8 ms·
If you're living in fear go find a paid platform where you are the customer instead of the product. If you aren't making enough money on YouTube to be able to
by colechristensen 6y ago
If you're living in fear go find a paid platform where you are the customer instead of the product.
If you aren't making enough money on YouTube to be able to afford paying someone to host your content and provide better, paid customer service, then you have to consider that the risk of being on a mostly automated, poorly supported platform is the only thing keeping you from losing money, or in other words, is the sole source of your income.
When you are as big as Google, very improbable failures happen all the time, pointing them out doesn't tell the story of how well they're doing unless your expectation is constant perfection. Go find rates, not anecdotes, then you might have something.
Also, if you're being blackmailed and harassed, it would seem to be a matter for the police and the courts, not Google, to fix.
- colinmhayes 6y agoYoutube has locked viewers in. If a content creator leaves youtube no one consumes their content, so this isn't really an option.
- colechristensen 6y agoThen complain about Google's monopoly, not its moderation inadequacies, and consider that creators unwilling to leave are the source of the monopoly, not necessarily its victims, especially if they're not even trying other platforms. I guess I don't like the entitlement/blame cycle where people who help create a problem complain about the consequences.
- colinmhayes 6y agoThe monopoly is due to threshold of creators being on youtube. A single channel leaving would make no difference. I'd love to see a movement away from youtube, but that would require a movement with serous organization, which creators mostly aren't capable of doing.
- colechristensen 6y agoCue the Simpsons clip "we've tried nothing and we're all out of ideas". If one is not willing, capable, or even interested in trying to solve problems they help create, as an individual or a group, I have very little interest in sympathy for their difficulty.
- colinmhayes 6y agoHow is writing blog posts not trying something? Seems pretty clear to me that content creators are trying to create outrage to force youtube's hand, which seems to me to be the only successful strategy other than getting laws changed.
- colechristensen 6y agoIf the only thing you are willing to do about your problems is publicly complain about them implicitly hoping for an angry mob in response is... quite nearly the least you could do. I think I have expended the amount that I care about the issue.
- Dylan16807 6y agoPeople have tried it, that's how we know it doesn't work. Refusing your pet idea isn't a refusal to do anything at all.
- flukus 6y ago> I'd love to see a movement away from youtube I have seen that, particularly in history channel circles were the content get demonetized for things like saying Hitler, many of them band together and publish to youtube last or not at all and promote these other channels in their videos. I don't know if any of them will be successful, but staying on youtube simply isn't an option for them either. I think if/when youtube falters it will be death be a thousand cuts, it won't be a single movement with organization and it won't be to something else as centralized.
- marcus_holmes 6y ago
- csallen 6y agoIt's quite possible to create content that survives and thrives without depending on some large, proprietary platform like YouTube. Happens all the time. Of course it's not easy. You have to figure out growth for yourself, and most indie businesses and projects fail. Then again, so do most YouTube channels. So it's up to you to choose the indie path or choose YouTube.
- colechristensen 6y agoYou can also do things because you want to do them, share ideas because you want to share them. This advertising fueled content filled Internet is pretty toxic. I don't remember any of the Internet idealism of the 90s mentioning the great progress of sharing information involving the creator of every piece of data available making a fraction of a cent every time it was consumed. I don't mind people getting paid to do things of course, but I do mind a culture dominated by selling each other's attention to advertisers in exchange for creative output, or creative output solely for the dopamine shot from attention and likes.
- brokencode 6y agoThat’s a pretty indifferent attitude to take. Do things because you want to? A lot of people make these videos for a living, and have no choice but to feed the advertisement machine. The business model of the internet is not something most content creators have any control over, and it’s pointless to criticize them for it. The only players who might be able to do that are the big tech companies controlling the platforms, which is why they take a lot of flak for how things are going.
- colechristensen 6y ago>That’s a pretty indifferent attitude to take. I don't see that at all. Encouraging people to do things for their own merit and not just to make money – and we have to be realistic here, most people trying to make money on YouTube or anywhere by creating content won't ever see a single dollar from it, so it's more like trying to win a crappy lottery. It's this constant sense of entitlement or talking like people are forced into making videos for a living which bothers me. It's a crappy job that is pretty easy to know how it works before you get into it. I keep seeing "no choice", well you can always do something else.
- Noos 6y agoIf viewers would actually pay for content they like, this wouldn't be an issue. The problems are that tech companies are 1. dumping product well under cost while 2. training customers not to pay anything. At some point, people need to realize what constantly wanting things for free is costing them and the people they watch.
- StavrosK 6y ago> At some point, people need to realize what constantly wanting things for free is costing them and the people they watch. It's not free, we pay for the content by buying products, it's just very very indirect.
- Applejinx 6y agoMuch of the population isn't economically able to purchase all the media they watch. The Silicon Valley 'everything free' experience doesn't exist in a vacuum, it's in an environment where there's an overwhelming majority of people who are only able to pay with their time and attention. Which is the Star Trek model. It's the future of 'nobody has to work to eat, and so now people go insane trying to pursue popularity since survival's a solved problem'. That makes it interesting in its own right, and we can already see both the possibilities and the 'race to the bottom' factor that ensues.
- jhelphenstine 6y ago“If you’re being blackmailed...” does sound like a matter for legal redress, but it ought not suffice as a guard against a company backed by Alphabet’s resources taking action. While your argument is technically sound, the consequences of inaction by YouTube can exit the sterile world of bits and bytes and bring real pain.
- Klinky 6y agoHow does one find ban/review rates for YouTube? Wouldn't this be internal data? Can you provide a link to a public datasource that shows shows outcomes of YouTube's banning/takedown and review processes?
- colechristensen 6y agoComb through public support forums, do public asks for reports of inappropriate moderation outcomes, find someone with significant enough financial losses to justify a lawsuit and use the legal discovery process to get internal stats or ask Google's representative on the stand, ask your state or national representative to support legislation requiring publishing of such statistics... there are a few ideas. All of them would require action to try to get data, I wouldn't know of any existing data because I haven't looked.
- Klinky 6y agoOk, so the answer is: no. This information isn't publicly available or easily accessible.
- colechristensen 6y agoI have no idea, like I said. I haven't looked and wouldn't otherwise know.
- spenthil 6y agohttps://transparencyreport.google.com/youtube-policy/removals https://transparencyreport.google.com/youtube-policy/removal...
- Klinky 6y agoNice, though aggregate data doesn't allow for third party analysis, only the analysis presented by YouTube, which if you suspect YouTube's analysis/handling, isn't that useful. That said there would be some privacy concerns if that data was just floating around out there.
- acituan 6y ago> When you are as big as Google, very improbable failures happen all the time, pointing them out doesn't tell the story of how well they're doing unless your expectation is constant perfection Just a thought experiment, does Youtube need to be as big as it is? Can’t Youtube say “given the current accuracy/precision of ML based solutions and how much our manual operations can scale, we are going to rate limit the content that circulates to match our ability of giving the best judgment on what videos to take down and what videos to keep”. Physical stores have maximum occupancy limits, and with coronavirus some even shown proactive rate limiting to say “hey, we can’t ensure transmission control above a certain density”. Those are corporations too, those also have fiduciary duty. I think “growth at all costs” is a major driver of these types of failures, especially when costs are externalized and distributed to the userbase; one annoying notification, one abuse feature change, one harmful policy decision at a time. > Go find rates, not anecdotes, then you might have something Youtube has near perfect knowledge of the warm data of their operations, and use it to optimize user frustration rather than minimize it, while we only get to know others are being abused when news make it to Hacker News. The inability to find the rates is inherent to the problem. Short of sneaking into Youtube data centers, there is only so much data you can find without Youtube’s say so. Which brings the question, for such a massive policy layer operation, why is this data not made transparent?
- colechristensen 6y ago>Just a thought experiment, does Youtube need to be as big as it is? A few scattered moderation complaints compared to wholesale rate limiting of incoming content... I can only imagine the madness of content producers if YouTube tried that. >Youtube has near perfect knowledge of the warm data of their operations, and use it to optimize user frustration rather than minimize it YouTube content moderation isn't human spaceflight. Having a goal of never failing is, well, a very inexperienced way of thinking about failure. On the order of half a million hours of new video content a day goes on YouTube, or something like 6 million uploads. Let's just pretend that the moderation decision is only made once on upload, you make 6 million decisions a day, how many ridiculous decisions are you going to make every day? Do you think that number is ever going to be zero? The reality is that there is an exponential relationship. Let's just say you can double your cost to cut failures in half. If it's not that relationship it'll be something like it. You can just keep doing it. Doubling your cost over and over, and you're still going to fail all the time. When a "one in a million" chance means something happens several times a day, well, you have to have a different attitude about failure. And when you're just about the only game in town, whatever you do to mitigate failure is going to attract people trying to screw with you to upset you and your users, to take advantage. Not only are you trying not to fail every day, you're trying to avoid people exploiting those attempts. It's just reality that you have a popular service, there is going to be some nonzero number of very upset users with just cause to be upset. That's just reality.
- mcv 6y agoSometimes it would be nice if you could pay extra to get better customer service. Especially when your income depends on it. In a case like this, I'd much rather pay the $50 to Google to make sure this gets fixed, than to the blackmailer. Of course that might create another incentive for Google not to provide any customer service at all until people pay.
- Applejinx 6y agoYup. Similarly, I'm now assuming the base Amazon shipping is 'pay ten-twenty bucks or so for super fast delivery, which will be about what the previous free shipping was'. Because since coronavirus, they claim to be so busy that normal stuff takes months: therefore, I don't think that will ever change. They will continue to have the free tier take months, making it more impractical and motivating the choice of 'fast' shipping, and since it's a global change I figure they get to keep it (in practical terms).
- jotm 6y agoIf you're earning enough to afford a different, paid, hosting provider, yes you should definitely get it. But YouTube is still a platform you must be on if you care about expanding your viewership.
- Applejinx 6y agoThere's a problem in that: what if you're up against VC-backed silicon valley unicorns whose business case is to overgrow and obliterate anything else in their sector? In other words, if you can't afford to buy cars and hire drivers and comply with all regulations then don't compete with Uber. The missing part is, Uber intentionally cuts these things out of its business model so you can't… I guess it would be, drive for Uber until you can afford a real taxi medallion. Likewise, I think being a YouTuber you will NEVER be able to earn enough money that you can jump ship to a competing video service with better conditions, because no such service (?) exists at the scale and audience of YouTube, because YouTube runs at a substantial loss in order to completely own the market for non-trivial uses. That's valuable. How valuable? Stock market valuable: as in, people with money THINK it is valuable, and I don't think the reality has been well tested yet. We're still in the world where dominating and monopolizing is seen as super valuable, because of some immense perceived payback that you apparently get to do.