8 ms·
I can see worrying about harassment. "Inclusivity", though? (From the tone of the press release, they mean race and gender, not article subjects.) Wikipedia edi
by Animats 6y ago
I can see worrying about harassment. "Inclusivity", though?
(From the tone of the press release, they mean race and gender, not article subjects.) Wikipedia editors are anonymous unless they don't want to be. How can anyone tell?
- thomasqm 6y agoI do not read anything relating inclusivity to demographics. I think they are just discouraging ignorance of other editors.
- IAmEveryone 6y agoInclusivity of editors is a major factor for inclusivity of content. Different demographics have different interests, experiences, and knowledge. It's trivially obvious that getting a broader subset of society to contribute will also broaden the content. With less than 10% of editors being women, for example, content is guaranteed to be somewhat skewed, even assuming absolutely no ill will by anybody. Among the famous examples are a scientist's entry being deleted as "not notable" just weeks before she won the Nobel Prize. Or, if you prefer quantitative data, that articles about women tend to emphasise their relationships and children (https://arxiv.org/pdf/1501.06307v2.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1501.06307v2.pdf).
- ed25519FUUU 6y agoI think you’re right here though. For example, the staggering amount of Japanese-centric pages on enwiki shows how the interest of a monoculture can have an outsized impact on the community. But at the same time, why not the free content?
- luckylion 6y ago> Different demographics have different interests, experiences, and knowledge. It's trivially obvious that getting a broader subset of society to contribute will also broaden the content. Wikipedia wants to be an encyclopedia though, not a bag of personal anecdotes and life experiences.
- SiempreViernes 6y agoLook at you go, immediately discarding everything that other persons could contribute on the sole basis that it would be content from people different from yourself, true meritocracy in action!
- hoseja 6y agoAnd yet, they're also right.
- luckylion 6y agoYou're misunderstanding what I wrote. Wikipedia very clearly states that they don't want original research even, much less original experiences and feelings. If you stay with the Wikipedia guidelines, a "diverse team of editors" could shift the areas of focus a bit (both within articles and on what articles get worked on), but the content should largely remain the same. They want to provide well-sourced information, present the major thoughts where no consensus is visible and do it in a way that every reader can go to the sources and check it. If you want more representation of $group on Wikipedia, you'll do much better by publishing more work of $group's members so that it can be cited and quoted on Wikipedia. Just having them on Wikipedia doesn't/shouldn't work, it's not a news paper where somebody may set the topics/angles to be covered.
- SiempreViernes 6y agoSo the reason "programming pattern" has more effort put into it relative "knitting pattern" is the lack of written sources about knitting?
- luckylion 6y agoI don't know "the reason", but I find "knitting pattern" to be pretty hard to write a lot about in an encyclopedic context while limiting it to exactly that term. The article as is gives a general outline of what a knitting pattern is. I'm afraid that might trigger you, but I do believe that explaining what a programming pattern is is actually much harder than explaining what a knitting pattern is, as it's much more abstract. And, of course, remember that the article isn't about "knitting", it's about "knitting patterns", so you'd need sources that concern themselves with knitting patterns _as a subject_ and not with individual knitting patterns. There are very detailed articles about knitting, there's an article about common knitting abbreviations (which I don't believe fits into an encyclopedia, but whatever), there's plenty of other stuff about knitting. What did you want to see on an article about knitting patterns? And, as a follow-up, why haven't you added that to the article about knitting patterns?
- rmrfstar 6y agoI know this is weak medicine, but Wiki is CC licensed. That means it can be forked if it turns out they are doing more than protecting people from harassment. For now let's give them the benefit of the doubt. It also has public change logs, so it is easy to have a debate about the presence/absence of censorship.
- etrabroline 6y ago>requires that any derivative of works from Wikipedia must be released under that same license, must state that it is released under that license, and must acknowledge the contributors (which can be accomplished with a link back to that article on Wikipedia). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Mirrors_and_forks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Mirrors_and_forks Looks like you're right. Forking Wikipedia is pretty easy from a licensing perspective.
- 6510 6y agoI like how cc requires making the materials available but it is served as a giant multi TB turd mostly made up of cruft. (think: custom templates) It is also funny how people seem to think anonymous users who cant be identified own copyright to anything. WP has refused to set up a proper identification process. 2 angry alcoholics > nobel laureate A [shame] link back to wp? why? They don't own the rights and they are not a reliable host for crediting sources. If WP vanishes you are still obligated to name the authors. (who have no name or address) The idea is of course nice. It would be more fun if one could easily export a category in various popular formats.
- Udik 6y agoForking Wikipedia is practically unfeasible without a huge organizational effort. And will probably result in loss of credibility of both branches. The public logs are there since ever, so does the censorship (some amount of it).
- crocodiletears 6y agoAre there db dumps available with article edit histories? I know that there are article backups you can download, but I don't know the limits or extents of those archives.
- Pinegulf 6y agoAnonymous editors lose by default. 'I'm group X so my opinion trumps yours.'
- zozbot234 6y ago> Wikipedia editors are anonymous unless they don't want to be. How can anyone tell? Anonymity and privacy are of course highly helpful but editors should be free to disclose facts about themselves if they so choose. I think we can all agree that incivility and harassment can be a major issue in such cases.
- luckylion 6y agoOn the other hand, I don't think Wikipedia editors should ever disclose facts about themselves. Ideally, you want anonymized contributions to ensure that the contribution is actually correct and correctly sourced and isn't just "waved through" because others recognize the name of the editor, or because they've said that they are Professor Xyz.
- Shivetya 6y agoThe reason to reveal though is used to bolster the contribution by allowing them to declare any edit they do not approve of to be based on their identity rather than the facts of the article. This is very common method and actually presented in writing as how to take over any system. You deny a voice to others by presenting the claim that any opposition is based wholly on identity issues.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- SiempreViernes 6y agoBy choice of topics primarily? Wikipedia has some severe biases when it comes to what and who counts as notable. For instance, you can compare ”programming pattern” and ”knitting pattern” and try to guess which is a 50 year practice and which is as old as civilization... That sort of topic bias is best solved by adding new contributors, but they will intrinsically have to be different sorts of persons, and historically that difference has caused issues for the newcomers: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/08/us/wikipedia-harassment-wikimedia-foundation.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/08/us/wikipedia-harassment-w...
- Udik 6y agoThen you need to establish strict(er) notability guidelines. The approach, tone, use of sources, etc. should be exactly the same when writing about design patterns and knitting patterns (actually, I have the feeling pages about knitting patterns will be much more sound and factual than those about design patterns- but that's only a specific case...).
- roenxi 6y agoThe last edit to the Knitting article at the time of writing is 24 September 2019, and the page doesn't seem to have any sort of edit protection enabled. I'm confident Wikipedia's policies aren't the major issue holding back a flood of knitting-oriented contributors. The people involved in knitting probably just aren't heavy internet users. As for the lurking culture war and worrying about the word 'inclusivity' it is hard to imagine a less important issue. Wikipedia is one of the most structurally democratic organisations on the entire planet, and possibly the knowledge accumulating enterprise most resistant to social pigeonholing of its members. Even I could literally copy their software and content and rehost the whole thing if I don't like how the project is run. The Wikimedia Foundation can do whatever it thinks is best; good luck to them. There is no reasonable problem here, even for the paranoid.
- ponker 6y agoKnitters are huge Internet users they just mostly use Ravelry.com instead of Wikipedia.
- truthwhisperer 6y agoJust a marketing term. Wikipedia/media should focus on objective output; not the millennial shit talks like inclusivity etc.
- DavidVoid 6y ago> "Inclusivity", though? ... Wikipedia editors are anonymous unless they don't want to be. Having more diverse editors will lead to more diverse content. Wikipedia pages of female scientists tend to get a lot more scrutiny than ones about male scientists [1]. There's another anecdote about moderator bias and some decent discussion on the issue overall in this thread [2]. Ultimately there are some issues Wikipedia can't solve since they are just a reflection of the rest of society in many ways. "We can't write about this scientist and her work because no one else has written about her," is a problem that Wikipedia can't solve by themselves. [1] https://www.chemistryworld.com/news/female-scientists-pages-keep-disappearing-from-wikipedia-whats-going-on/3010664.article https://www.chemistryworld.com/news/female-scientists-pages-... [2] https://old.reddit.com/r/TwoXChromosomes/comments/ekv3te/female_scientists_pages_keep_disappearing_from/fdeainf/ https://old.reddit.com/r/TwoXChromosomes/comments/ekv3te/fem...
- luckylion 6y ago> Having more diverse editors will lead to more diverse content. Can you elaborate what content you'd expect to see more of if the editors were "more diverse"? This gets thrown around a lot here, but nobody actually says what exactly they mean. There are more than six million articles on the English Wikipedia. What would change, which topics would get more, which would get less attention if Wikipedia editors were swapped out to represent their attributed groups (along some axes; most likely gender and broad ethnicity, I'm guessing, but not social status or education) of the American society at large?
- DavidVoid 6y agoIt's pretty simple. If there were more Norweigan editors then I'd expect to see more content about things that are "notable" within Norweigan history and culture. Replace Norweigan with African American, female, etc. and you'll see how having more diverse editors would lead to more diverse content.
- luckylion 6y ago> If there were more Norweigan editors then I'd expect to see more content about things that are "notable" within Norweigan history and culture. Like what though? Here's [1] the Portal on Norway, there are hundreds of articles on Norway and Norwegian culture. From what I can see, the Norwegian Wikipedia does not cover Norway that much more, even though you can reasonably expect that it's primarily authored by Norwegians. There are fewer but still hundreds of pages about e.g. Zimbabwe, its history, culture, politics, demographics etc. I fail to see what's being not presented there. I understand the concern that it may be too USA-centered, and to a small degree it probably is, but I don't believe it's anywhere near the proportions it's made out to be, and I don't believe that it would significantly shift, because it's absolutely not a special interest community that covers only their ideas. And given that the US is the lone super power right now, militarily, culturally and economically, it is to be expected that it is very well covered, even in other language versions. It's somewhat important to everyone on earth how the US works. It's less important how Liechtenstein or Lesotho are organized, and either has their own history, but their history isn't strongly intertwined with recent world history. The super vast majority are articles that are global (in any and all meanings) in nature, explaining scientific concepts and history. You may argue that, since Wikipedia's goal is to represent the common consensus of scientists that these topics would be different if e.g. Zimbabwe had been the world's super power for the last 70 years, and I partially agree, but far from completely. We'd see a lot more information about Zimbabwean wild life, nature and environment, but we'd still see articles on lasers, genetics, space travel, the history of Arabic numerals, because there's really no reason to believe that Zimbabwean scientists wouldn't have looked into these things etc. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Portal:Norway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Portal:Norway
- dusted 6y agoProblem with inclusivity is that it becomes murky emotional stuff real fast. "I'm triggered by the color orange, HN is SOO exclusive towards me because I cannot STAND that color, and as long as anyone dares post links to pages with orange, or that disgusting orange is used anywhere on the page, I cannot participate (checks diagnoses)"
- Shivetya 6y agoInclusivity, because you can then lay claim any dispute of facts of an article are instead a dispute that only exists because one side is bigoted, racist, or other such nonsense, and actually only disagrees because they do not accept the person posting the disputed fact. It is one of the main methods of cancel culture, by portraying any disagreement as based in identity differences there can be no functional discussion of the facts at hand
- shadowgovt 6y ago> bigoted, racist, or other such nonsense Can you clarify how one side or another in a discussion being bigoted or racist is nonsense?
- 0-_-0 6y agoThe claim that it's bigoted or racist is nonsense, not being bigoted or racist.
- shadowgovt 6y agoI don't think I follow. Can you provide an example of such a discussion that has happened?
- 0-_-0 6y agoIn general? I guess a good example would be transgender athletes. This is a controversial subject but a reasonable argument can be made that people who grew up with higher levels of testosterone have an unfair advantage over people who didn't. This concern is often dismissed as bigotry. This fits the above description that said "portraying any disagreement as based in identity differences there can be no functional discussion of the facts at hand"
- shadowgovt 6y agoThank you. I think that's a good example. For instance, I don't think I understand why people would want to ban those who were born identifying male from athletics because they have more testosterone than those born identifying female. Clearly, if the hormone levels are the issue, they should just sample the hormones of athletes at some point in their developmental process and ban anyone with too much testosterone from the womans' events, regardless of their gender identity. Identify as a woman but your testosterone levels are outside 1-sigma from average at 13? Sorry; doesn't matter if you were born a woman and have always thought of yourself as a woman, you're banned from Olympic Women's Pole Vault for life.
- shadowgovt 6y agoThis policy also governs face-to-face meetings, where online anonymity does not apply.
- andruby 6y agoHere’s what they mean by inclusivity. Right now the large majority of authors/editors on wikipedia are caucasian men from richer western countries. This causes an inherit bias in wikipedia’s content. Wikimedia rightly would like the authors to be an unbiased representative sample of society if it wants to be a representative encyclopedia (do se still use that word?) I visited wikimedia’s HQ almost a decade ago. Back then they were trying to solve this problem by making the editor more approachable.