11 ms·
France, Italy, Belgium stop hydroxychloroquine use for Covid-19 on safety fears
- lbeltrame 6y agoA shame, since the Lancet paper has problems[1][2] in particular related to the baseline of the HCQ-treated vs non-HCQ treated patients. And by admission of the authors themselves, it is not a substitute of a RCT. And this before the results of the Minnesota trial are out. At this point I hope those are negative, so that it does not show that countries are overreacting. [1] https://statmodeling.stat.columbia.edu/2020/05/25/hydroxychloroquine-update/ https://statmodeling.stat.columbia.edu/2020/05/25/hydroxychl... and related posts [2] https://twitter.com/StevePhillipsMD/status/1263899569252896771 https://twitter.com/StevePhillipsMD/status/12638995692528967... PS: The title is misleading. The ban is on the use on severe diseases, not all of them, according to the text in the news.
- orwin 6y agoYes, i'm not a proponent of HCQ, not without RCT as some of my previous post might tell you, but the "raw" data of the Lancet study seems pretty well harmonized for raw data, i wouldn't trust this study for my national policies. I can't take HCQ as i already have extrasystole and a allergies treatment that already can cause arythmia, so i hope this won't be the "best" treatment, but really this paper, while interesting, should not be used to take decisions.
- lbeltrame 6y agoAs I wrote elsewhere (check my post history) I personally think that if the effect is there, it is small. I don't really mind if HCQ doesn't work, but I get mad when people say "follow the science", and the most basic thing to do for science (a RCT) is not done. Let's see if the U of Minnesota trial is published soon. The PI of the study tweeted he had sent revisions to the manuscript, and hoped for a publication this week (and he however added that he thought the same last week).
- tialaramex 6y ago> most basic thing to do for science (a RCT) is not done. Randomised Controlled Trials are the gold standard but not the "most basic thing". They are the ideal we'd like to have but often simply aren't an option. One of the most obvious reasons we often can't do a trial is that we have good reason to believe it would be unreasonably dangerous, which is why these trials stopped. The opposite scenario happens sometimes too. If all patients treated with Hydroxychloroquine magically got better they'd stop the trial and recommend immediately using it on similar patients.
- pen2l 6y agoLancet isn't the only paper that has raised issues with HCQ treatment. Sciencemag [1] has this to say: However, both HCQ and AZ have potential cardiac toxicity (QT prolongation, which can lead to fatal arrhythmia), and HCQ additionally has the potential for negative effects on the eye. Understanding risk-benefit ratios is paramount if these drugs are to become a standard of care for COVID-19. Several post hoc analyses carried out in the United States and Europe suggest modest benefit, at best, from HCQ monotherapy for COVID-19 patients; one large post hoc analysis among U.S. veterans suggests that there is harm to patients from HCQ. Given the mechanistic rationale but lack of well-designed clinical studies and potential for drug-induced toxicity, there is a key need for controlled, randomized trials to test the efficacy and safety of these drugs for COVID-19 patients. [1]: https://science.sciencemag.org/content/sci/368/6493/829.full.pdf https://science.sciencemag.org/content/sci/368/6493/829.full... I don't think it's a "shame" that some have decided to stop wtih HCQ when other viable treatments seem to have less concerning side-effects. Either way, we will know very soon with greater certainty as ongoing randomized trials finish up.
- lbeltrame 6y agoMost of these analyses were done in late-stage COVID-19 patients, when any antiviral won't work (same results with remedisivir, lopinavir/ritonavir/ribavirin), that's why the discussion won't stop. Didier Raoult in his very controversial paper suggested prophylaxis after exposure to the virus. And guess what, no one (save the U of Minnesota trial, AFAICS) has done a RCT on that. EDIT: I think it's a "shame" because all analyses so far focused on the late-stage disease, as I said, and because hopefully real RCT results will be out soon (like, real soon, or so I hope).
- mxcrossb 6y agoIt seems like we’re in trouble if we try to pursue a drug that has to be administered early in the disease process. Such a large percentage of people recover on their own that even a very effective drug has limited returns. And of course you need the infrastructure to detect the disease early and deliver huge supplies. It makes me worry that all antivirals we try will fail.
- cataflam 6y ago> PS: The title is misleading. The ban is on the use on severe diseases, not all of them, according to the text in the news. And the RCTs are still going and will finish, unless there is a major negative effect noticed in them, which is not the case so far.
- lbeltrame 6y agoIndeed, there is hope that a definitive answer will come out (at this point, given how politicized the discourse is, any answer in either direction willl be fine). FTR, the U of Minnesota trials used normal dosages and (according to its PI) did not report any cardiotoxicity so far.
- acallaghan 6y agoIf it had any effect on covid-19, it'd be very obvious by now. There isn't some massive conspiracy here, it just doesn't work. The reason trials have stopped is because France, Italy, Belgium & the UK have seen worse outcomes generally, directly because of it. I don't get the 'it needs to be taken before symptoms!' argument - like we can possibly give a immunosuppressant with non-negligible side-effects (e.g. arrythmia) to billions of people with no scientific evidence of it working on covid at all.
- zackees 6y agoIt HCQ doesn't work, why is it the common first line of defense used internationally? Why does scholar.google.com list so many papers showing that it's effective?
- ceejayoz 6y agoBecause it's a highly effective and widespread malaria (and RA/lupus) treatment?
- vixen99 6y agoThe dose for malaria is 200mg. It's the higher doses that are associated with heart arythmia in covid patients. According to a trial reported in https://bmcmedicine.biomedcentral.com/track/pdf/10.1186/s12916-018-1188-2 https://bmcmedicine.biomedcentral.com/track/pdf/10.1186/s129... "No serious cardiac adverse effects were recorded in malaria clinical trials of 35,548 participants who received quinoline and structurally related antimalarials with close follow-up including 18,436 individuals who underwent ECG evaluation." "Chloroquine is the most widely used antimalarial drug in history. It has a terminal elimination half-life of one month and an annual consumption of hundreds of tonnes for over 50 years, so it may be the drug to which humans have been exposed to most. Despite producing consistent QT prolongation, the only case reports of TdP and sudden death have been for its use for non-malaria indications such as systemic lupus erythematosus or rheumatoid arthritis, where high doses are used for much longer than in malaria treatment, or in overdose"
- halflings 6y agoAgree this isn't an RCT, but why would this be an "over-reaction"? It's not like the default reaction is to administrate millions of doses of a medicine that has yet to be proven effective. (and could potentially do more harm than good) The studies supposedly proving HCQ's effectiveness have much bigger caveats (tiny sample size and/or manipulation of the groups in a dishonest way, like Raoult removing severe cases from the treatment group whereas the control group had none)
- lenkite 6y ago“India has so far made the right decision on HCQ and that this decision has been based on evidence,” Preeti Sudan, Secretary, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, was quoted as saying by The Hindu. The government late last week extended the use of HCQ for paramilitary and police personnel involved in COVID-19 management, besides direct health care providers for positive patients. Soumya Swaminathan, Chief Scientist at WHO also told The Hindu that WHO is not advising stopping all HCQ trials but has only dropped HCQ from the Solidarity Trial, and that many prophylaxis trials using HCQ are ongoing or about to start.
- OneGuy123 6y ago"coronavirus is what happens when you put the reproducibility crisis in charge of the planet"
- umvi 6y ago-- @mwilcox[0] [0] https://twitter.com/mwilcox/status/1260458110596120576 https://twitter.com/mwilcox/status/1260458110596120576
- 0xcafecafe 6y agoCan someone please elaborate on this? What is the "reproducibility crisis" in this case?
- xapata 6y ago"Most published research findings are false" (not reproducible) https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1182327/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1182327/
- whydoyoucare 6y agoThis is an excellent read: https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/12/12/beware-the-man-of-one-study/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/12/12/beware-the-man-of-one-... -- basically says one has to be very skeptical of trusting a study that suits the narrative, and how studies can be cherry-picked to align with your narrative.
- umvi 6y agoReproducibility crisis is well known, especially in social sciences. However, it affects other science fields as well. In a nutshell, the crisis is that there is far more incentive to churn out a new publication/study than reproduce an existing one. So we have tons of studies that are the only one of its kind that have not been reproduced. The crisis part comes in where attempts to reproduce the results of these studies fail which throws into question the legitimacy of the entire field's publications. So you can imagine how putting your faith into covid-19 related studies (such as effects of hydroxychloroquine) that were rushed and results not reproduced independently can result in problems down the road. Science is probably the best tool we have for determining truth. However, it takes a long time and a lot of effort to converge on the truth and people put far more faith than they ought to in the results of fresh publications that have results they like (or fear).
- Alex3917 6y agoMeh. It wouldn't surprise me if these trials are being run by the makers of Remdesivir or some other drug, and they're purposely killing folks to make their treatment look more effective. It's a pretty common tactic in the pharma industry for drug makers to do trials with enormous doses of their competitors products to make them look more dangerous by comparison, and given that this whole thing has turned into a multi-billion dollar cash grab I would assume that that's what's happening here unless proven otherwise. It's the same thing with famatodine, where someone observed that folks taking it for heartburn have a lower risk of death. So rather than doing an RCT with giving folks 10mg orally (a normal dose), someone started doing an RCT with like 140mg injected. Just thinking about it logically, why would you ever give someone a drug that ostensibly works by blocking viral replication when they've already had the virus for multiple weeks? It makes zero sense, which tells you there is something shady going on.
- cm2187 6y agoParticularly in the case of a 1950s drug that has been consumed by millions of people, and which as far as I know was available without prescription until covid. It’s like saying aspirin is dangerous. Sure. At a certain dosage.
- bonzini 6y agoQuinine-based drugs are no small thing. They are neurotoxic even at low dosages, for example (the somewhat-related antimalaric drug mefloquine very often causes really bad nightmares, at the very low prophylactic dosage, and it has a long half life so they persist even a few weeks after you've stopped taking it).
- lenkite 6y agoWe are talking about HCQ. Perhaps its use is strange in the US, but in India its commonly prescribed for malaria (and also lupus, arthritis). My entire extended family (ex-military) has taken HCQ at one point of time or another. No ill-effects for millions of people. Heavy dosages should be avoided of-course.
- pjc50 6y agoThis is essentially the Andrew Wakefield fiasco on speedrun, isn't it? My skepticism was founded entirely on seeing who was promoting this idea, and it is slowly being vindicated.
- lbeltrame 6y ago> My skepticism was founded entirely on seeing who was promoting this idea The proponent has no effect on the null hypothesis. What was needed was a RCT: no results are out for any, at this point.
- dougmwne 6y agoI disagree from a statistical point of view. Of all possible hypothesis we choose to study, for the great majority we will fail to reject the null hypothesis. (For most things we study, we will find the treatment has no discernible effect.) If some unstudied hypothesis is being promoted at random by vested interests, the chance that it is in fact an effective treatment is low because most treatments we would try are ineffective. And a vested interest will use every rhetorical tool at its disposal to promote what it is selling, including citing studies and scientists. If those do not exist or seem low-quality then skepticism is warranted. We should be wary of all medical claims till they are supported by high quality evidence.
- take_a_breath 6y agoIf the snake oil salesman presents a new, improved brand of snake oil, skepticism is wise.
- fat_turdsicle 6y agoThe salesman being the medical establishment, and the new improved snake oil being Remdesivir? I read you loud and clear, buddy.
- maxerickson 6y agoYou are describing a decision making framework with no real world applicability. Like, how do we decide which things to study with RCTs? We ask experts...
- flashyfaffe2 6y agoThis is what I appreciate in YC feed. You got far more better information gathered in one than the MSN article shared initially.
- Luc 6y agoFor better information, I would suggest following the credentialed scientific experts on Twitter. You can get information straight from the very best people in their field. Here, I feel it's a bit of a crap shoot, and half the comments are misinformed & happy to share it.
- dpoochieni 6y agoHaha, damned Poe's law, hope this was sarcasm! During Galileo's time most credentialed experts believed the sun to spin around the earth.
- reccanti 6y agoI think it’s always good to be wary of relying uncritically on experts. Nobody’s infallible, but there’s valuable perspective that comes from “person actively involved in the process” vs. “Armchair Hacker News expert”
- zabana 6y agoInterestingly enough, the french military are still using it to treat their personnel.
- fratajcz 6y agoThey have only confirmed ordering some in case it is proven to be useful. (this was 1 month ago) https://factuel.afp.com/oui-larmee-francaise-sest-procure-de-la-chloroquine-elle-invoque-un-achat-de-precaution https://factuel.afp.com/oui-larmee-francaise-sest-procure-de...
- scottmsul 6y agoA cardiotoxicity paper from the WHO in 2017 said the following: "Despite hundreds of millions of doses administered in the treatment of malaria, there have been no reports of sudden unexplained death associated with quinine, chloroquine or amodiaquine, although each drug causes QT/QTcinterval prolongation. Unfortunately, there are relatively few prospective studies of the electrocardiographic effects of these drugs." Link to paper: https://www.who.int/malaria/mpac/mpac-mar2017-erg-cardiotoxicity-report-session2.pdf https://www.who.int/malaria/mpac/mpac-mar2017-erg-cardiotoxi... Link to Chris Martenson's video where I first heard about the 2017 paper: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rN_YpFhdii4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rN_YpFhdii4 Chris Martenson is doing an awesome job staying on top of the science in an apolitical manner.
- Alex3917 6y agoHaving ACE2 receptors depleted increases blood pressure and changes the properties of blood itself (probably the source of the weird clotting issues), so it makes sense that there would be more risk with Covid-19. Plus many or most Covid patients are probably already polypharming with 5+ drugs already given their age, unlike people going on vacation to Bali or wherever. I wouldn't trust the trials showing that it's dangerous, but I wouldn't assume it's safe either.
- klmadfejno 6y agoThe data from those hundreds of millions of doses were on people who did not have COVID-19. It's not contradictory to say that the drug does not tend to cause these effects generally, but does cause these effects in a specific context. Like, say, a deadly disease wrecking havoc on your oxygen levels. Maybe it does, maybe it doesn't. Hard to know anything.
- cozzyd 6y agoAlso, the dosage may be different
- YeGoblynQueenne 6y agoFrom the linked paper: Summary of findings and proposed recommendations 1. Apart from halofantrine, antimalarial medicines thatprolong the QT/QTc interval,such as quinine, chloroquine, artesunate-amodiaquine and dihydroartemisinin-piperaquine,have beenassociated with a low risk of cardiotoxicity. This seems to indicate that there is a risk, albeit low. The risk is for cardiotoxicity, not sudden deaths.
- nana- 6y agoWhat a shame