5 ms·
"All good engineering works on the principle of defence in depth." That line is as much a sound-bite at this point as anything you'll hear on cable television.
by timr 16y ago
"All good engineering works on the principle of defence in depth."
That line is as much a sound-bite at this point as anything you'll hear on cable television. Yes, good engineering has many levels of fall-backs and redundancies. But when you've reached the point that you've evacuated the last fifty people from your site because it's no longer safe for them to be there, then you've exhausted your defenses. There's no more depth.
Let's stop whistling past the graveyard: a meltdown is, in fact, a really big deal. Maybe the "wide concrete tray" will capture the waste. Maybe it won't. But in the meantime, you're hoping that there's not a secondary fire from the heat, or a steam explosion, or some other kind of explosion that flings radioactive particulate for miles around. You're hoping that the fuel won't melt, form a critical mass in the bottom of the reactor, and re-initiate a reaction that's hard to stop. You're hoping that the containment doesn't breach, and that vast quantities of radioactive waste aren't exposed to the elements before the whole system calms down again. You're hoping that the whole system calms down again.
The point is: they've lost control. The 'engineering' that they're doing right now is desperate and hacky, and they're very nearly out of options. It might be comforting to pretend that this whole thing is scripted out on some intricate Japanese checklist somewhere, but that's really nothing more than a fantasy. I certainly hope that things aren't as bad as they sound, but this isn't just a matter of bad PR by some pessimistic, nuclear-energy skeptics. These guys are actually in trouble.
- cperciva 16y agoMaybe the "wide concrete tray" will capture the waste. Maybe it won't. Maybe the laws of physics will change, but I'd be willing to bet that they won't. But in the meantime, you're hoping that there's not a secondary fire from the heat Concrete doesn't burn. or a steam explosion At the point when the nuclear fuel melts, all the water has boiled off 1000 degrees ago. or some other kind of explosion that flings radioactive particulate for miles around. Explosions don't just happen for no reason. You're hoping that the fuel won't melt, form a critical mass in the bottom of the reactor, and re-initiate a reaction that's hard to stop. Nuclear reactors don't hold enough fuel to form a critical mass. In order to become critical, they need a moderator (usually water) which thermalizes neutrons.
- marshray 16y agoSure the laws of physics don't change. But the state of this complex system is way way out of understood and explored space at this point. http://www.digitalglobe.com/downloads/featured_images/japan_earthquaketsu_fukushima_daiichi1_march16_2011_dg.jpg http://www.digitalglobe.com/downloads/featured_images/japan_... This game was out of the playbook from the beginning, as soon as all the batteries and backup generators failed.
- timr 16y ago"Maybe the laws of physics will change, but I'd be willing to bet that they won't." There's absolutely nothing about the "laws of physics" that guarantees that this particular reactor design is going to be able to contain a full meltdown, because it's never happened before. Nobody knows. "Concrete doesn't burn." No one said it did. There's plenty of other stuff around that does burn readily, which is why the plant is currently on fire. A lot of that stuff is radioactive. "Explosions don't just happen for no reason." Indeed. But red-hot piles of radioactive waste are a good way of making explosions happen, particularly when there's lots of hydrogen gas floating around from the breakdown of the cooling water and the fuel. That's why there have been several explosions at the plant. "Nuclear reactors don't hold enough fuel to form a critical mass. In order to become critical, they need a moderator (usually water) which thermalizes neutrons." You're assuming an intact core. Criticality is a function of density, shape and temperature, in addition to mass. Melt the fuel rods, and the guarantees of that nice, well-moderated behavior are off. In general, you're making lots of simplistic assumptions about a nicely behaved, engineered, controlled system. What they've got now is far messier. Moreover, a lot of the stuff that you're saying can't happen, is actually happening right now. The reality of the situation trumps your theories of the situation, however confident.
- jellicle 16y agoIt's a shame that cperciva's nonsense is being modded up. > "Nuclear reactors don't hold enough fuel to form a critical mass." Come on. Each reactor core holds over 100 tons of uranium, of which about 3-5 tons is U-235. Critical mass under perfect conditions is 50 kilograms. Conditions are not perfect for forming a critical mass, but you've got 100 times as much U-235 as is strictly necessary, and there is no fucking way of knowing what will happen when an entire reactor core melts and flows together, because no one has ever been stupid enough to try it. Chernobyl experienced a criticality event, and there is absolutely no guarantee that Fukushima will not. Moreover, each reactor has a spent fuel pool with five times as much fuel in it as the reactor itself has. And no containment vessel. And no water being supplied. And when the water boils away from those pools, and that fuel melts and flows together...
- adsr 16y agoTotally agree with this, it reminds me of impenetrable software and unsinkable ships.
- timinman 16y agoExactly, the bottom line is were playing with nuclear reactions and hoping everything goes as planned. It's arrogance.
- lurch_mojoff 16y agoAs is every technological and scientific achievement humankind has ever reached and is relying upon. Replace nuclear reactions with, say, human flight and your statement remains just as valid. I don't see many people crying out for abolishment of planes, though.
- moe 16y agoI don't see many people crying out for abolishment of planes, though. I think there's a tiny difference between a plane falling out of the sky and a nuclear reactor melting down. I'm sure you can spot it, too, if you think long and hard.
- NickPollard 16y agoThe plane falling happens a lot more often?
- moe 16y agoAre you serious? According to [1] roughly 15k people died in plane accidents over the past decade. It doesn't seem unreasonable to assume that Chernobyl killed many more than that. Furthermore a nuke meltdown renders a large area uninhabitable and leaves an economic footprint "slightly" bigger than a few planes coming down every year. Quote from [2] (page 33): Coping with the impact of the disaster has placed a huge burden on national budgets. In Ukraine, 5–7 percent of government spending each year is still devoted to Chernobyl-related benefits and programmes. In Belarus, government spending on Chernobyl amounted to 22.3 percent of the national budget in 1991, declining gradually to 6.1 percent in 2002. Total spending by Belarus on Chernobyl between 1991 and 2003 is estimated at more than US $13 billion. Other Quote (same page): Belarus, for instance, has estimated the losses over 30 years at US $235 billion. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aviation_accidents_and_incidents#Aircraft_Crashes_Record_Office_.28ACRO.29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aviation_accidents_and_incident... [2] http://www.iaea.org/Publications/Booklets/Chernobyl/chernobyl.pdf http://www.iaea.org/Publications/Booklets/Chernobyl/chernoby...