fact check was part of what he said.
- moralestapia 6y agoI don't know about "they" and "the guy". I was just explaining why, in general, content providers prefer to stay of trouble ...
- mc32 6y agoMaybe they’ll do the same for their advertisers too? Maybe they’ll fact check UBI? Etc...
- ashtonkem 6y agoThat would be their right, yes.
- gpm 6y ago1. You're generally wrong except in some special cases 2. Twitter already automatically adds posts to special themed sections called "What's happening", so even if you were right there is no added liability. 3. Adding fact checking is not adding things to special themed sections, so this is off topic.
- eanzenberg 6y agoAs they move into a “publisher” role, they will be liable in count.
- root_axis 6y agoYou're wrong. Stop spreading misinformation. > No provider or user of an interactive computer service shall be treated as the publisher or speaker of any information provided by another information content provider" (47 U.S.C. § 230)
- moralestapia 6y ago>You're wrong. Stop spreading misinformation. Be a bit more tolerant of other people's point of view. Anyway, I think you are misinterpreting the intention of that sentence. It basically means that, in principle, the behavior of being a "provider or user of an interactive computer service" does not imply that it is "the publisher or speaker of any information provided [...]". But that does not exempt them from potentially being the actual publisher, and all the rights/obligations that go with it. Trivial example: Someone publishing its work on the web (hence becoming a "user of an interactive computer service") does not imply that they lose copyright; even though they "shall [not] be treated as the publisher or speaker of any information provided [...]". Again, IANAL, but I read a lot of copyright, safe harbor law, DCMAs, etc... and it goes like that.
- root_axis 6y ago> Be a bit more tolerant of other people's point of view. Why would I tolerate a blatant falsehood? > that does not exempt them from being the actual publisher, and all the rights/obligations that go with it. With respect, you're totally misinformed. Social media websites do not fall under any kind of "publisher" obligation, this is a totally made up meme that people spread online. Now, if you want to argue that we should change the laws so that these websites would fall under some kind of publisher obligations, I would disagree, but that would at least allow room for "tolerance of other people's point of view". However, in terms of the actual law you and the parent are unequivocally incorrect.
- awb 6y agoFairness is an impossible outcome but a worthwhile pursuit. There are tons of edge cases with free speech, but we almost certainly want the free market to experiment with potential solutions. It would be great if there were attempts at a free speech Twitter, a free of hate Twitter, free of disinformation Twitter, etc. and let the chips fall where they may.
- dangoljames 6y agoThere is no constitutional edge or corner case. The language, for once, is unambiguous.
- blahbhthrow3748 6y agoWait, to be clear you mean the language "Congress shall make no law" which clearly doesn't apply to Twitter? I agree it's unambiguous the constitution doesn't allow the government to restrict Twitter's rights
- didibus 6y agoIsn't that exactly what happened with the internet? And it seems the market have already chosen that a slightly moderated but not too heavily model seems to retain and attract the most users. Twitter I don't think is putting in place these moderation mechanism for fun or through their own personal CEO's own moral and ethics. They do what they think will be best for business.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoI don't want free martek experimentation here. Freedom and promotion of speech has massive effect on society and politics of the day. It's massively inappropriate to put market forces and wallstreet quarterly reports in charge of it.
- awb 6y agoFree speech in a public, shared space is a constitutional right. Free speech to write whatever you want on a private company's website is not. It's governed by their terms of service. As long as their terms of service is applied equally and consistently it should be legal as far as I know. Maybe you could make the argument that their rules are discriminatory and aren't being (or can't be) enforced equally, but that's different from telling a company that they have to accept any type of content without restriction. FB, YT, Reddit, Twitter, etc. have been removing posts and banning users for years. So, the act isn't new, but the fact that it's being applied to the President is new.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoas long as they are not using limited public goods (e.g. part of the EM spectrum to broadcast), then from my perspective they can do anything they want assuming it doesn't break another law. now if they want to use limited public goods, well then there's a role for the FCC or something like it...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- free_rms 6y agoTwitter is the place where the entire media and political classes hang out. They're all addicted to it. These people's opinions shape real-world politics and election outcomes. Could that be a 'limited public good'? Due to the network effects, it seems like only one website at a time would hold this status.
- ashtonkem 6y agoNo, you don’t get to declare something to be a limited public good after it gets popular.
- free_rms 6y agoTwitter deserves credit for creating their platform, absolutely. They created a platform where everyday people can interact with top media and politicians. Now that it's here, and they're all on it.. "the coffee shop can throw you out" seems a little trite. I don't like Trump either, set him aside, what if we were on the wrong side of Twitter's politics?
- ashtonkem 6y agoI fear letting the government regulate twitter more than I fear twitter deciding my politics aren’t acceptable. I can leave Twitter, but creating a back door for the government to regulate political speech has consequences that stretch much further than Twitter itself.
- tw04 6y agoI love the theoretical situation that doesn't exist as a justification for not doing the right thing. This isn't a "different points of view" - this is the leader of the United States LYING on their platform, and them choosing to provide a link to FACTUAL INFORMATION. There is no "contradictory point of view" - he claimed there was massive voter fraud and there's literally 0 proof to back up his claim and mountains of evidence to counter it.
- mc32 6y agoI think the claim is an exaggeration, but I don’t think that the method is fraud proof. Let’s see fact checks on diet claims, exercise, claims about social solutions, claims about the economy, etc., etc. Let’s see fact checks on their own advertisers.
- dangoljames 6y agoTheir advertisers are not operating from the office of the chief executive of one of the largest and most successful of nations.
- mc32 6y agoSo some forms of disinformation are more acceptable than others even if they have more immediate effects on people?
- D-Coder 6y agoThis is the "Doesn't cure cancer!" response. They don't have to be perfect. They don't have to save the world. They don't have to cure cancer. Any improvement is an improvement.
- gamblor956 6y agoYes. There are degrees of disinformation. Some are worse than others. Life is not binary.
- cgy1 6y agoThey don't have to because they would've banned and will continue to ban anyone else who's tweeted the type of stuff that Trump's tweeted. They've only gotten into this situation because they've refused to ban or suspend Trump's account.
- everdrive 6y agoTwitter's not the supreme court, and they don't have to set a universal maxim to act.
- mc32 6y agoExactly. They are not, but they like to play like they are.
- diffrinse 6y agoBecause it's their walled garden and everyone using it signed a contract acknowledging this
- RealityVoid 6y agoYou can argue it's wrong or imoral or destructive to society or whatnot, by you can not argue that, within the context of US law, it is illegal. They are perfectly within the bound of the law to do what they do. What would NOT be lawful would be Trump to close them down because they did what they did. That is full stop illegal if he did it. Not sure how legal it even is to threaten it this way. At this point, Twitter might as well even close Trump's account. Still legal, still within their rights.
- lenkite 6y agoSure they can. And then they can be treated as a publisher with ALL the legal liabilities. They can be sued in court as the 1996 Communications Decency Act. Section 230 will no longer be applied to them.
- gpm 6y ago> Attaching a disclaimer to the speech of another though is not straightforward. Yes it is, it just involves adding an html element below it > Will they get into the business of fact checking everyone over certain number of followers Their choice, because of the first amendment they can do it to anyone or noone at their leisure or based on whatever criteria they like and as arbitrarily as they like. > Will they do it impartially world-wide Their choice, because of the first amendment they can choose to be as impartial or as partial as they like as locally or globally as they like. > How can they even be impartial world wide given the different contradictory points of view, valid from both sides The simplest solution is to not be impartial, but that's a decision that is wholly up to them and whatever they decide is protected by the first amendment See how simple it is? They do whatever they feel like and the government is obligated to not interfere. The end. (Other governments might object to some of these decisions, the US government most certainly has no legal power to)
- beager 6y agoThank you. The naive, incorrect view is that private entities restrict your constitutional rights by refusing to host UGC or by editorializing/annotating it. An evolved, but still incorrect view is that a private entity is legally or constitutionally obligated to apply their policy about hosting speech consistently across all users.
- Simulacra 6y agoNo, it doesn’t work like that, corporations will only FactCheck people they disagree with.
- ashtonkem 6y agoThere are certainly prudential concerns with platforms fact checking; is Twitter implying that other Trump tweets are factually correct? But whether or not you like the feature, the idea that the president of the United States would threaten “shutting down” Twitter because he doesn’t like a feature is beyond the pale, full stop.
- bfdm 6y agoIs any of that necessary? Applying extra scrutiny to the president is not unusual.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Attaching a disclaimer to the speech of another though is not straightforward. From a free speech perspective, it's straightforward, private parties can choose to relay (or not) whatever viewpoints they want, and can choose to relay those viewpoints with or without commentary. From a “what’s an ideal policy” perspective, maybe it's not, but “your policy is not ideal” isn't an exception to free speech justifying government intervention. > How can they even be impartial Private actors aren't required to be impartial. In fact, the whole premise of the marketplace of ideas is that private parties will be partial in choosing which ideas to present and how to present them.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> In fact, the whole premise of the marketplace of ideas is that private parties will be partial in choosing which ideas to present and how to present them. The issue is that a few giant corporations have got a cartel going. It's really an antitrust problem which is only a speech problem because the market is the marketplace of ideas.
- gigatexal 6y agoIn the game of whack-a-mole of false-information spewers I think it makes sense to tag those with the largest audiences who have the largest sway like Trump as this is the most efficient way to curb disinformation. Twitter is doing the public a solid by doing this and I laud them for it.
- lenkite 6y agoYes, especially when so-called fact checking is also deeply flawed and does not link to the actual congressional reports and investigations.